In the heart of Clinton Hill, this cozy, old-school spot serves up classic pies and hearty heros, with a no-frills charm that keeps locals coming back.
"Tony’s Pizza Spot showed its age via a menu that didn’t subscribe to the latest pizza fads (no Buffalo chicken pizza, for example)." - Robert Sietsema
"This Clinton Hill pizzeria shows its extreme age, via a narrow sagging interior, intriguing clutter, and menu that doesn’t subscribe to the latest pizza fads (no buffalo chicken pizza, for example). This makes it a great place to imagine what neighborhood pizza was like 40 years ago, with a charming plainness in its sturdy crust, slightly sweet sauce, and liberal hand with the cheese. Want variety? Pile on the anchovies." - Robert Sietsema
Kevin Glass
Confessions of a Food Freak
Riley Keating
Cory Long
Ruth Wee
Sarah L
Chika Uchendu
Charles Liu