Nice Guys Pizza, Beer, and Cocktails

More than a Pizza place; it’s an upscale dive bar with ponies, pinball, great food and excellent cocktails. They also book great bands and the bar tenders are awesome! By far, one of the best bars in FLA! The vibe is outstanding!

Wish I lived walking distance to Nice Guys! Great pizza, great beer, great service, great bands (The Electric Mud and 20 Watt Tombstone), great sound! Will look for every opportunity to go again.

My visit to Nice Guys Pizza was nothing short of fantastic. I went with my wife and mother-in-law, and we all had an amazing time from start to finish. The atmosphere of the place was vibrant and unique, with a mix of modern and retro elements that made it stand out from your typical pizza joint. One of the highlights for us was the pinball machines—such a fun touch! We played a few rounds while waiting for our food, which made the experience even more enjoyable. Now, let’s talk about the food—because that’s what really made this place special. We ordered the hot garlic Parmesan wings, a large pepperoni pizza, and garlic knots, and everything exceeded our expectations. The wings were absolutely delicious—crispy on the outside, juicy on the inside, and coated in a flavorful garlic Parmesan sauce that had just the right amount of heat. The pizza was exactly what you’d want from a top-tier pizza place: a perfectly cooked crust that was crisp yet chewy, a well-balanced layer of sauce and cheese, and generous amounts of pepperoni. Every bite was a delight. The garlic knots were a perfect side, warm, fluffy, and bursting with buttery garlic flavor. Beyond the food and atmosphere, the service was great. The staff was friendly, attentive, and made sure we had everything we needed. Even though the place was busy, we never felt rushed or ignored. It’s always nice to see a restaurant that balances quality food with great service and a fun, welcoming environment. Overall, Nice Guys Pizza is more than just a place to grab a bite—it’s an experience. Whether you’re a pizza lover, a pinball enthusiast, or just looking for a great spot to hang out with family and friends, this place has it all. We’ll definitely be back for more!

I had an excellent experience. Great vibe, the pizza was awesome and the vegan menu is super cool. Vegan pepperoni with onion and pineapple. If I lived near this place, it would easily be a weekly haunt for me. I highly recommend trying this place!

Great atmosphere if you don't need to talk, there for music night, which was nice. some good bands some bad. Had the Big Mick Pizza. This is their play on a big mac. Only thing I can say is "where's the beef"? Apparently you have to ask for extra meat and extra sauce. good late night bar food but also was mediocre at the same time. Some great drinks, but definitely a niche crowd style location reminds me of the niche mediocre fad college bars and restaurants i used to frequent until I learned what true quality was.

Great Pizza. We had a split of the hot and honey Pizza, along with the my cousin Vinny Pizza atmosphere is fantastic. Good vibes. A must stop if you're in this area of Fort Myers.

Went to drag brunch. We also had the thanksgiving special pizza last November. All 3 of the pizzas and the special biscuits and gravy were incredible. The thanksgiving pizza and the chicken and waffles pizza are some of the most genius ideas ever. The drag show was amazing especially since we were sat next to a lovely lady having the absolute time of her life which brought everyone's energy up. Bingo and the raffle were a great time.

Drag brunch bingo!!!! You don’t normally need reservations for Nice Guys but for this event you do need reservations. This is one of my favorite spots. Anytime we go there. It’s a great time so adding drag queens and bingo even more fun and all the food for brunch was amazing.

From Service, ambience to the food and drinks this place is great! Nothing like it in the Cape! We stopped here on our way home from Naples and I am so glad we did. The unique menu is delicious. We had the Chicken, Bacon Ranch, Prosciutto with hot honey and a Pb&j inspired pizza along with some unique cocktails and it was a 10 out of 10. I also really liked the "vibe". Eclectic and fun. It's definitely different than the norm in Cape and I loved everything about it! If you want to something fun and different this is the place!!

Updated review, we picked up several pizzas this weekend for a birthday celebration. I will clarify that I did not eat any pizza, but I did have their Man Salad. It looked great, lots of Italian meats and gorgonzola crumbled cheese. The greens were fresh and the To Go presentation was very nice. The downside was the requested salad dressing was not anywhere to be found. Dry salad is not very enjoyable, but luckily the home we went to had some salad dressing I could use. So, they went up a star at least.

Love the ambiance here. You will not find a place like this in Cape Coral! I love their tots with sauce flights. The pizzas are unique and the crust has a nice crisp but also a good texture. We tried the general tso pizza. Not my favorite pizza from Nice guys but still good. I love the hot honey pizza and their specialty pizzas. We will definitely be back to try more! The service was great! I wish I could remember her name she was so fun and great! Also back in December my friend had her baby shower in the back arcade room, they did a really nice job and it was fun to do a party there. Great service.

Retro 70's/80's vibe pizza place, open late, great specialty drinks & if you get a pizza try one of their signature pizzas & not just cheese & sausage type of thing. Always busy; crowd late is younger but being older we're always welcomed & service is amazing. A hidden gem in Cape Coral.

Staying in Sanibel / Ft Myers area and this was delivered to the hotel. It was actually kind of cold by the time it got here ( not the fault of the restaurant) but was still excellent. I eat a shiz ton of pizza, all over ... more than most people. I can tell that this was one outstanding pizza when it first came out of the oven. This was the Truffle Shuffle and I added ham. Try it !

They have a great selection of specialty pizzas and the pizzas are always delicious. I had been looking for authentic New York style pizza for years. So glad to finally try and love Nice Guys Pizza.

My friend and I really loved this place. This is not just a pizza joint! It is a very eclectic dive bar with some crazy decor as well. The pizza was fantastic. Our server was friendly and attentive, and the vibe overall was what we needed to end our weekend.

Nice Guys Pizza is such a fun place! The atmosphere was fun with great music, interesting decor (so much to look at!), and friendly people. I liked that they had interesting mocktails. Not sure if that's for Dry January or always on the menu, but I ordered the Santa mocktail, which had interesting ingredients (pumpkin and pistachio), and it was great! We ordered the fried cheese, which were unlike any mozzarella sticks I've had before. They looked more like French Toast sticks, but there was melted cheese inside, and they were very good. There were so many pizzas we wanted to try, but we went with the elote pizza, which was great! I love corn and elote flavors, which I would recommend if you order this pizza. It was a pizza base with marinara sauce and cheese, which then had corn and elote sauce drizzle on top. We definitely would want to come back next time we're in town!

October 2024 ~~ Awesome pizza place! The pizza, the drinks, the staff and the music was the bomb :) We got a pizza & wings & two drinks. Pizza - Washington Carver with peanut sauce, bacon, jam, mozzarella & provolone - loved every inch ! Also the Cajun Honey Butter BBQ wings - amazing . Drinks - Enemy Of Tradition Martini :)

Stopped into Nice Guys Pizza for a quick bite while visiting family in Cape Coral this past weekend. My fam loves this place, so my husband & I decided to give it a try. We were starving after a long day of driving and setting up for an event. It was a Saturday night, and while they were pretty busy, we were still able to be seated right away. It's nice to see that the Cape has gained some pretty cool local spots since I last lived here 14+ years ago. This place has a fun, eclectic vibe with quirky decor and colorful lights. Since the parking is behind the building, the main entrance is through the back where you're welcomed by bright neon murals in a black-lit hallway. Service was quick and I was happy to see some mocktail options on the menu. I started with the non-alcoholic negroni and the garlic knots. These are smaller than you're typical garlic knots, but they're served in a big generous pile with a side of marinara for dipping. They were super fluffy and delicious. We were sooo hungry and these really hit the spot. Their dough really seems to be the star of the show here. If you enjoy super soft, fluffy pizza crust, then you'll love their style of pizza. They have many unique signature pizza combinations, but we went with a more simple one -- the Hot Honey pizza which is topped with salami, prosciutto, garlic, tomato, and hot honey. Our eyes were certainly bigger than our stomachs in this moment because we ordered the medium 14" but the small would have been plenty for the 2 of us. Oh well, it made for great leftovers the next day!

Ughhh, I can't get over how much I love their pizzas to the point that it's annoying. The reason I say this is because Nice guys is a bit of a drive for us, about 45 mins. Which when you're crazy their pizza for a solid week in the middle season is not a great thing. This place is open late which makes it a great hang out with friends. They have a craft cocktail list that has some signature drinks they keep year round but also ones they change out seasonally. It always fun to see what new offering they have and the staff does a great job making suggestions based on what prefers you give them. Now for the pizza, don't be boring and just get a plain pizza or a pepperoni here. Be adventurous, they have fun pizzas that might seem weird at first but are amazing. They got a wide variety of specialty pizza. If you're stuck between two, depending on the combo they can do half and half pizzas. One of my absolute favorites is the Washington carver. It is made with peanut sauce, bacon and even has a raspberry jam swirled on top. At first, that might sound gross but it absolutely amazing especially if you're a fan of pb and j sandwhichs. The sweetness of the jam is balanced perfectly with the nuttiness of the sauce and the salty saviory bacon. I never expected to love this pizza as much as I do. If the seasonal fruit on the black and gold is peaches that is my next go to. Definitely suggest stepping out of any pizza comfort zones and trying any of their special pizzas!

the food is awesome! I really don't like how dark the vibe is but love that they have an outdoor area & it looks like they are building onto that too!

The restaurant is so fun, full of art on the walls, the servers were SO nice, and our food didn't take long. My food was amazing, I got the vegan wings and vegan blue cheese My partner and friends obsessed over their "crunchy on the outside, melt in your month inside" wings, the garlic knots they were dying over, and the pizzas were fire! This place is a must try

Their crust is amazing and pizza menu has unique toppings. They charge way too much for "build your own" toppings though. Service is super friendly.

Nice guys is hands down one of the most intriguing restaurants in all of Cape Coral. Their interior design, specifically for the holidays was elaborate and just so well done. Their drinks are top notch and always themed. Their apps and pizzas are amazing as well. We started with the cool ranch tots and received SIX dipping sauces! Most homemade! Highly recommend nice guys to anyone willing to make the drive.

Another bartender recommended this place in Cape Coral, so we decided to give it a try. Visually entertaining, good rock music, great service and delicious food. We had a meat lover's pizza. Pizza was hot with a lot of yummy toppings. Tried one of their delicious cocktails created by Zach, called Enemy of Tradition - a coffee martini with Parmesan foam. It was delicious and had wonderful coffee flavor. Conversation with Zach and Frampy was fun and interesting. We will be back to try more pizza topping combinations and more creative cocktails. This place is a great find.

You say you're looking for great pizza and mixologist quality drinks? This place has got both. With a cool "retro-hippy" vibe, plenty of space, great for larger groups too, pinball, and even trivia night! Who could ask for more! We always bring company and friends here for the great atmosphere.

Such a cool place, all about the vibes!! There's so much to look at and I love the black lights. The cocktail menu is also very cool. I got a gingery cocktail because they make their own ginger beer, VERY gingery too much for me but still good. I'd try a different cocktail next time. We also got the ranch tots, a pepperoni pizza and I got the bao buns platter. Hmmmmm go for the cocktails/beer and the tots. The pizza was insanely greasy and you couldn't even hold it and is that type of pizza, not my preference. I also thought the bao buns themselves were good but all the fillings lacked flavor, especially the meat. I'd still come back a million times over because this place is just so cool!! Friendly and fast service.

Loved the vibe, the service, great drinks and tasty pizza. As New Yorkers, we prefer a dough that's less doughy and a bit more crisp but we will return.

Placed an order order ended up being wrong when I called, the manager told me it wasn't their problem because I went through a third-party. Which you can only go through a third-party, so that takes the blame off of the company . don't order from these guys because they make you do it online and then they screw it up and they're not responsible for it. Paid $30 for a medium cheese pizza, which I didn't order a cheese pizza.

Best pizza ever!! I love to go there because the vibe is really cool. Everyone is really nice. I have tried the 'Some Like it hot', the spicy garlic parm wings, and corn dogs. All have been consistently good. The only one I didn't like was the chicken pizza masala because it lacked flavor.

Amazing pizza!!! The crust is so light and airy! The sausage is the best that I've ever tasted!

Food: the mesquite honey butter BBQ wings had just the right amount of tangy zest mixed a smokey sweetness. Nice and crunchy outer texture. So good that I ate 6 and took the other 6 home. Service: my bar guy was busy but I'm not blaming. He got to me as soon as he could. His humor was sarcastic but in good nature. Ie I asked him what was better: the pizza or the wings. To which he said..neither. followed with: both are great. Ambiance: dark light lit. Very eclectic. Pop culture references through out. Back wall had paintings of sloths and portraits of rpg dice as heads on torsos. The room next door was a row of pin ball machines. Best part..they have pinball league that one can sign up for and participate in tournaments. Price wise id say ranges from average to moderately expensive. Ie my Nitro butter beer was $12. The wings were $16 for 12. So tonight's meal came to $31 n some change. Minor dislike: I was only allowed 1 flavor for the 12 wings. I wish I could have done half n half. The somewhat of an offer to that was ordering them naked ( keeping my clothes on of course) and getting 2 sauces on the side.

Waitress was lovely and helpful!! Ordered - Garlic knots Buffalo wings Hot honey pizza - pictured! Smash!, golden girl, PUFF

The place is dark and dingy as were the bartenders. Our bartender was really nice though. They have lots of odd pizzas that you wouldn't think to put together but are delicious. We ordered the My Cousin Vinny which was very tasty but very salty. We also ordered the garlic knots which were soo good but their marinara sauce needed a little bit more flavor. It's a cool spot. We may check it out again.

WOW is all I have to say. I crave pizza at least once a week and I've been searching high and low for the best spot. I have mainly seen NY style pizza offerings or brick oven pizza offerings in my area but nothing like Nice Guys Pizza. Was the final desecration pizza the best pizza I've ever had in my life with the right amount of crunch, spice, ranch, chicken, crust? YES. Did the time of day impact this conclusion? Possibly, but I assure you, you do not have to be drinking for this pizza to be out of this world. Bonus points that they stay open until 1:30am. I saw someone getting a takeout pizza at 1:25am. We came in with a large group and many others got different options like the Margarita Pizza and although it was good, if you're even considering #22, JUST DO IT! The drinks are also fire. They put a lot of love into their old fashioned and our crew really enjoyed our time here on our 40th bday bar crawl. We will 100% be back. I will say the bartenders were a bit busy on a crowded Friday night so the service was slow, but it was worth it! The overall ambiance is moody, dark, eclectic, dive bar vibes. Even the bathroom is dimly lit with dark red and black decor. I actually dug it. I liked that no one could see the sauce running down my face and my lipstick smeared due to devouring my pizza!

Good food, good service, very different vibe from most other places in the region. It's a hipster-ey spot, with funky murals, black lights, loud music, and a bank of pinball machines. It's a fun place, haven't really been to any other places like this since moving to town. The pizzas are interesting and tasty (not traditional, think stuff like prosciutto, peppers, and hot honey). They have vegan options too, which is nice. The wings were also very good. And whoa, the fried Oreos are really good (more like Oreo donuts really). We sat outside because the inside was packed and we didn't want to wait. Next time, I'd opt for indoors, at least at night. The outdoor space is right on a busy road and it wasn't quite as fun as it seemed indoors. But outside might be better if you have a large group.

A funky place, but for me the food fell short. The Man salad was a generous portion and technically I suppose it did have Gorgonzola cheese on it. There was a decent amount of prosciutto ((it looked like it anyway) and the dressing was not memorable. Ok, maybe the pizza will be ok. I'm kind of a pizza snob. The pizza crust was soft, not soggy. There was no crunch or crispy crust. Reminded me of a Domino's crust. The sauce was a bit lacking in flavor, but the pepperoni was ok. Maybe their specialty pizzas are good. The share looks unusual. I would never think to put honey on a pizza. If you are looking for a good traditional pizza, look elsewhere. Good service and a lot of interesting beers.

What a cool place! I love the throw back vibe. The menu is extensive and includes an assortment of vegan foods. I cannot wait to go back and try more options. We did the Brie pizza which was loaded with arugula and garlics. So so yummy. Our server was great and super nice. We tried to order the special appetizer and they had just run out. She could t have apologies more.

Very good experience. Delicious pizza and appetizers. Drinks were also awesome. Service was quick and helpful, and turnaround from the kitchen was very good as well, we did not wait long for our food. They don't allow kids to go in after 9, and I agree, as the scene feels more bar like as is gets late, but at 5(ish) the place is great for family and friends. Definitely recommend, and will return.

Love it! Such fun pizza! Don't come here for your average pizza, come here for a super fun pizza! The Heart Attack is so freakin tasty, omg! And the dessert pizza...sooooo good!

The place had a cool look going on and they had decent music playing but it sucked to have the concert venue side also playing music, so two songs were playing so we couldn't hear either of them. Also the garlic knots came out undercooked, the middle was complete raw, we kind of thought it was cheese with how stretchy it was but it wasn't.... Food took very long to come out and the pizza was a bit much for the price, We had a signature small pizza ($20) the pizza was 5/10. Servers were nice but they should really let us know that all servers are there for everyone because it was very confusing when our first server didn't come back and just walked around us but thankfully other two servers walking around approached us and we just stuck with the server that seemed more attentive, I'm not sure how the tipping goes like if it's a tip pool or what but hopefully our server got her tip. Update: the raw dough eaten from the garlic knots has significantly hurt our digestive system, we won't be coming back for a second visit.

I don't know what the hell you guys are putting in the bread, but please never stop. The flavor of these pizzas absolutely slaps my sweet tender little tastebuds to a magical realm of perfectly cooked proteins and house made sauces. If they have a pizza that you think sounds weird, grow up and order it anyways. I'm sitting here eating a piece of microwave nice guys pizza I bought last night, and this is still absolutely better even the second day than ANY other pizza I've ever had fresh

Attentive and very pleasant staff. Great selection of beers and craft cocktails. Pizza selections are wild but tasty and different. Great spot.

Great pizza restaurant. They have a separate vegan menu with some well thought out options. We got the pretzel bites appetizer and both of us absolutely loved it. We also got a general Gaos pizza and it was also really tasty. Great vibe along with great food! If you are a plant based eater head here.

Wow! What an amazing place. Fantastic pizza and beer. We shared the Washington Carver (a PB & J pizza - sounds gross but it's delicious) which we get every time we visit Cape Coral

OMG, what a gem!! Most eclectic creative pizza/food/cocktail menu I've encountered so far in Fort Myers/Cape Coral. I don't know what it is about some of these places in the Cape, they are passionate about their booze. Passionate about their food, reminds me of the science mixologist food/chefs of Portland. The place is gothic, funky, clean-grungy vibe, loved it. Will definitely come back. Only had the Hummus ( very tasty) and a drink, a cucumber lime rosemary gin concoction that was bomb! Can't wait to try their dynamic, creative and explosive menu, which also offer GF crust and healthier options. Xoxo Oh, and unisex bathrooms were cool, just sayin. Unless the pizza slices on the door indicated male or female. I just happened to go inside the one with the Mick Jagger urinal lmao!!

The family went to pick up pizzas while they waited. They had a drink. They really love the atmosphere. They said it was very cozy. The food which was about five pizzas. All different styles were 100% amazing. Highly recommend this place but I would say dine in versus takeout. Not that the food is different but there's so much to see and do there.

Fun experience. I always enjoy the experience, this quirky weird little spot has good pie, cold beer and great service. Nice way to spend an evening... bring friends

Came to Nice Guys to play pinball and it was so fun!! One of the machines was broken but we got our money back. A server came up and asked us what drinks we wanted and i ordered a beer on draft and she said she would check to see if they were out, she never came back for 25 min and another server took our food order. Then I saw her again and asked and she said they don't have it. The other server who got our food order said they did and dropped it off in 1 min...As a bartender I was slightly annoyed, but overall a great atmosphere and experience w the pinball!!!

I went to Nice Guys Pizza with my fiancé for dinner and we had a good time. Their service was great as well as their atmosphere. We ordered their hummus appetizer, which was served with pita bread and red pepper jam. We both agreed that it was delicious. We then ordered a couple of pizzas and were delighted about how tasty they both were. I ordered the Freaks And Greeks Pizza and my fiancé ordered the Big Mick Pizza. Both Very Delicious! They had a decent craft beer selection, but they wouldn't allow any tasting of beers so you know what you would like, which was disappointing. Overall though, great experience! Can't wait to return to try more of their unique kinds of pizzas!

Amazing Crust on the pizza so good. We had a few different pizzas and will definitely go back.

Still great. The funyuns are off the menu right now (sniff sniff) which is a bummer, but the tots are great. The stinky buns are awesome and the cocktails....well those are the star of this place. The sign outside says pizza and beer but the cocktails are the best in Cape Coral. The pizza is unique and delicious. Always a good time.

If you love the 80s and great pizza you have to check out Nice Guys Pizza in the Cape! Last night my husband and I took our two teenage daughters and we all had a great experience. There is indoor and outdoor seating available, we recommend inside so you can enjoy all of the vintage decor! All of the staff is friendly and the service was excellent. We had wings, pepperoni pizza, General Tso's pizza, and a hot honey pizza- all of which we would order again. We finished our visit playing pinball. This place is a local gem and must try!

I went to nice guys because I got recommended by a friend that I met in the area. He told me about their pizza when I got there the place is like a club at night very dark music and people not a family friendly place

This place is perfect: fun, weird, clean, big, not too crowded and oh...amazing pizza! We've gotten a few different pizzas including one with ranch and fried chicken, and one with chorizo. Both were to die for. I've wanted to try the wings and am told they are incredible. Absolutely love the mezcal old fashioned. Great beer selections from everywhere. Place is a must!

We had Vegan pizza and cauliflower wings both were delicious I would recommend and we're going back soon! Did carry out!

The food was amazing we got the truffle pizza, and the my cousin Vinny and it was delicious. The drinks were also amazing, we will be back! The service was nice too, the girl forgot her name was sweet.

YUM- I'm not a big pizza fan, I was when I was growing up in Chicago and as I've moved my relationship with Pizza has been complicated. So if I write a review it's truly because I enjoyed the Pizza. Nice guys Pizza is a fave now. First off the space is cool and has a darker vibe, my rocker emo side loved it. There normally is a bit of wait but it's totally worth it. The food is great, they're known for their pizza and wings but we also enjoyed the Garlic Knots, they were so flavor full and out of this world. We ordered two types of pizza, a chicken buffalo and one with hot honey, both of them were so savory and delicious. the staff is welcoming and attentive. Will make sure to come back.