Show Me Pizza

If you want creative, flavorful Neapolitan pizza, this should be on your radar. If Bufalina is where you go for more fancy, traditional tomato sauce based Neapolitan pizzas, then this is where you go when you're feeling more adventurous and fun-loving. We had 3 pizzas. The first one was the 50 First Dates. Liked the toppings on this one. Second was the Domo Arrabiata Mr. Roboto, which had an assortment of textures and flavors we enjoyed. The spiciness from the sauce & chili oil perfectly cut through the savory meat and sweet honey. Last, we had the Cashville Hot Chicken (not pictured bc we got too excited to eat it). This one was probably our favorite. Slightly crispy, savory, hot chicken with nice brightness from the pickled onions. The pizza can get a bit soggy, but that's par for the course for Neapolitan. Overall, the flavor combos were fun and nicely executed. Great toppings, sauce (Arrabiata in particular), and tasty cheese (cheese pulls included!). Loved how charmingly fun the decor is and the owner, Benjamin, was awesome. We loved talking to him & his effortless charm. Come give this place some love!

New favorite pizza spot! The pizza was even better than the ones I had in Italy a month ago. Somehow these guys figured out the secret recipe to the perfect dough, sauce & cheese ratio. We got a traditional pepperoni which far passed my expectations. It had crispy deli pepperoni, fresh oregano leaves and tons of cheese. We also got a sausage pizza with their homemade onion sauce because it sounded interesting. It was even better than the 1st pizza somehow. Great pizza, great vibes, nice location. You gotta try this spot

Best gluten free gf pizza I’ve ever had in my life. Don’t think this can be topped!! It was like… like real pizza! Check out the crumb. I got the Carbone Copy Spicy Vodka and added pepperoni. Wish I lived in Austin, I’d come here all the time!

Honestly this is the best pizza that I’ve had in Austin. My fiancée and I ordered the vodka sauce pizza and pepperoni pizza and it came out delicious. I liked my pepperoni pizza so much that when my fiancée asked for a slice, I truly had to think about it for a second because I wanted the whole pie! Can’t wait to be back (for my own pie😊)

Not one to write reviews but my experience had to shared for others to know. I ordered 2 pizzas for delivery from Uber Eats. The Carbone Copy and Duck Side of the Moon. Had asked for the Carbone Copy to have extra char, but from the looks of it, had the same amount of char as the Duck pizza. On top of that, my first bite into the Duck pizza revealed a bone. If they’re doing the job of deboning the duck meat as opposed to getting meat thats already deboned, they need to do a better job of job. And I have ordered from here before, read the reviews about soggy, floppy pizza before but chose not to listen to them. Terrible mistake because amongst all my other troubles with these pizzas today, they’re exactly as some other people have described. The entire experience has been awful, and Im positive I can spend that type of money elsewhere for better quality.

One of the best Neopolitan style pizzas I’ve had and you can tell everything is homemade. I would give this place 10 stars for service if I could. The owner was super friendly and enthusiastic and you can tell he is passionate about customer service and delivering a high quality product.

Such a cool patio tucked away off South 1st. We got the 50 First Dates- the combination of smoky pork, sweet pineapple, and melted cheese that could stretch for day was JUST what the doctor ordered. A hidden gem for pizza lovers!

Show Me Pizza is hands-down my favorite pizza spot in Austin! 🍕😍 I usually go for their Margherita pizza—it’s always fresh, flavorful, and absolutely perfect. But this time, I decided to try the Pepperoni, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint. The crust was perfectly crispy, the cheese was melted to perfection, and the pepperoni had just the right amount of spice. It looked so amazing when it came out that I completely forgot to snap a picture before diving in! What really makes this place stand out, though, is the heart behind it. I got to meet the owner (Benjamin) while he was working behind the counter, and he was so kind and genuine. You can tell he takes pride in every pizza that leaves the oven, and that kind of passion makes the whole experience even better. The vibe is relaxed and welcoming, with great indoor and outdoor seating options. Whether you’re looking for a casual night out or just some seriously good pizza, this is the spot to be!!

BEST GLUTEN FREE CRUST EVER!!! We came to try the gluten free pizza crust for me and even my fiancée loved it! It was amazing - so flavorful and still doughy like, not all hard and crunchy like most gf crusts! Service was great, pizza comes out so fast! We also ordered the Cesar salad and meatball plate - both incredible. Meatballs are so yummy with the sauce and not dry at all! Very cute indoor seating and outdoor seating with live band playing tonight (Friday)! We were super impressed - we will be back for gf pizza again no doubt.

Still five stars and perhaps even more well earned! The biggest update is they now have their liquor license and serve beer and wine. The selection has improved over the past few months and everything is very reasonably priced. show me continues to be the best Neapolitan pizza you can find in Austin and arguably all of Texas. Their monthly special pizzas are also worth giving a try if the birria pizza is available when you stop in it's everything a birria taco would be except less greasy and no corn tortilla. The owner, Benjamin is a real pro and just a nice guy. Highly recommend the spot.

Alright y'all, we dream about this pizza between visits. It's been our favorite for the last two years. There is so much care put into it and the flavors absolutely smack your tastebuds into what I call my happy place. The DOMO ARRABIATTA MR. ROBOTO is easily our favorite. Spicy and a little sweet. Today we tried the new CARBONE COPY SPICY VODKA! It was delicious, though our Texan tastebuds do not find it spicy. Ambiance is chill, great for friends or a date. Or middle of the day pizza craving. Very welcoming and inviting. Benjamin, the owner, is so friendly and always remembers us. Try it. You'll like it. You'll wanna get more. You're welcome.

The pizza was so warm, fresh and delicious!! I especially loved the Domo Arrabbiata Mr. Roboto, that is a MUST try if you come here. Hot honey on any pizza is a game changer. Service was quick and easy, you check out at the front and they bring the pizza out to you shortly after. The vibe was amazing! It was so beautifully decorated outside with Christmas lights so we wanted to sit outdoor. So chill but fun at the same time. They had live acoustic when we were there. Will definitely come back!

Perfectly sized to share, these pizzas were packed full of flavor. Beware of the hot honey because it is hot! The toppings were incredibly fresh and full of flavor. I could eat the pizza plain the bread is so good and crispy. The pizzas were done cooking and ready to eat so fast I couldn't believe it! Parking in front is minimal but there is street parking close by. The building is on the older looking side but the air conditioning kept us very cool inside.

We stopped by after an event near by. Staff didn't really seem happy to see us but we ordered anyways . We had the margarita pizza. It didn't have any fresh tomatoes which was different than usual but overall it was really good, great cheese and the perfect amount of basil however the basil whole and you had to break it up yourself. Cool patio area with a few games. The pizza came out in 5 minutes I'm not sure if it was a cheese pizza they just reheated and added basil to or what. I would go back but would hope the staff was a little more Edgar to see us as we were 1 out of 2 parties there at the time.

Kind of disappointing. They are very proud of their pizzas, based on price, but bottom line was that the one we shared just wasn't worth it. Nothing particularly bad about this place, but there's a better pizza place down South 1st about a half mile.

Show me Pizza Went to Show Me on a Friday night. The service was very quick for arriving around 7:15pm (busy time). I was with a friend and we ordered a cheese bread, meatball, and cashville hot pizza. Every item came out at once, which isn't the best thing when having several courses. This can be worked on! The cheese bread, in full honesty, was really not good. It had a béchamel sauce that was not good in taste or flavor. The quantity of this sauce was so large that each bite only tasted of this. I wouldn't recommend. The meatballs were amazing! Thick and moist, the sauce was amazing in flavor too. Loved these so much! The Cashville pizza was good! It was spicy, and the sauce on it was tasty and unique. Loved this, but I do have a couple critiques. The pizza was super greasy. Dripping in grease and lots of grease was sitting on the tray too. Another critique was that the pizza was cut into four slices (fourths) , and when you tried to pick up the slices - all the toppings slide off because the crust is very soft and floppy. I probably won't be back, but the cashville pizza and meatballs were good in flavor!

Show Me Pizza has been on my list of pizza in Austin to try for a while now. I finally stopped in during a day when I was avoiding the crowds of SXSW an I had a great experience. Love the small cozy vibe inside & was given a great rec for the spicy sausage & honey pizza. The pizza was ready VERY quickly (within 10 min) as the place wasn't super busy at the time. YUM!!! The pizza was a good size (between a personal & a medium) so my boyfriend & I were able to share as dinner. The crust was soft in the middle & properly charred on the outside. The Italian sausage was crispy & perfectly cooked. The light sauce was so fresh & pulled all the ingredients together! Also tried the tiramisu and it was homemade & very good (not like the plastic-y stuff you find at many restaurants). We will be back to try many more of their menu items! (I hear the cookies are baked fresh daily!)

Oh wow, where do I even begin with my favorite pizza spot in Austin? The personal-sized pizzas are just perfect for one, and it's always a blast to trade slices with friends. I've been here countless times, and I'm surprised I haven't written a review sooner! My go-to is the "50 First Dates" with pineapple and pulled pork, it's absolutely divine. The sweet and salty combination is unbeatable. I've also tried the "Domo Arrabiatta Roboto," which is packed with meat and just the right amount of spice to keep it delicious. Next time, I might just go for a classic pepperoni! You can't go wrong with this place, and I highly recommend it to everyone

Show Me Pizza is my favorite pizza in Austin. I highly recommend eating it at the restaurant because the taste is unmatched when it's hot and fresh! Cashville Chicken Pizza is my new favorite. I normally avoid chicken on pizza but this one is just WOW. So so good!! You MUST TRY. If I opt for carry out, I heat up in my air fryer for a few minutes before diving in.

My favorite pizza in Austin. I am a classic pepperoni gal and love their small crispy pepperoni's. They have perfected their ranch flavor to pair with their pizzas and it's the best combo. They do have vegan options - which is always a plus! Great service and cute spot in South Austin!

Everything that I've had here has been great. Its only downfall is parking but if you don't mind scouting the neighborhood and walking a little bit... It's a really good spot. They also do live music on their patio and it's BYOB. They are in the process of getting their liquor license so I'm looking forward to that Pizza is really good. Priced fairly. It's a local spot. Everyone that works here is really nice and easy-going

Given the ubiquity of vegan cheese options at pizzerias these days, the art of the cheese less pizza is almost entirely lost, or at least, taken for granted. Not so at Show Me Pizza. They manage to pull off an incredible tomato pie, topped only with fresh herbs, that highlights the full depth of flavor in each component. The sauce tastes like real tomatoes (imagine that!) not sugar or a concentrated paste. The crust is thin but substantial, chewy, nicely charred all over, and delicious enough to eat the bones, too. Don't be deceived by it's humble appearance; this isn't a compromise or token offering. It's the pizza you actually want to eat.

delicious and a gluten free option!! the owner was so friendly and helpful. will be back!

Great pizza! We tried a vegetarian one called the Grazing Goat with mozerella, goat cheese, some tiny little pinky nail size flavor bomb peppers, arugala, etc. that was phenomenal. I have to come back for the North Alabama white sauce pizza (I used to live in North AL so I miss this sauce--I think it was called a Cashville Hot Chicken or something). No alcohol or TVs here si I'll probably order to-go next time, but inside was quaint, service was excellent, and their side patio had both fans and heaters for summer/winter--the pizza, which drives this place, was excellent, and I literally keep going to new places all over Austin--this was on the Neapolitan side I think so like Bufalina or DeSano for comparables. I foresee stopping by here monthly for the foreseeable future just to try each of their specialty pies.

Best pizza in Austin and very good gluten free crust. I've been a regular customer for more than a year now - the domo is one of the best pizzas I've ever had. Love the hole in the wall vibe, too. Amazing service, owner will talk to you whenever. Can't recommend it enough. I'm always bringing new friends to try it. Try the domo if you can handle a little spice!

Absolutely love this place! The first time I visited was due to a friend bring me after not being able to stop talking about it and I'm glad he did. The pizza is awesome, I really like the dough and the combination of the toppings. A bonus is that it's byob, so don't forget a bottle or two. If you have room for dessert, I highly recommend the panna cotta. The last time I was there they had a roasted mango version and it was delicious the owner recommended it. Speaking of which, both owners have been there the last few times I stopped in and they made the experience memorable. I haven't had he great customer service like that in a long time, they make you feel like a friend.

We love this place! Pizza, vibes, live music, BYOB... 10/10! We are going to miss walking to this place when we move.

We're constantly ordering from Show Me Pizza on Uber Eats and doing pick up. Today on National Pizza Day I ordered meatballs with pizza, and unfortunately they forgot to give the driver the meatballs with the pizza. Guess what? They called me right away to apologize, then the owner personally drove to our house (15 min away) and delivered a fresh order of meatballs. If this isn't high level customer service, I don't know what is. Not only is their customer service top notch, but as a pizza snob, Show Me Pizza is easily the top 3 best pizza place in Austin! I hope everyone shows them love and continues to support this pizza spot, because they honestly deserve it!

Amazing pizza! My table and I ordered the Grazing Goat and the John Kelso to share and both were very tasty. The dough is nice and spongey and the topping ratio on the Grazing Goat is perfect. Neither were any of the red-sauce pizzas so I'll have to give one of the other types a try next time. Seating was easy to grab and the pizza was out in under ten minutes while still tasting fresh. The 12" pies seem a bit smaller for the price point but the quality is great so I think it was worth it. The indoor AC didn't seem to be working but the patio outside was nice and had a large industrial fan to keep things cool. Mosquitos do come out at night so bring bug spray.

Great spot and fantastic pizza! We loved their monthly special pizza and the outdoor seating was perfect to grab a pie and enjoy some live music (which was also very good!)

Atmosphere is always welcoming and friendly. The pizza is superb no matter what choice you get!!! This is one of the best pizza places in Austin hands-down!!!!

They had me at the cashville hot chicken pizza! I am absolutely in love with Via313 for their Detroit style pizza, but we wanted a Napolitano pizza and I wanted a break from Home Slice. A friend had recommended Show Me Pizza and their menu has some really interesting pies. They have indoor and outdoor dining, so we popped in and ordered the above mentioned pizza, the meatball pizza as well as the house salad. We met the owner and he was so cool and approachable. OMG, the dough!!!!! I do not eat red meat, but I love this dough so much, that I also consumed the dough from the meatball pizza it is that good! It was just perfectly cooked with a little char, but soft and doughy. I now have another favorite pizza joint!

Great NY style pizza and very chill outdoor patio with live music. Pizza is on par or better than Home Slice - I like both. Grew up in NY within walking distance of 3 real NY pizza parlors.

In my ever constant quest for the best pizza, I tried Show Me Pizza, which was just a few blocks from my work. I logged onto their website and saw they had a vegan cheese option - promising. Ordered a pizza (sausage, vegan cheese, kalamata olives). Was one of the best pizzas I have ever had. It's always about the crust first. Score. The wood-fired pizza crust are near perfect - great chew but thin with that perfect toastiness. Next - sauce. I always order red sauce. Another score. Great flavor. Next - vegan Mozzarella - Score #3. They make their own vegan cheese from cashews. It is D - elicious. Have been back several more times - great every single time. The owner is extremely friendly and engaging. Love this place.

Came here for lunch with my coworkers who tend to be picky when it comes to pizza. They absolutely raved about this place. The service was fast and friendly. The food was PHENOMENAL. I was really surprised by the quality and quantity of ingredients on the pizzas. My boss got the 50 First Dates, my coworker got the Meaty Boi, and I got the Domo Arrabiato Mr. Roboto. I love the size of the sausage chunks as well as the combination of spicy arrabiata sauce and honey. The crust got nice and crispy too. Some quick notes: - The parking situation sucks, but the food makes the battle more than worth it! - They only sell 12" size pizzas. - They are BYOB. - You can watch them make your pizza. Dinner and a show! :)

I love pizza. I love this pizza. I was in the downtown area and craving pizza. This popped up and I ordered several and to my surprise was met with a new joy in my life. The staff were extremely pleasant and made sure the order was correct. Now on to the pizza: Beautiful masterpieces, all with deep, complex and complementary flavors. The crust is delicious, smoky and the right amount of chewy. I ordered the cheese sticks, pepperoni, first date and a make-your-own. I can't stop thinking about the wow factor I had during each bite. Even the homemade ranch was the bomb! This is my new FAV in a town with really good pizza!!! I just wish you had a location closer to north Austin.

These pizzas are so delicious! the flavors are incredible, staff is also excellent. They are friendly and you can literally feel the freshness of the products. Do not hesitate on trying these 5star pizzas!

This is really authentic Neapolitan style pizza. Their dough is made from a traditional recipe, a slow process that requires a couple days of rising and proofing. The results speak for themselves. No other pizzeria in Austin has crust like this. The sauce is made from scratch. Delicatessen quality toppings (nothing from Costco) and meats smoked in house will make you want to try every pie on the menu. Even when they're super busy I have never had to wait even 10 minutes. Great food and fast service. Also, you can BYO beer!

This pizza hits all the right spots. The crust is so perfect you could eat it by itself. The sauce tastes like the tomatos were harvested just for you. So fresh and robust. My mushrooms on my pizza were well seasoned with truffle oil and garlic. It all tasted like it was slowly made to give depth and lots of flavor. In a town with a ton of lizza spots Show Me Pizza standa on it's own. It's delicious and all your senses are triggered. I'm looking forward to more, more, more.

Very disappointed... ordered 2 pizzas and cheese sticks through UberEats and received pizza that to me and my partner tastes like burnt oil and sort of a propane/natural gas flavor. Very unappetizing. After all the good reviews we thought this place would be great, but this is a hard pass, both pizzas were just bad on flavor and had a non-food flavors to them that made them inedible. Called to speak to them about this and they said this was the first they had ever heard this complaint, they mentioned it could be a different cheese if they ran out of their standard kind... but this wasn't it, it seems like an issue with cooking as all 3 items tasted like they had been saturated with a non-edible natural gas and smoke flavor. Angrily now driving to home slice now to get replacement pizza, as "Show me Pizza" only offered us to taste more pizza over the phone for a delivery order, doesn't seem like they really wanted to look into what the root cause could be and so I just hung up. Really disappointed, but excited for the much better Home Slice.

I came here because the Grazing GOAT was calling my name. It had all of the elements that I would want on a pizza but somehow didn't hit in the way that I thought I would. Not a big fan of that particular pizza but would be back to try something else! The employees are incredibly kind and you can tell that they care about their customers and know their regulars by name. During our short visit, three different people asked about their cannolis which they were out of. Will be back to try those out

The place is truly THE BOMB. Go! Spread the word. This is the Kelso + added sauce. I know. But it's so good.

Fast, delicious and consistent. We tried an adjacent pizza place one time when we moved into this neighborhood over a year ago. We never went back but when wandering home we saw the sign for Show Me Pizza. Thankfully we gave it a try because it's now our favorite pizza in town! The crust is chewy and delicious. The toppings are unique and pair well together. The 50 first dates is delicious...but skip if you're a pineapple on pizza hater. The apocalyptic honey will melt your face off but you won't be able to stop eating it!

They have a good cauliflower crust option for a vegetarian pizza. It's just super cheesy but otherwise good.

Show Me Pizza definitely lives up to the hype!! People have been telling me about this spot for a while now, and I finally had a chance to go try it. It's a super laid back spot with really delicious pizza!! They're located in the old Torchy's brick and mortar location on S 1st, and it definitely still taps into that relaxed, "Old Austin" & "Keep Austin Weird" vibe that we all cherish dearly. The interior was cute and artsy, and there was a great live band on the patio. BYOB made it extra easy and affordable to have a chill, good time without breaking the bank. Prices overall were very fair too. The pizza was delish!! They nailed a proper Napolitano pizza that felt just like being in Italy. We tried several. Everything was fresh and cooked perfectly. I'm picky about red sauce, which is often too acidic or you can tell it has a lot of added sugar. Theirs was perfect. They also didn't skimp on the cheese, which can be fairly common with this style of pizza. Good balance. The service was great, and Ben, the owner, was there also. He was really welcoming and super friendly. It's obvious he puts a lot of love into both the food and the overall experience he's creating for his patrons. If you're in the area and craving a good pizza and chill vibe, definitely check this place out!!

The pizza here is bomb! The space is kind of small and intimate. The locals were socializing with us and service was great. The parking was a bit challenging. I would definitely come back.

Super disappointed. Ordered pizza tonight for us to enjoy with friends while we watch the game. Came all disheveled in the box as well as very undercooked and certainly not hot. We ended up having to cut it, too - wasn't cut hardly at all, barely saw lines through it. We cut it and put it back in the oven at home to try to get it hot. First impressions are gold and this one was unfortunate. Update: we also found a bone on the pizza. Like absolutely unreal. See photo.

Yes! Finally a solid pizza place in South Austin. We ordered a bunch of pies and everything was perfection. Will definitely be back again!!

First time to try Show Me Pizza and it will be the last. We ordered 2 pizzas and a Tiramisu that we paid $64 dollars for, the pizza was the size of a small dominos and the bottoms of both were burnt so bad that it was all you could taste. Super disappointed.

This place is crazy good. Very unexpected and surprised because I never really hear about it. I built my own with the onion bechamel sauce and it was ssooo good. I love that they have the option to add thyme to the pizza. Def coming back!

Stopped in with a coworker for a quick late lunch. Quick and friendly service. I ordered the Cashville Hot Chicken. It jumped out at me from Yelp and on the menu. Will definitely stop here again in the future.

Definitely one of those places where you need to wear stretchy pants because you WILL eat the entire pizza. I really enjoyed their diverse specialty pizza selection. The Cashville Hot Chicken one was absolutely insane. Not too hot but just enough kick with reasonable amount of chicken that wasn't overbearing! Staff was incredible and super personable as well! Definitely stop in for something new pie wise!

Loved checking this place out while in town from Houston. The cashville hot chicken was great. We all devoured it. It is BYOB which was nice. The counter guy even told us where to go to get some wine. The wait wasn't overly long. Overall the dough tasted good too. My only problem was the heat while inside that even during a heatwave it was cooler to sit outside. The playlist definitely was great. Nice place to sit and chill with friends.

Cheerful service, the kind that makes you feel like you walk out of it happy. I got the pepperoni, right off the bat, flavors were well balanced and the smokiness perfect. The dough was definitely not cooked to perfection though, there was a tinge of rawness to it that took away from the whole experience.

We stopped by Show Me Pizza on a whim and were pleasantly surprised. Both the indoor and outdoor spaces were cozy. The inside reminded me of a diner-space which I loved. We had the pork belly kimchi pizza which was delicious and worked really well flavor-wise. Definitely coming back to try their other fun combinations.

The owner working at the counter is always so friendly. Like, it really makes you want to come back. Amazing patio area. Great vibe. It's unfortunate that it's empty every.single.time we visit. I wish it was busy and exciting. Get the pepperoni pizza--it's amazing. Skip the cheesy bread and cookies--they're not good. Also, skip the Buffalo chicken pizza. I found it pretty underwhelming compared to the pepperoni (which again, is amazing.)

Boy, I'm just one slice in and all I can say is WOW! This pizza not only looks amazing, it tastes the same. Great char on the crust, pepperonis crisp, tasty cheese & sauce. The one thing setting this off is their apocalyptic honey! It's spicy and has a wonderful flavor. I've been hitting different pizza places in ATX, but this is number 1 for sure!