Pickler Sandwich Shop

Uh yeah the flavor was good but the portion was definitely not worth the money. Thankfully my office provided lunch as soon as I finished my “wrap” which was the size of a small child’s lunch with extra sauce on the side since there was barely any of the sauce anyway. But never going back

I got the Reuben sandwich, which was delicious but quite small in size and I don't usually mind that, but for almost $15 I expected a slightly larger sandwich. The place is quite small so you have to get it to go. They also use a touch screen ordering system and don't accept cash, so make sure you bring your card. So aside from the size of the sambo, the taste was good, but not enough to make me come back.

Trying a locsl sandwich shop is always on my list. This one was eassy peasy. Walk in, place your order at the kiosk and food wass ready in minutes. Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese and fries made in peanut oil were delicious. Husband said Bacon Cheeseburger was better than train cheeseburger. He's a man of few words that knows what he likes.

Good food but inconsistent portions. I ordered double meat and I get the same amount of meat, but I pay a lot more. Sometimes they will give me double meat when I pay for it. I don’t understand what’s going on, but the food is good. They just don’t pay attention to the tickets. Why tip in advance when you order if your food most likely will be wrong?

Their prosciutto grilled cheese sandwich was too oily for me and the fig jam was overpowering so it tasted too sweet. The toast was a bit burnt. You can choose 2 pickles. I got their horseradish and spicy pickles which were good. They're also under construction right now so the menu options are limited.

Nice, quick and clean. I got the Brie it was super yummy. Would definitely recommend for a quick lunch stop. Friendly staff as well!

11/10 Sandwich shop. Amazing food, great pickles, and super pleasant staff. Highly recommend!

Cheaper than other sandwich spots but really small portions. Sub par service. Would not recommend.

Never would have popped into this place had I not seem some seller reviews and I'm so glad I did! They have touch-screens to place your order and pay. They were so quick making my 2 sandwiches (The Rachel & the Tuna salad sandwich). They were so so good! The tuna was made to perfection and I'll be dreaming of it for weeks to come. The Rachel was wonderfully balanced and flavorful. Highly recommend for good quality, well made, full NYC sandwich

I was in the mood for actual breakfast food. I don't usually eat breakfast most days but today I really wanted eggs and bacon. Yelp always suggests Pickler to me and today I took the app up on its offer. I made my delivery order and the food arrived earlier than expected. My brekkie sando was nice and warm, ready for consumption. It was a nice sized portion and tasted exact to my specifications. I ordered their egg and avo sandwich, subbed for a whole wheat wrap, added bacon and extra crispy onions - my eggs were fried. Everything tasted great. My one issue was with the delivery. For whatever reason, the Grub Hub app automatically defaults to "Contact Free Delivery" and tells the delivery oerisn to callt/text when they've arrived. These instructions end up printed out on the receipt above my instructions to just leave the order with the front desk. When I'm working in the city, I'm working with patients and can't always leave to grab an order. It's a roll of the dice regarding who might read the entire bit of instructions and who does not. Today, the delivery person called me but he could not hear me. The call disconnected and he called again. I picked up and he still could not hear me. I decided to step out and see if he was waiting in the hallway, and he was. I asked if he had my order and as he gave it to me he complained about calling me. I said that I answered and have no control over him not hearing me - then it got weird. He berated me and threatened that next time he would do "something". I immediately called Grub Hub. It was an off encounter and he must have been waiting for two minutes, as the calls were one minute apart and the hallway is just outside my office door. We have patients here, with mental illnesses, and this man showed his complete rear end because, maybe he was having a bad day and got frustrated? Not sure, but I hope to never see him again as there is surely something troubling him, deeply. This is definitely not an issue that the sandwich shop has anything to do wuth, but if you're receiving food delivery in this area, there is a good chance that person could be delivering your food so be wary.

This hidden gem of a sandwich shop is classic New York--unassuming, but absolutely delicious. Give it a try; you won't be disappointed!

This is a take out place in midtown catering to mostly office workers. Sandwiches are the rule. Mine was a hot pastrami sandwich that came with melted swiss cheese and mustard. It was fine, and although not as thick with pastrami as some well known delis, the price was easy to take. It was only after I returned the tray that I noticed you can self serve a dill pickle that goes with your sandwich. The sandwich sign outside promotes the coffee for a dollar when you spend for lunch. Overall a solid choice for lunch.

Good pickles . Very mediocre sandwiches. Bad bread. Mediocre quality meat and cheese.

I think it's connected to a college satellite campus? Pretty mid-food, but pretty decent pricing.

Checked out this place for lunch recently. It was really yummy. I liked how you order on the computer screen, it made it really easy. There seems to be definitely be a lunch rush here, so maybe order ahead or get there a little earlier. I will be headed back for sure to try some other sandwiches.

Let's talk Pickler sandwiches! Ordering is a breeze with the self-service kiosk. We opted for the classic Chicken Club and Reuben straight off the menu. These sandwiches cater to smaller appetites, so if you crave a hefty one, you might need to look elsewhere. Yet, their flavors, composition, and ingredient freshness hold their ground against bigger competitors. The self-service pickle bar adds a fun twist. And don't miss out on the hand-cut, delicious French fries!

I went for the Ruben sandwich which was very nice, however the size was quit small and I don't usually mind that but for nearly $15 I would have expected a tad bit more of sandwich for my buck. The place is rather small so expect to get takeout also they use touch screen order systems and didn't seem to take cash so make sure and bring you cards. So other than the size of the sambo the taste was delish, but just not enough for me to make a return visit.

Save your time and money and go somewhere else. The sandwich itself was good, but the bread was really thin, there was barely any meat, it was tiny, and the coffee was luke warm and watered down. I got the pastrami. Also, there's no public bathroom. For $12.50 a sandwich, they are robbing you. You'll see what I mean if you see the size and thinness of the sandwich. But don't even waste your time.

Popped in for a quick lunch on a trip to NYC, and Pickler hit the spot. These are simple sandwiches with top-notch quality ingredients. Absolutely delicious. Quick, straightforward service. Small, lil hole-in-the-wall type of ambiance, but man, great sandwiches. Definitely recommend!

Wraps are small but this place is made to order perfection. Grab some pickles with your sando, and enjoy. I have had consistent lunch from here for years.

Tried this spot for lunch while working from my office today and loved it! Reasonable prices and very fresh sandwiches that came out quickly. I loved my BLT! Will definitely be back.

Consistently great service and the sandwiches are tasty--some veggie options too. Breakfast sandwiches are also solid. Price point is reasonable. Only a few seats so plan to take out.

Phenomenal breakfast BLT sandwich...will be back! Excellent service, made to order fresh food. Don't miss this great spot when in the neighborhood.

Thinking about Pickler makes my mouth water! I really love this place--their sandwiches, their fries, and especially their pickles! I think one of my favs is the Caprese Grilled Cheese, but really I love any grilled cheese. The fries always come out piping hot, and they're best if you enjoy them there. Okay, now the pickles. There are so many different kinds of pickles there, and I've now gotten to try them all. My favourite by far is the spicy one, which was definitely spicier than I was expecting. I can't wait for my next visit back so that I can buy a whole tub of pickles!

Love this spot. Best veggie sandwich ever. Go to lunch spot in midtown!! Their pickles are also delicious.

The food was tasty, I had the tuna sandwich. It was a bit thin with the fillings. The delivery was super quick! I have not gone in, ordered through GrubHub so I can't speak to the ambience.

I just love this place. Best breakfast sandwich that is not on a bagel or from a bagel shop: scrambled eggs, pepper jack cheese, slice of tomato, and avocado with chipotle mayo and I sub sourdough for multigrain - all good fresh baked breads from a tristate bakery. They toast it in a panini press. yum. all orders more than $8 get 2 pickle halves. I love the half sour. The tuna melt is good as well. They have good deli sandwiches too. This is a small business and everyone working there is so nice! it's small and has a few tables if you wish to order and eat there. I hope everyone will go here. We've lost a lot of businesses in Turtle Bay and this is one not to miss please support them!

Made a stop here on a Wednesday afternoon for lunch. Currently difficult to find because of the construction going on (as well as limited signage). Thankfully was able to locate the entrance and make an order quickly. Lunch special has discounted sandwiches and free pickles to boot. Decided on the Hot Pastrami ($10ish), to go along with some spicy pickles while I waited. Pastrami is a basic layering of meat, swiss cheese, and strong mustard inside of two slices of rye bread. Simple overall sandwich that wasn't too hefty for a mid-afternoon meal. Pickles are certainly spicy, and they have other varieties as well if that's not your thing. Service is quick and they do have bar-seating available if staying inside. Not the greatest sandwich spot out there, but good enough for a moderate meal.

3.5 stars - first time here and I'd like to return before giving it a higher star review. So the expectation is there but I'd like to have a second taste. Passed by on a whim - exploring my work hood and wanting to find something different, this caught my eye. Oddly it shares a building with a local College but the space works. Limited seating so I took my order to go. Grabbed an avocado grilled cheese sandwich today. In it had sliced tomatoes, chunky avocado, jack cheese and grilled on multigrain bread. By the appearance, I think they grilled my bread too much for my liking (see photo). So while not as pretty, it tasted great. Liked that the avocado was a bit chunky and not like a spread, it adds substance. The tomato was semi thick sliced so again, making it more hearty. The jack cheese combined with all that, tied it together. Yum. I watched the sandwich crafters at work and am thinking a second visit to try the burger and the other grilled cheese that caught my eye - it's a bacon with caramelized onions, two cheeses on sourdough. Hint of garlic mayo too it says. You had me at the bacon. One note about the sandwich, it did get a bit messy to eat so I'm glad I had mine to go. So I scarfed it down in the privacy of my office with a ton of napkins on hand. Note: there's a line but it moved quickly. There was also a pickle bar where you can grab a few but I couldn't get close enough to take a pic. Too many people! :-) Will let you know how it is when I return.

These sandwiches are delicious! If you are in the area and are wondering where to grab a bite, you'll be doing yourself a favor by stopping in this cute sandwich shop. I love the Turkey Club, the Chicken Caesar Wrap, & the Max's Wrap. Those are my favorites but you really can't go wrong with any sandwich here. So go check them out and I hope you enjoy it as much as I do. Cheers & Enjoy!

Passed this place on a whim for some quick eats. Coming off a flight and needing a quick meal for the morning, I needed some food stat. So that $5 Avocado Grilled Cheese was exactly what I needed. It was my first bite in NYC in awhile, and the grilled cheese was pretty good. It came out super quick in less than 5 minutes and everything about it tasted good for a breakfast sandwich. The pretzel roll was definitely good and I enjoyed the softness of the bread. The avocado worked well with the grilled cheese, which was satisfying. The sandwich was hot and tasted fresh. Tried my friend's coffee and it was pretty good too. I'd recommend here for a quick and affordable bite.

Great sandwich. And nice choices. Only issue it's short in seating space. But it is delicious food. I take it go and eat by the water. Go enjoy you'll love something trust me.

Drop-in for a lunch pick-up and I was a little confused at the storefront but it's just shared with a coffee shop, quite small and not the best to sit down and eat - best to grab and go! I was fortunate to order during my walk over to avoid any lunch rush, so they were already preparing my order when I got there. The folks there are super nice and were very welcoming, they made sure that I had something on the grill before they started to work on the remaining orders. The sandwich was super delicious, the bread was toasted to perfection and not too greasy, it worked well with the pastrami meat and melty cheese. I wanted to honestly eat two sandwiches cause they really put some work into the sandwich! But after one I was already stuffed and if I ate two, I would have taken a nap during a work meeting! hhahahaha. Would definitely recommend you to order lunch ahead! It is a great sandwich option and even better with drinking a seltzer to wash it down.

Stopped in on Tuesday afternoon for lunch. I had the Avocado grilled cheese with bacon and sadly it was really disappointing. Somehow overly toasted, almost burnt bread with 0 cheese pull or even fully melted cheese. Ingredients were fresh though - so I gave an extra star. The pickle was decent but from a place with this name, I would expect nothing less. Priced alright for a manhattan sandwich spot - but I won't be visiting again.

Randomly found this spot by Yelping "sandwich" near work. Thank goodness. I did an online order for a NJ Sloppy Joe - (Double decker roast beef, smoked turkey, Swiss, thousand island and coleslaw. Pressed)...and then, in the 'comment's' section, prayed that they could swap the swiss for goat cheese, the coleslaw from greens, and the dressing for spicy brown. I definitely thought I had zero chance of actually receiving the meticulously-crafted (and admittedly probably annoying) sandwich. A Yuppie Joe? I arrived at the place, was greeted quite nicely, offered some free sample cookies (REALLY GOOD - chewy and chocked full of nuts) and other treats. I tell the attendant my name, get my sandwich all wrapped up...and just wonder version of the NJ Sloppy was underneath. I got back to my office, unwrapped my treat...and what lay before me was..exactly what I ordered. Boom. Loved it. What more could I want? More cookies, probably. Until next time....

I am so glad that Pickler is back open and I don't have to miss out on my mid week sandwich cravings. Especially now that they have a pick up window for contactless takeout and are also doing delivery. I got the Avocado Sandwich and added smoked turkey and chipotle mayo on a multigrain bread and my partner got Egg Salad Sandwich with added cheddar cheese on a multigrain bread. We loved our sandwiches! Pickler is always a great lunch spot!

Easy, quick sandwich delivery in the area. I've tried the Buffalo Chicken Wrap and the Avocado Grilled Cheese...both delicious and perfectly prepared! Their Chipotle Mayo is also seriously amazing.

I stumbled across this place earlier this week as I was trying to find something new to try out near my office. The place looks nondescript from the outside, but it's actually a decent sized place in the inside. You enter into the ordering area, where there's a cashier and two self-service counters for you to order on your own. It seemed a bit confusing at first, but I seemed to grasp it pretty quick. To your left is a seating area with a bunch of barstools to eat in and the chefs behind them preparing the food. I ordered the avocado grilled cheese and it took me about 5 minutes to receive the order (wasn't too bad). The avocado grilled cheese was pretty solid for the most part. The avocado, mayo, and pepper jack mix in pretty well. If anything, the sandwich was slightly on the smaller side, but it was also $6.50 so can't complain. I did have a couple issues to mention. First, the bread was quite burnt. They need to be a bit careful going forward because multigrain bread can get burnt pretty easily. Second, the grilled cheese either needs a bit stronger wrapping or maybe I should be provided with a small plate because the mayo can drip a bit and cause a little mess on your desk if not careful. Nothing too crazy, but it's worth mentioning going forward. The grilled cheese was good and this place will be in my rotation going forward.

Absolutely best tasting Rueben. Perfect balance of meat, cheese, and sauerkraut. Not like other places that pile on half a pound of meat! The fresh cut fries are also wonderful, just wish they sent more ketchup or gave options for other dipping sauces

For starters again, Rockabye was playing so bonus points for that. So I ran 9.15 miles this morning and was fucking STARVING afterwards. I wanted a big, fat, juicy breakfast sandwich. Sometimes I just crave bready and cheesey. And by sometimes, I mean all the time. It's a nice, crisp, spring Saturday morning. I step outside and it's drizzling so I have to immediately turn around and walk past my doorman and go up to my apartment to get an umbrella just to go back down to walk past him for the 3rd time in 45 seconds. Classic. I must've read the location wrong because for some reason I thought it was on 46th street so I walked an extra block. Classic me. I found the entrance confusing (I did drink a decent amount last night, it was my birthday, so let's blame my cognitive difficulties on that. Like my CSF was literally tequila and hefeweizen). I walk in to what I'm not sure is the actual place I'm attempting to locate (this place) but decide to bite the bullet anyway. God forbid I get a subpar sandwich tho. I walk up to the counter, there's a lot going on in this place when you first enter and the 25% of my frontal cortex that was functional was overwhelmed. I greet the girl working there with a "good morning" until I realize that I think it was like after 12 and I ALWAYS do that, it's so embarrassing. People are like...uh....it's like 2pm... Like, people have actually said that to me before. Please try less hard to make me feel better about saying something stupid. I go with 2 scrambled eggs (should've done three) well done, with pepper jack and I ask for a bread recommendation. The girl suggests ciabatta or sour dough. I went with the former although I was intrigued by the "pretzel roll" they have. Price was super fair, $4.40. While I was waiting another customer comes in and the girl says "good morning...uh..sorry I mean afternoon" to him. I guess inaccurate time perception is similarly contagious to yawning. Lol, I haven't even gotten to the food yet. My sandwich was prepared and I set off on my trek home. I dig into the bag and pull out this beauty. It was wrapped snuggly but I was disappointed in its size. Wouldn't be the first time. Amiright? Size aside, it was magnificent and warm. I separated the two halves and the cheese was still melty like on commercials. Holy shiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiit. The eggs were cooked to PERFECTION. The bread was crisp on the outside and soft on the inside. The pepperjack was barely noticeable. I doused that shit with valentina EXXtra hot and went to work. The sandwich was spectacular. I devoured it like an animal. Only problem was the size (ugh, classic). I was still hungry afterwards. Perhaps I should hve ordered a bagel or more stuff in it. Maybe it really is my fault.

This place is fantastic, best sandwiches in the area and are ready in 5 minutes every time. Hidden gem on a side street so never crowded and they give away variations of free pickles which are awesome. I don't normally write reviews (good or bad) but this place needs to be talked about. Keep up the good work.

Stopped here for lunch on a weekday afternoon. I got the hot pastrami sandwich with the half sour pickles. The sandwich was the right size to leave you satisfied and the assortment of pickles to select from is the perfect touch to go with the sandwich. I would recommend!

Pros: speedy delivery and overall tasty food Cons: don't provide you with the option to purchase a beverage or a pickle via seamless or yelp...since I didn't see the option to purchase a pickle, one would assume it came with the sandwich. To be on the safe side, I specifically requested one on the side = got nada. Bummed, especially since "pickle" is literally in the name of the store :(

I came Monday morning to get breakfast. I was kind of shocked how the place was completely empty. I ordered a toasted Egg Man sandwich for $8 which is arguably expensive for breakfast. But let me tell you it was worth every penny. My sandwich came STUFFED with egg salad and yumminess. I wanted to save half for later but I couldn't cause it was too damn delicious. I expected it to be a little saltier with the ham and cheddar but it's actually on the sweeter side. After breakfast I fell into a food coma which we all know can't be good for work. No regrets though. I can't wait to return!

Pickler & co is a good spot for sandwiches in the midtown east area. It's a little pricey for the size of the food, but it's good quality. Pros: I've tried a number of things on their menu and have been satisfied with all of them. I'm a big fan of their make-your-own option. I go with Swiss, turkey, chipotle mayo, avocado, and caramelized onions - a delicious combo. It comes out pretty quickly; I've never had to wait more than 5ish minutes, even when it's crowded. Could be improved: The layout of the place. It's confusing when you walk in - the menu is on the walls and people are often standing by the register while they wait for their food. Occasionally I've had minor issues with my order (forgotten tomato, etc.) but that kind of thing happens everywhere once in awhile. There are a few seats inside, but it a small spot and gets very crowded in the afternoon. I'd recommend taking your order to go.

Not a fan of their latte, the espresso tasted a bit burnt. Also, I've been ordering almost the same sandwich each time I've been here, but yesterday the cheeses were still cold even though I asked for the sandwich to be pressed (never run into that issue before) and the sandwich was super messy. I did reach out to CS per the card they've been leaving in your brown bag and David said to ask for it extra pressed in the future...mmmm ok.

Yay, a fresh and delicious sandwich spot near my office. They have "classic creations" or you can build your own. This goes for sandwiches AND salads. Prices vary depending on what you get. I had the hot pastrami sandwich for $12. Perfect size for lunch. Dare I say it is better than Katz's? For orders over $7 you get your choice of slaw and pickle (self serve).

Wow! So amazing! I was in the city and wanted something unique close by so I looked it up and read the stellar reviews for this place. They didn't exaggerate! I made my own sandwich with ham, bacon, Swiss, greens, fig spread, mayo, and honey mustard on ciabatta and pressed. The man helping me was beyond nice and patient through my indecisive process even though I changed my mind several times. Everyone that worked there was great! He also let me know about the pickle and Cole slaw station! I got a sour pickle (yum) and mayo Cole slaw (also yum) and took them to go with my sandwich. Definitely going to have to come back here many more times when I'm in New York! Also if you're walking, keep your eyes peeled! I walked right by it and had to turn around so make sure you don't miss it!

Funny thing is, I asked what they put in their tuna and was told onion. If I had known they put cut up pickles in it, I wouldn't have ordered it. Sadly, the pickles did nothing to help this overly dry Tuna. They need to put in more mayo. It's almost inedible as is. I am sad to say the tuna is the better of the two items I ordered. I actually sought out the best BLT in NYC. Picklers came up as one of the top places to order a BLT from. I like my BLT with heavy mayo. Not only did I tell, and remind the person who took my order, but when they called out my name to pick up my bag, I once again asked if they put extra mayo on my sandwich. I was assured they had. Opened up the sandwich and not only was there NOT extra mayo on it, there was NO MAYO at all making it inedible for me. What a waste of time and money. If this is the best NYC has to offer, I am beyond disappointed. Buyer beware.

I wanted to be adventurous today - so I went on yelp, typed in my zip-code and "Lunch" and this was the first place to pop up! The reviews looked great, so I wanted to see for myself what this was. When you walk in, you will see a coffee shop to your right and the lunch place to your left. I went at around 11:20 and there were maybe 1 or 2 people besides me. So there was no wait! I already had my mind made up with what I wanted to get - the Turkey Club for $9.25 (smoked turkey, pork bacon, pepper jack cheese, avocado mayo, tomato and romaine on sourdough). The sandwich looked smaller than I had anticipated (perhaps because I was so hungry), but later found that it would do the trick to fill me up. The sandwich was really great - but I guess everything that has bacon is defaulted to be great. I would assume this places could get pretty crowded as you approach noon, so be prepared! The place had 1 or 2 tables to sit, but it is obviously not a place you would want to come to eat in.

Ordered the Cali Club w/Roasted Turkey and pressed. I also ordered a bag of jalapeño chips. Delivery was through Yelp and I received it within 20 mins. The sandwich was amazingly delicious! The bread was multigrain which tastes great toasted. The combination of turkey, sprouts, tomato, cream cheese and avocado was so good! The addition of the sunflower seeds gave the sandwich a nice salty crunch. Paired with my favorite jalapeño kettle chips, it's a winning duo. I will definitely order that again!

Didn't read a single review, just went in during a work trip and it was busy over lunch. I was between The Reuben and hot pastrami - asked the woman who rang me up for her advice (she had none, although she was wearing a sweatshirt that said Reuben, ha...). I ordered the hot pastrami and loved every bite. I tried two pickles on the side - horseradish (horrible) and spicy (good, still not great). Hot pastrami is a win - took one star away for disappointing pickles.

You don't know how good a place is until you start missing their sandwiches. When it comes to ordering sandwiches, I always do it online. When it comes to what type of sandwich, it's always the Rachel. Turkey pastrami, just like a Rueben but it's Rachel. When it comes to the two free pickle, well, I've tried all flavors. I'm more sour and spicy. Pro tip: There are 2 cashiers and two self serve iPads (by the cashiers). So when it's busy, there's technically 4 windows open. Just order online.

Came here at around lunch time on a Sunday and it was relatively quiet. Luckily they serve breakfast all day as that was what I was craving for. Tried their breakfast BLT and a latte. The sandwich was pretty good, just a little stingy on the bacon :( Coffee was a disappointment....doesnt have much a strong coffee taste (probably too much milk) and it also had a sour aftertaste to it, which i didnt like Price was reasonable though.

Used to be a staple when my office was in midtown. Fun sandwhich flavors, good chips and the best pickles. Grab yourself a combo and a la croix and eat outside on a summer day. I especially loved the broccoli Brie sandwich they had! Yumm!

Great cafe for a quick breakfast! The staff was friendly, the service was fast. On my way to the UN building, I felt like drinking something thin and hot, and Pickler's cafe au lait ($2.75) was perfect for me. They steam up milk so that it won't get lukewarm. I chose a chocolate banana muffin out of various kinds of muffins - whole grain, browny, cranberry, etc. and it's about $3 each. the chocolate banana muffin was sooo delicious!! I loved big chocolate chunks in the flavorful banana muffin. I will regularly come back here to try other breakfast options.

Very very disappointing. Please take money to other bagel establishment. Ordered a Plain Bagel, with American Cheese and 2 Egg Whites. 9$, which is mighty expensive for the bagel. Then when I got back to my desk at the office, I take out the bagel and unwrap it. Noticed that they had FORGOTTEN THE CHEESE. How do I pay $1.50 for a slice of cheese and not seem to have it in the bagel!?!??! A bagel with two egg whites tastes like shit. Very unfortunate as I wanted to like this place.