Austin B.
Yelp
tl;dr a family-run BYOB pizzeria cooking up signature square pies among other Italian fare
Many Philly-ites swear by Santucci's, and it's not hard to see why -- the original location in South Philly has been serving up some of the city's best pizzas since 1959. Dished out exclusively by the pie, the pizzas have a signature thin-crust and square-shape, crafted uniquely with the cheese underneath the sauce. The pies are wood-fire to-order, so expect to wait 20 minutes or so for it. The non-pizza options at Santucci's are middling at best, and it's for this reason that I'm only giving it 4 stars.
The original Italian Market location is situated unassumingly on a quiet residential corner. But as soon as you walk in, the delectable smells of fresh-baked Italian herbs and spices. The majority of the space is taken up by the large, open kitchen, where a half dozen staff members are hard at work cranking out pies. The simple seating area toward the right of the restaurant is crammed with numerous two-seater wooden tables, flanked by the homey atmosphere of exposed brick and red shiplap ceilings. Walls are decorated with Italian accents including wine bottles and framed prints. But nonetheless. Santucci's remains with the times, featuring a flat-screen and stereo sound system.
During this past visit, my partner and I were really craving some high-end pizza, and ordered The Works, decked out in pepperoni, sausage, peppers, mushrooms, and onions. As always, Santucci's continued to dazzle us with their pie, served on a wooden pizza platter with a full-sized spatula. The large is enormous, sporting 17" x 12" dimensions. The layer of cheese separating dough from sauce ensured that the pizza never ended up a soggy mess. The crust was crisp and buttery -- even I, a notorious non-crust eater, chomped down on every last bite. The red sauce was sweeter than chain pizzerias', accentuating the freshness of the ingredients. The sausage, meanwhile was robustly savory, perfectly complimenting the peppers and onions.
For $28, we enjoyed one of our favorite pizzas in Philly, and still had two slices to take home. While I'm skeptical of whether delivery would end up the same quality, I have no doubt that I'll be back in-person soon enough.