Sal's Pizza Store
Permanently Closed

Sal's Pizza Store

Permanently Closed

Classic pizza since 1957, homemade gelato, authentic Italian fare

new york-style slices
authentic
thin crust
friendly owners
good vibe
chicken a la vodka
pepperoni
fresh ingredients
Sal's Pizza Store by null
Sal's Pizza Store by null
Sal's Pizza Store by null
Sal's Pizza Store by null
Sal's Pizza Store by null
Sal's Pizza Store by null
Sal's Pizza Store by null
Sal's Pizza Store by null
Sal's Pizza Store by null
Sal's Pizza Store by null
Sal's Pizza Store by null
Sal's Pizza Store by null
Sal's Pizza Store by null
Sal's Pizza Store by null
Sal's Pizza Store by null
Sal's Pizza Store by null
Sal's Pizza Store by null
Sal's Pizza Store by null
Sal's Pizza Store by null
Sal's Pizza Store by null

Information

305 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231 Get directions

$1–10

See Menu
Debit card accepted
Contactless accepted
Alcohol
Beer
Seating

Information

Static Map

305 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231 Get directions

@salspizza_

$1–10 · Menu

Features

•Debit card accepted
•Contactless accepted
•Alcohol
•Beer
•Seating
•Wheelchair accessible entrance

Last updated

Jan 18, 2026

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2026 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@eater
391,688 Postcards · 10,991 Cities

Look Dine-In Cinemas Is Opening in NYC, Hell’s Kitchen - Eater NY

"Sal’s Pizza Store, a staple of Carroll Gardens has announced its closure. In a past interview, it claims to have been one of the original by-the-slice places from the 1950s. 'Around ‘53 to ‘57 is when by-the-slice came around and we’re number three on that list. You can come here, you don’t have to get a whole pie, you just get a slice and go back to work.' The last day for Sal’s, a slice shop in business for more than 50 years, is this Sunday, according to Brooklyn Magazine." - Emma Orlow

https://ny.eater.com/2023/2/23/23610446/look-dine-cinemas-opening-nyc
Sal's Pizza Store
@nymag
507 Postcards · 90 Cities

"Fridays are pizza nights, always. When we lived in Brooklyn we had a tradition: an extra large cheese pie from Sal’s on Court Street."

Grub Street Diet: Silvia Killingsworth
Sal's Pizza Store
@grubstreet
13,564 Postcards · 1,477 Cities

Silvia Killingsworth’s Grub Street Diet

"When we lived in Brooklyn we had a tradition: an extra large cheese pie from Sal's on Court Street." - Chris Crowley

https://www.grubstreet.com/2021/04/silvia-killingsworth-grub-street-diet.html
Sal's Pizza Store

Damian P.

Google
My girlfriend and I were walking down court street and were both very hungry it was about to rain so we needed something quick and savory. We were in luck, as we continued to walk we saw Sal's Pizza right there on the corner and definitely tasted the authenticity in the Italian food they served. I had a cheese slice which tasted amazing and she had a Sicilian which superceded our expectations will be going back highly recommend 👌!!!

Ben K.

Google
An unpretentious neighborhood pizzeria serving up good New York-style slices and pies. My dad used to take me here as a kid. I still like to stop by for a slice or two—and now I can enjoy a beer with my slice(s) as well.

Leonardo T.

Google
The Sicilian with Mushrooms & Pepperoni was a good slice. While the crust could've been crisper the cheese was excellent and drizzled with olive oil.

Tyler C.

Google
amazing pizza. crust is light and delicious and everything is fresh and high quality. love the pepperoni.

Joel Y

Google
Feels like a real authentic mom and pop pizza shop. Had a great slice, chicken a la vodka, crispy, thin and buttery crust with a delicious sauce. Super friendly owners and just a great vibe. Highly recommend.

Michael F.

Google
Maybe it was a mistake, but we got a pepperoni pie which is pretty out-of-character for me (I'm a plain guy all the way). That said, the pizza left a ton to be desired. There was a yellow cheese on it as opposed to the expected usual mozzarella and parmesan and at the very least the visual affected how it tasted. I will disclaim: it wasn't bad. I'd eat it again if I had to. It just wasn't good. Pizza Adventures: Destination #109

Mark L.

Google
Not much to say except it's good Brooklyn slice but a bit pricey. Other equivalent Pizzeras charging $2.50 for the plain slice vs. their $3.50 price. Sauce is tangy and the dough is very thin.

Javier K.

Google
Excellent unfussy pizza with fresh ingredients. The large pie easily feeds two if they aren't too hungry.