Ed U.
Yelp
Jamie W. and I had tickets to see the jacked-up version of "The Music Man" starring Hugh Jackman, so we felt a need to eat something a cut above Papaya Dog before the show. I was web surfing when I came upon dining recommendations from not a renowned chef or an acknowledged foodie. They came from Fran Drescher. The Nanny. Yes, the lady in red when everybody else is wearing tan. I believe I've only seen her eat rugelach on her show, but she did a good job convincing me that Robert would be worth checking out.
It's on the ninth floor of 2 Columbus Circle on top of the multi-level Museum of Art & Design appropriately initialized as MAD. Pretty wild exhibits. Even though I made a reservation just the day before, I had the unmitigated gall of requesting a window table facing the circle. When we arrived, I timidly asked if one was available, and the hostess led us to the last one facing the window, a mini-table abutted against the wall. But hell, Jamie and I didn't care because there was enough room for the two of us.
Besides, we still had the same panoramic view that the more obviously anal pre-planners had at the nicer tables. We saw not only Columbus Circle, the former Time Warner (now Deutsche Bank) building, and several blocks of Columbus Avenue but also the Trump International tower. Blech. They offered a $44 lunch prix fixe, but before we considered our choices, we felt a need for cocktails. Jamie ordered the $18 Mad Manhattan even though he never had one before. I told him "Go brown or go home!" I didn't know what I meant.
It was a potent mix of Woodford Reserve bourbon, orange bitters, vermouth, and Amarena cherries. I had the comparatively tamer $18 Wolf's Negroni which had a decided Latin accent with mezcal, Campari, sweet vermouth, and an orange peel (photo: https://bit.ly/3A1aPtN). When we started seeing ghostly apparitions of Trump through the window, we realized it was time to eat. For our openers, Jamie ordered the Gazpacho, ice-cold richness topped with a corn zucchini relish (photo: https://bit.ly/3bBrJG8).
I went for the fresh Tuna Tatare, chopped, mixed with jalapeños, and slathered with avocado sitting atop cucumber slices (photo: https://bit.ly/3PYNWwN). Meanwhile, the soft bread rolls kept coming warm and addictive as they were (photo: https://bit.ly/3A1yRVv). Either the entrees were quite generous or the alcohol was making everything look bigger. Jamie decided on the Scottish Salmon served with artichoke leaves, cauliflower a la grecque, and radish fennel salad (photo: https://bit.ly/3JDStm8). Quite a slab and nicely tender with the cauliflower adding a surprising crunch.
I went for the Organic Amish Chicken, a roasted half-chicken split in quarters and kept quite succulent. It was served with baby veggies, fingerling potatoes, and herbed chicken au jus (photo: https://bit.ly/3vMzhwx). When it came to dessert, we were both drawn to the Mango Coconut Mousse with kiwi jelly and a base of dried meringue (photo: https://bit.ly/3A1Z0na). But I noticed the fashion-forward Japanese women at the next table ordered the House Made Sorbets as they were Instagramming every morsel of their meal.
In the middle of my entree, I asked the server if I could switch my dessert to the sorbet. When two of the mango desserts arrived, I presumed I was too late, but then the server came back with a color-coordinated bowl of raspberry and lemon sorbets that was quite refreshing (photo: https://bit.ly/3JEeykf). That was truly a nice gesture. So the flashy girl from Flushing was right. Robert showed she had style, she had flair. Besides, the large unisex restroom had the best view from a toilet I've ever experienced.
FOOD - 4 stars...not highly creative in concept but truly satisfying in execution with generous portions
AMBIANCE - 5 stars...great views, colorful setting, even a mini-table works for the non-picky
SERVICE - 5 stars...the last-minute window seat and extra dessert impressed us
TOTAL - 5 stars...Fran Drescher is my new tastemaker?
RELATED - Looking for dining options in NYC? Here's a collection of places I've visited and reviewed: http://bit.ly/2YS9ELs