D.wight L.
Yelp
Came by with some friends who live in the area for a meet-up dinner. Still don't know what they're really trying to do here as I think I saw "South American" fare on their menu. Kinda of a large geographic area to pull a cuisine from, wouldn't ya say. I mean there's Peru, Colombia, Argentina, Brazil, Chile and Uruguay just to name a few. And all mentioned are different enough from each other, so what are they trying to do here? Not hating, just confused.
Sit-down service as this strip does little casual fare. Ya sign up for the bougie suburban segment if you set up shop on this street. I mean I've had legit Jerk Chicken and stewed Oxtails before many a times, but it was more into the hoods of Oakland, East Palo Alto.
Sizzling Jerk Shrimp ($19/3.5*) Came in a small cast iron pan with about 5 medium shrimps completely submerged in a tasty garlic-oil flavored aggressively with spices which I was assuming was 'jerk' spice. Great flavor but a ton of oil, like they easily coulda put several more shrimps in there for that much oil. Shrimps a bit overcooked but not horrible, just not super plump anymore. And it came with this huge ball of some bread with a hard crust. I tried it but it was pretty dry and hard and with some soft bread already on the table, I just couldn't exercise this.
Oyo Pepper Pot ($18/3*) My friend ordered this for the table and by the name I didn't know what to expect. What came was basically a braised boneless short-rib in appetizer form. A small mound of super tender shortribs to the point where is was more shreddable than sliceable. I prefer the latter as I like texture in protein and produce, I still have all my teeth so I don't mind using them on the daily. Talk to me when I'm 85 and I may change my stance. But this was cooked in a heavily spiced sauce that was kinda sweet. Reminded me bbq sauce minus the smoke. Didn't love this but I took a few bites onto some bread.
Seafood Paella ($34/4*) This wasn't my dish but I took a bite and felt this was the best thing we ordered. Actually came in a paella pan and the rice was actually legit. Cooked well and they actually used a shorter grain rice which is legit for Spain. Not sure how South Americans do it, so once again not entirely sure.
Paella del Negra ($36/2.5*) Another friend ordered this and of course I took a stab at this as well. Except this was a big time curve ball. I usually love 'black' paellas tinted with squid ink but this wasn't even a paella at all. Ffirst off they use 'Fideo' pasta instead of rice, that threw me big time. Fideo is like broken up vermicelli noodles so upon arrival it looks like basmati rice (long grain). Now I would've liked it just fine if it were executed properly but the dish was definitely on the salty side. My friend didn't even want to pack most of the leftovers home, so I took it as I don't like to waste food. I mixed it in with freshly cooked basmati rice as home and it proved to be better mixed in with something more neutral as to stretch out all that saltiness. But to eat it on its own, was a fail in my book.
Jerk Chicken ($22/3*) I'm a huge jerk bbq fan that if I see a place offer it, I'm gonna get it on the first visit. Not sure what they were going for here, but Carribean Jerk is heavily marinated meats, slow cooked over wood without any glaze or sauce lacquered on top. Here it was a generous half chicken so for the price, huge bang as I took most of it home. But the outside of the chicken was heavily rubbed with spices and not sure if it were roasted or grilled over flame but the whole exterior was blackened from all the spices being roasted to blackness. Some parts were more burn't flavored but if you ate a piece of that crazy spiced skin with a good chunk of meat then it countered pretty well. Now if you just got a piece of the exterior then it would be much too salty and charred for my taste.
I actually would have gave it a better rating but the breast meat was pretty darn dry. Just unlike any jerk chicken I've ever had, so again left me a tad confused. The accompanying fried plantains were good tho, the only thing that didn't make a to-go box.
Dark and Stormy ($14/1*) I usually like these when I go to a Carribean themed resto/bar. Dark rum, lime juice and ginger beer, usually a festive winner. But here, this may have been the most awkward version I've had yet. First it was sweeter than it had to be, so I was already struggling with the sips. Then they put some sugary marinated fruit inside as a garnish and it just made everything taste artificial like I was drinking air freshner infused liquor. So gross. I usually can have at least 2 drinks with a long dinner, but here I was scurred to go on any further.
Service was fast and the place was lively. Obviously this area is fond of the place. I'm a little more jaded and baffled. And that's okay can't win em all.