Gary G.
Yelp
This was my favorite bagel joint when it was in Providence and is my favorite now that it moved to Cambridge. Sadly, Monday to Friday only, at least for now, but I respect a place that chooses quality over making the extra weekend dollars.
Flavors: They've got great core flavors every day, with a very densely-packed, salt-forward "everything" bagel. I'm even more of a fan of their pumpernickel everything, which gives you the best of both worlds. All have what I consider the right density (significantly denser than Bagelsaurus).
Toasting: They don't technically "toast" the bagel; instead, they "warm" the bagel BEFORE slicing, to simulate a right-out-of-the-oven temperature and feel.
Cream Cheese: I've only had the chive and the plain; both good and both fine of smoothness. Thankfully not fridge-cold.
Toppings and Sandwich Construction: Superb. Their salmon, available in a few varieties, is made in-house, sliced thin, and piled generously. Excellent whitefish salad too; a little on the loose side (read: messy), but very tasty. Sandwiches come with plenty of supporting vegetation and such.
Service: Helpful, but it helps to know that the wait times after ordering are a bit longer than at most.
Seating: A few tables, a few stools, and whimsical decor.