Nicky's Undefeated

Ordered a slice of cheese pizza and a Philly. The pizza was great and the Philly was okay. I paid $34 including the pizza, Philly, fries and 1 drink. I wish it was more seasoned and had some green peppers in it! The quality of the meat was great and the service was good too. Meat needs a little more flavor, but it was a lot of food and my kids liked it.

I grew up in Philly and New York, when I moved to Georgia I never thought I would find a taste of home down here. But that’s exactly what this place is. A bite straight out of Philly. The people are great, the vibe is amazing, the food is delicious. You won’t regret trying this place, unless you have no taste, then I can’t help you. 😂

The owner said they had to reorganize their marketing team and when they did they got several bad reviews. This is the second time I’ve had their sandwich and it’s the best cheesesteak I’ve found and I’ve been all over Atlanta. It beats Dave’s, Fred’s Meat and Bread and Woody’s. I used to frequent Philly and I would put this sandwich easily as one of the best I’ve ever had. If you come in they have big tvs and beer selection. I will be back. It’s great. The picture doesn’t do it justice this sandwich is FAT and the old bay fries are crispy crinkle cut and fantastic. I have already told my friends.

We’ve been looking for A place that sells good cheese steaks that taste as close to home as possible. People told us to try Big Daves it just didn’t win us over. 1 year later someone told us about Nicky’s. We thought it would be another place we wasted money on cheese steaks! Nope! I’m here to tell you, If you’re looking for an authentic cheese steak look no further! It was such a treat! We found our place! And they had water ice! Can’t wait until Football season. We have a new place to go! Thanks to the staff at Nicky’s! The Customer service was top tier! And they rang the bell. It felt like home! ((GO BIRDS!!!)) It was nice to meet you Walt! See you soon! We’ll be sending traffic!

Great spot! Had the beef wit (Philly for with onions), cooper cheese, seeded bun, and a roasted long hot pepper. Paired it with old bay fries and cheese dip and ended some Italian ice. Took me right back to eating in Philly. Only way to be more authentic would be if they yelled at me and the whole town smelled kinda funny (but I think we're all better off with the friendly staff and clean smell of Nicky's!). Highly recommend!

If I could give this place 100/5 stars, I would. I LOVE Nicky’s Undefeated!! I get the same thing every time: a cheesesteak with onions and cooper sharp cheese on a Liscio’s seeded roll…AMAZING. It has become my obsession! The staff is amazing (especially Kirsten, she is the sweetest!) and have been so kind to me since I started coming here. When the owner found out that I am moving to Philly soon, he surprised me complimentary water ice (so good and creamy), talked to me about the area, and gave me recommendations which I appreciate so much! The atmosphere is so fun and makes me feel like I am already connected to my soon-to-be new home. I love all the Philly facts that are on the table numbers and all the decorations that are unique to Philly. I had my first cheesesteak in February when I first visited Philly. When I got back to Atlanta, I knew I had to find a place to get cheesesteaks. I feel like I got that and so much more. Very thankful for the amazing food and welcoming community! This will be the one of the places that I miss most in Atlanta. Thank you guys!

I’m gonna start with the cheesesteak. It was to die for! The best I’ve ever had. The service was amazing. I believe the guy who brought my food out was the owner he was sooo nice. I got a large size one but it was so big so I took half of it home to my husband. We will definitely be back

Updated Review: After several friends claimed they had a fantastic sandwich, tried it again and this time it was spot on, very good philly. So make sure you either get cooper cheese or whiz,

As a recent transplant from the Philly area I had my trepidations but Nicky's blew them away. The Italian Hoagie the Philly Way and the Italian Roast Pork were fantastic. Making Nicky's a regular stop from now on!

My friend and I were looking for a low-key place to grab drinks and food on a Saturday afternoon. Nicky's Undefeated was the perfect place! They have something for everyone, including people like me who are dairy free. Violet was an excellent server/bartender. She was very sweet & friendly. We were greeted with a delicious scoop of complementary water ice. I ordered the buffalo chicken Philly with vegan cheese and a side of fries. I didn't love the cheese, but that's on me - not Nicky's. Our food was delivered smoking hot!! That's always a plus for me. My Kentucky mules were delicious. If you like a sweeter alcoholic drink, try the Lemonara. We swapped the vodka for tequila and... Chef's kiss! The restaurant was very cute! The decor is Philly inspired. There was a steady flow of customers, but it never felt over crowded or uncomfortable. Needless to say, we will be back!

Went in for the first time last week. Will absolutely be going back. First and foremost, the staff were all awesome from the cashier to the co-owner. Food was delicious, portions were much larger than I had expected. Prices feel slightly high looking at the menu but it's plenty of food for the money. The pretzel bites were awesome, my wife got the Impossible cheese steak and I got the buffalo chicken, both great. She also got a side of the Old Bay fries which were solid as well. The place was decently busy when we went in and even through the traffic, everything was very clean.

Very nice place. My server was very polite and the place was welcoming and clean. I ordered a Philly with American cheese. It was delicious. I would have liked peppers and more seasoning on the meat but the sandwich was good. I will definitely come back for another. The bread was fresh which is important and the sandwich wasn't greasy which is crucial to me. I love a Philly loaded with peppers and onions. (I love cherry peppers for some extra heat too) Another plus was the sweet tea. I love gold peak sweet tea.

Active casual sports bar type restaurant. I ordered a half of a Philly cheesesteak, fries and a drink that cost $20. It wasn't worth that at all. It should really cost about half but I'm assuming it's a small local business. My food was pretty bland so I probably wouldn't come again but the owner was super nice!

Had a great first visit here - the cheesesteaks were outstanding! Rib-eye with cooper cheese & grilled onions on seeded roll ....buffalo chicken cheesesteak was also solid. Fries were hot & well-seasoned. Very friendly service & food came out quick. Had some ice cream & a tiramisu for dessert. Great beer & cocktail selection. Lots of TVs on the wall to watch sports. We will definitely be back! Great addition to Main Street Tucker.

It was a bit of a drive for us to check out Nicky's undefeated the other weekend but I am happy we did. The steak sandwich is for side one of the best I have had in or outside of Philly.

I love this place, and come here often. Best cheese steak outside of the SE Pennsylvania area, and would give most of them a run for their money. I recommend the Founders Special, and a cold beer (or something tamer) and enjoy the ride. Great service, alway a line if you order walk up, and full of Philly ambiance. Love the addition of other PA beers besides Yuengling, although I would never stray from America's oldest brewery.

Tasty. Miss the peppers and onions. If you're looking for Philly style, I think this is the closest you'll get in Atlanta. Service was decent and the ambience is Sports Bar.

Very good lunch here today. We preferred the cheese steak over the Italian hoagie. We'll return & likely try the cheese steak egg rolls. Staff were all very nice. Wish we lived closer but it's prob best we don't for our waistlines ;-)

Watch repeats of the Eagles 2025 Super Bowl victory as you stuff yourself with a generous servings of cheesesteak and bay fries. Very northeast cheesesteak joiny feel to the place. No one will go away hungry.

On main street, with street parking Indoor large seating area with benches or stand alone tables Order at counter, get a number, food will be delivered at your table. Big menu with traditional hoagies and sub or fried chix style hoagies The portions are big and price reasonable Friendly and knowledgeable staff

Parking is a bit tight in front of the store but if you go around the block to the back, there might be more parking spots. Their cheesesteak is solid! Fresh hot melted cheese on proper cooked beef and good bread. Simply tasty. I do wish they have mushroom as an optional topping but that doesn't affect the quality of the cheesesteak. They have a window for togo order if you don't want to dine in. You can also just walk in and place the order for to go. The restaurant is nice and clean. The staffs are friendly and helpful. I will try the ice cream the next time i stop by. Definitely should give it a try if you're in the area!

First walked in and I thought I was over priced then I got my food and my eyes dropped!! They put a lot of food on the plate!! The spot is really good and I like it. There is bar for those who want to just drink. Very family friendly place so you can bring anyone here for some good food. The service was awesome and they were friendly. Definitely a good tucker spot!

I have been looking forward to trying Nicky's Undefeated for awhile now. I had a rough day at work, didn't feel like cooking, so I picked up hubby and we moseyed along in traffic and headed downtown (Tucker) to try the Philly/Jersey sandwiches. I ordered the beef cheesesteak "Wit" (with onions) and provolone with the seeded bun, plus fry combo and added cherry peppers and banana peppers. Hubby ordered the Italian hoagie (Philly Way) on a regular bun, plus pasta salad combo. Both sandwiches were stacked with meat! I wished there were a bit more onions in my cheese steak, but I'm not complaining because of the amount of meat - it was a perfect ratio of bread:meat (tipping heavier to the meat side just as it should). I really enjoyed that the meat wasn't chopped too much so you got nice big chunks which kept it from getting over cooked and dried out like many places do. I'm going to try the Cooper cheese sauce next time instead of provolone. I had eaten half my sandwich before I even noticed I didn't get the seeded bun like I ordered. I was enjoying it too much to realize. Once I did,though, I was disappointed because I can just imagine how that would have nudged the sandwich even higher on my taste scale. Oh well, just means I have to go back sooner so I can try it. {I'll make sure I get the right bread BEFORE I start to devour it, though.} Hubby really enjoyed his Italian hoagie, he loved the seasoning/oil/vinegar they used as part of the "Philly Way." He said the dressing was better than [the chain Jersey sandwich place] - Shocking!!! {he loves that other place}. He also raced about the pasta salad which was well seasoned and dressed. He thoroughly enjoyed being able to order a side other than a bag of chips. For dessert we opted for peach ice cream (for me) and lemon water ice (for hubby) - hubby definitely made the better choice! We had never heard of water ice before - it is a creamy refreshing not too sweet delight. So how long will it be before we return? Knowing us and our enjoyment of great "sand-ditches" - and knowing how bad I really wanted to try that seeded bun - it won't be very long at all. Edit: I'm thinking I got sliced jalapenos, not the cherry peppers I ordered...another thing to check next time.

I. Can't. Even. If you long for an authentic sandwich from the South Jersey/Philadelphia area, Nicky's in Tucker GA is your Nirvana. They've even got Cooper Sharp Cheese. IYKYK.we had the chicken cheese steak and chicken cutlet sandwiches. Both awesome. Get yourself a wooder ice on the way out!

We were very happy to see this new addition to the Tucker culinary landscape. As we walked in, the space is impressive--clean, spacious, and not crowded. There are large TVs and get this--a bar--a full bar! But I digress... We ordered cheesesteaks, of course. I got the Founder's sandwich and my wife got something that was basically just beef and cheese on bread. We were both pleased with what we got. Lots of meat on a nice roll. It needed more cheese, but I'm not going to hold this against them, yet. Staff was very friendly, considering we walked in with less than 30 min to closing. But they took our order at the counter, and they served us with a smile. Next time we'll do our best to arrive early. Holler if you're coming with.

Nikki's Undefeated? More like Nikki's Unbothered--because they clearly don't care about customer service. Walked in to pure chaos--the owner, Walt, yelling about his favorite team like it was his personal clubhouse. We had to shout just to place an order. I got a chicken cheesesteak and fries, my friend got a regular one. Easy, right? Nope. People who ordered after us got their food first. After 25 minutes, I asked what was up. Walt said our ticket didn't print. Michael, the other owner, said the chicken "just takes longer." So which one is it? Because those two lies didn't even try to match and they were standing next to each other. When the food finally showed up? Cold fries. Missing fries. No apology. Just blank stares. Then, when we asked for a to-go box, we got hit with "Boxes are only for cheesesteaks"--even though we just watched someone get one for their cheesesteak. The math ain't mathing. Bland food. Excuses on top of excuses. No customer service. If I wanted rules, I'd go to court--not pay $15 for a mid cheesesteak. Never again. Cant help to think some racism was involved can't prove it but no other Black people came in after me. Makes sense now.

Wow!! This place has the best Philly Cheesesteak and other Philly favorites! The owner delivered some of the orders and made small talk to just about everyone there. I could hear some patrons saying they were from Philly. They have table seating and a bar to sit and order. I will definitely be back!

I love a good sandwich and I ordered the 6 inch Italian hoagie the Philly way with a side of bean salad. My taste buds were so happy - a genuine hoagie! I ordered it with the seeded bun so the oil and vinegar did not make my bread soggy. And the bean salad! It was soooo good, nice and flavorful. My order was so satisfying! Will def be returning!

Spot is mid at best!! Customer Service definitely gives we couldn't care less that you are In here or not! I could say more but I'm good.

Finally made it to Nicky's Undefeated in downtown Tucker. Their cheesesteak is one of the best I've had in the Atlanta area; high quality ribeye, really good provolone, grilled onions, all on a proper roll. The service was quick and friendly. And I like the fact they have a full bar with draft beer and spirits. Great spot, cool dining room and vibe....we'll be back.

I have been eager to try this place since I saw news of it opening and it did not disappoint! I am constantly in search of good sandwiches down here (originally from NY) and these tasted like home. I got 4 half sandwiches, fried mozz, and pasta salad. The only thing I'll say I could pass on is the pasta salad. It was fine, but overpriced. Now, to the good: Italian sandwich: removed lettuce and tomato, added hoagie spread and mayo. I enjoyed this one - actually more so after it sat a half hour or so. I do wish there was slightly less mortadella and more of the other, but still a solid choice Philly: beef. Cooper cheese. Enjoyed this one as well Nick Foles: awesome sandwich. Generous chicken portions, flavorful broccoli rabe, just enough drizzle, sharp provolone worked well, didn't overpower Rocky balboa: I love a good chicken parm and this was solid. I do prefer 1 large cutlet and not pieces, but that's being nitpicky. The cutlet breading and flavor, enough sauce and mozz. Bread help up but easy to bite into. Finally a good parm! Prices are fine with me - you get way more than your average subpar sandwich spot. Ordered takeout during prime lunchtime and it was ready and waiting for me. If you want a good sandwich - go here!

Great food and atmosphere. We need more place like this in Tucker. My only complaint is I wish they stayed open later.

Omg the best! I hope this place stays in business forever. The food is beyond excellent. The staff is very friendly and professional. I feel really comfortable here and I'm a loyal customer at this point.

I went here on 8/19/2024 for the first time. I got some chicken wings 6 for $12.00 I wanted lemon pepper flavor they had Garlic Parm instead they are delicious! The cheesesteak is really different from others I tried before the copper cheddar is creamy in delicious and you taste it the whole time you eat this sandwich. I also got a lemon water ice delicious.

Well, I will say Tucker can add another great resteraunt to the city. I had a 6 inch Philly. That sandwitch was nice and flavorful and cheesy. I especially loved the bean salad. The bean salad had a nice vinegarette taste,with just the right amount of onion added in. The service was a little slow,around 25 minutes. However, the quality of the food and tastes was exceptional. I will certainly be back again and advise you do the same.

Not bad Philli cheese Wanna try variety of Italian ice flavors Italian sub wasn't a fan

I've been very excited for Nicky's to open. Tucker has some great little food spots but I'm always happy for more. And it would be great to get a cheesesteak from somewhere that's not a national chain. Inside: Very nice. Clean, not crowded. The decor is super nice, and seems like more is coming. Large TVs and a good sized bar, could see coming here to enjoy a game. Lots of nods to (what I assume is?) Philly, even down to the table numbers. Food: Food came out pretty quick. Fries are solid. Well seasoned. Didn't strike me as like the best fries ever but very good. The cheesesteak is AWESOME. Great bread, lots of steak, delicious onions and nice melty cheese. My favorite thing about the sandwich though is that it wasn't super greasy. It didn't feel heavy or oily. Really loved the sandwich. The cherry peppers... a little weird? Not sure if it's a Philly thing but they were just 4 whole cherry peppers in a deli container and cost $2. The counter worker told me they'd be on the side, but I assumed they'd be chopped and something I could add on to my sandwich? Again, could just be a regional thing that I'm not aware of but I wouldn't order them again. They were good! But just snacking on peppers was a little weird. Service: not much to say here. Order at the counter and take a seat. Service was fine. Worker was friendly and nice, asked if I had any questions before ordering and walked me through the sandwich selections. Overall: 5/5. Even though Nicky's is still working out some kinks - they were assembling kitchen tables while I was in and they're Coke machine didn't want to cooperate 100% - I'm so excited to have it in Tucker. If the cheesesteak is a preview of the quality of their other menu items, I can't wait to try their hoagies and ice cream.

I have only been here twice since the restaurant opened. On my first visit I ordered a foot long Italian Hoagie (pretty sure). Today I am going to try the Beef Philly Cheesesteak. I have to say that this Philly was awesome! The service is great and I will be back.

Guys, this had to be some of the best sandwiches ever! My hubby got the Philly, which was amazing. (Of course we had to try each other sandwiches, lol) The beef was so juicy and my god, soooo much flavor! I had the Italian sub which was also divine! There was so much meat, loads of very fresh and crisp veggies, and smoky provolone. It literally took me 3 tries over a 6 hour period to eat the whole thing! It was only a 6 inch but still took me that long to eat the entire sub. The prices we thought were very reasonable for the amount of food. The pasta salad was also fantastic. Next time we're in Tucker, we'll definitely be eating here again. For you Tucker locals, this should be in your go to list!

Tried this place on a whim since I was in the area. The Cheesesteak was fantastic. Juicy and flavourful shaved rib-eye with the sharp creamy cooper cheese. My wife got the steak egg rolls which she loved and the garlic Parmesan wings were cooked perfectly and pretty big as far as wings go. We took the food to go, but the place seemed pretty rad, lots of space. Sort of a family friendly sports bar vibe.

This is a cool place! Friendly staff. Nice vibe. Getting a drink while I wait on takeout. This is just what I wished for Tucker. Thanks Nicky!

About 2-3 weeks after this review I ordered through uber eats to see if the sandwich would be just as good and it was good but just not as good as getting it straight from the restaurant. I would recommend that if you're in a pinch that food delivery should be fine, but highly recommend you just go into the restaurant yourself. You'll see some good sights and can catch the game anyways so what's wrong with that?! So I'd say with food delivery 8/10, at the restaurant 1000000/10

My wife and I just split a 12" Founder's Special combo. Best cheesesteak I have ever had! You will regret it if you pass up a visit here. Service was quick. A++

We've been wanting to try this place for awhile and it did not disappoint! I had the Founders Special and my husband built his own cheesesteak. For the sides we had the soup and the pasta salad. We inhaled every bite and will definitely be back!

Wow - Nicky's Undefeated is awesome! Growing up in Philly area everyone has their favorites - Geno's, Pat's, Jim's and many more. Well Nicky's is right there with them. The rolls are as good as they get. My Philly Cheesesteak was awesome with fantastic meat. No need to wait for trip home to get an EPIC sub. The ATL now has your Philly in the south classic food!!!! Well done Nicky!

Best Cheesesteak in state of GA by far. The service is amazing and the atmosphere is great the owners check on you to make sure your order is good

Tried the new roast pork sandwich. To me, this was the best sandwich in Philadelphia and I am glad to see it on their menu. Same great bread as the other sandwich and lots of tasty pork. Mine was a to-go order and they thoughtfully put the juice in a separate container so it did not get soggy on the way home. It's important to add the juice because it adds a lot of flavor. My sandwich was missing the provolone, maybe you have to ask for that. Typically, this sandwich includes sautéed broccoli rabe or spinach. This one seemed to include frozen, chopped spinach, which was just okay. The sandwich was good, and certainly filling. I will try it again -- and be sure to ask for the provolone. Fresh sautéed spinach or broccoli rabe would take it up a notch. I've had the Founders Special cheesesteak, Nicky Foles, and Italian and all were excellent, this was a notch below this time.

Authentic cheesecake spot in Tucker, Ga. Owner was super nice. My wife had the cheesesteak with cheesewiz. I had the rocky balboa. Street parking is available as well.

We went to Nicky's Undefeated on the Saturday after it snowed. We live in the Tucker area, and always excited to try a new restaurant downtown! The restaurant was a casual, laid back vibe. My husband ordered the cheesesteak and I ordered the crazy Betty, a buffalo chicken cutlet sandwich. We both got the half portions, and they were still decently sized. Both sandwiches were delicious! The service was also friendly and attentive. Can't wait to come back and try more from their menu!

The best cheesesteaks in Atlanta! Better than some I've had in Philly. Great, friendly service. Their fries are great, and the veggie hoagie was loaded with veggies.

UPDATE: They have put the real Philly sandwich on the menu. The real one, the sandwich people from the area know: the roast pork. And it is very, very correct. Pork well seasoned and tender, broccoli rabe on the top and super sharp provolone under. A side of magnificent jus from the pork comes with. Get this with the seeded bun because it holds up to all that juice better. I don't know anywhere else in Atlanta that serves this sandwich so here is a chance to experience something only Philly locals might know about.

I remember this old location used to house a restaurant called Hot Bettys. It was so good and I was so sad to see leave, but I finally decided to try this spot. This is gonna be my go to whenever I feel like a good Philly cheesesteak. The prices are not cheap but they give you your moneys worth And the best part is they have gluten-free bread. The place is nice and clean and atmosphere is laid-back. I hope they don't change if they don't I will be a steady customer. I just wish that they had the option to have mushrooms. We ordered again for take out sadly my sandwich was on regular bread when I requested gluten free so please double stress when ordering to go if you want gluten free!

Went to watch a game with some friends atmosphere and service was upbeat and fun. Had the philly and chicken nachos, both were excellent. You can build the philly any way you like with different cheeses and toppings. Will definitely be back.

Seriously so good - as a vegetarian I love having an option for a cheesesteak! The restrurant is super clean and comfortable, everyone is always kind and the food is top notch.

We came for dinner this evening - met friends at 6:15. None of us had ever been, so we were eager to try the food. The service and food were good. The experience, however, was awful. We realized upon arrival that the high ceiling would tend to make the space rather loud; what we did not expect was the *outrageous* noise we experienced from no fewer than 10 people who brought their game - with noisy "tops" in a "covered dish". Patrons of all ages were completely shocked and offended by the noise that never relented. Sadly, we will not return to your establishment on a Wednesday.

First off, I want to say the food is always consistent and ON POINT delicious!!! However, a couple of things to think about when going here. I placed an online order as I live really close by. Issue #1 - Parking. Not that the owner can do anything about that - but it's problematic. Issue #2 - finally parked in the back and there is a sign pointing customers to use the back hallway to the restaurant - but when you go to the back door it says ONLY for service delivery and employees. I always ignore because nobody is policing. In fact the owner sat in a booth near there today on his phone and he didn't seem to mind. But why make that confusion? Issue #3 - that back hallway smells like sewage...BAD. Not a good experience when you're hungry and going to feed you mouth. I don't know if it's the beauty shop and permanent solution or the bathrooms over flowing with whatev - but it STINKS. Issue #4 - I ordered online and there should be a spot to pick up orders but instead had to wait in line for 15 min while others were waiting to place an order. Glad to see it busy... good for the owner... bad for me cause my fries were COLD. none the less, they were toasty warm with a little air fry - but have a TO GO place to pick up like every other fast casual. Still, the best cheesesteak EVEH! the 1/2 is enough for 2 - trust me, don't pay the expense for the big one.... Unless you're a big one yourself. =)

The Philly cheesesteak had plenty of meat and overall was good. Right amount of cheese. Onions were sparse and cut too small. Two of us split the large sandwich and it was a filling meal. Very disappointed with cheesecake, Small unremarkable slices. $8 apiece way overpriced for what they were. You're better off buying a whole one from the supermarket. They need a section for pick up orders. Stood in line for quite awhile and finally went to get someone. I don't know if we'll be back