Chloe T.
Yelp
I was too lazy to trek all the way out to Kettl at Greenpoint, so I stopped by Setsugekka instead. It turns out, it's a good contender for matcha and goes pretty hard! It's a serious, high-caliber matcha spot (someone recommended Starbucks instead and I'm sorry but LMAO)
I tried a traditional preparation of Senju no Mukashi, which was about $9. It was a little overpriced for something that was $27/20g, but you get to see it prepared in front of you and chat with your server. It wasn't overly bitter and it definitely was fresh, a little grassy and oceanic. If this was their mid-tier variety, then it was a good sign that their higher-tier ones were even better.
I wish they had a better assortment of things to eat with the matcha. They only had jam-filed cookies, which I skipped. Matcha can often be hard on your stomach if you haven't eaten anything before or during drinking it. More traditional wagashi would be great, and would seriously step up their game.
They have an in-house mill, which was VERY impressive. I had to try out their house-milled matcha, as it should induce ethereal transcendence with its insane freshness. I grabbed Yuki and Jobetsugi, something I intended to use for my lattes.
The Yuki was, to my disappointment, dumped straight into the tin... it was pre-sifted (great) it seems, BUT THEY SHOULD HAVE TOLD ME TO REFRIGERATE IT!! Gah. I thought it might've been sealed in a foil bag, which is why I let it sit outside for a day, but if it's oxidizing at room temp it's going to kill some flavors off. It still tasted decent, and at the back of my palate I can taste some of the magical complexity, but I do wonder if it could have been more had it stayed cold the entire time. If you're going to pay $66/20g, or around $13/cup the way I do, it's gotta be done very well.
The Jobetsugi was sealed, and it's a really good matcha latte base! It's very clean and fresh. For the price ($40/80g) it's excellent; I might start getting my matcha just for barista purposes here. I've also noticed the matcha is pre-sifted here (or just very fine?).