Jan K.
Yelp
I actually had low expectations because of the celebrity "gimmick." But I'm glad I decided to give it a try. It went into my top five after the first bite.
Staff was super-friendly and helpful. After paying, we were directed to the seating area (probably a dozen picnic tables that seat six.) They delivered our steaks minutes later.
Everything was wrapped to-go, and steaming hot in a very sturdy paper bag. Onion rings (flawlessly breaded and fried) were crispy, and the onions still had a "bite." Obviously the cooks know the correct oil temperature and time to fry.
But the STEAKS! We each ordered fried onions and Cooper on seeded rolls (yeah, not OG but after 50 years of eating cheesesteaks, I find this a welcome trend.)
Ribeye was gristle-free, superbly seasoned, and chopped JUST RIGHT. Every bite was a perfect ratio of just-browned onion, gooey cheese, and beef that had JUST enough grease. Distribution across the fresh Aversa roll was perfect. No "empty" bites, and nothing overflowed, leaving me scrambling for a fork to reassemble the steak. This was HEAVY.. but just heavy enough. I was really full with three bites to go, but couldn't stop eating. The roll held up until the last bite, still with a delicate crunch (without the need for toasting.)
I wasn't able to finish the 40 Oz. Stella after the sandwich, but was glad beer was an option.
I have too many favorites (JRP, Angelo's, Johnny's Pizza, Allessio's) to proclaim Skinny Joey's "the best."
But in my half century of averaging one per week, I can honestly say it's in the category of "none better."