Eliza B.
Google
Updated - Second time here and I am not happy. We were 5 people and were trying to put the inside tables together and was told not to put three together. No one came in after us so it wasn't busy, so I am not sure why we couldn't use 3 small tables for our party. The tables and chairs were dirty but there was no concern there. Zero customer service!
We ordered 7 slices like the ones you purchase by the slice, and were told that we should just have a pie, to which we agreed. The pie we got was half the size of the one they sell by the slice, and certainly not enough for 5 people. The gentleman proceeded to explain that he never makes the larger pie for table orders and proceeded to explain the pricing, which I never asked him for.
Overall, the flavor was good but the dough very soft and completely different from the slice, which is thinner and more crispy. It would seem that they stretch the dough for the slices to make them thinner.
Coming from a place where pizza is culture, this was hard to swallow. And the price exorbitant for the small pie. Needless to say, the picture I posted was for a slice, but don't expect the same size when you order a pie. And don't expect it to be crispy.
The restaurant exists to serve the Jewish community, and that is beautiful. But outside of that community not so much. They have a good opportunity to turn it around by adding someone else at the front who understands service, and knows how to listen to the customer, all while continuing to honor the Sabbath and closing during that time. That's commendable, but if you turn people off outside that community you won’t be around too much longer.
Also, bathroom was filthy!
———————
First time here. Pizza Slice was good.