Hilary L.
Yelp
I am very sad to write this review and have been putting it off in the hopes that this would change. I have been a loyal local patron of Skylight and a member of Friends With Benefits for many years. I would have given them 5+ stars without a second thought. I have spent a lot of time in this store and have very happy memories here. Sadly, I no longer feel comfortable and welcome here. Since October 7, Skylight has consistently featured incendiary titles such as those in this photo in the front of the store under "Current Events" and "Staff Recommendations." The titles Skylight has elected to feature give only the Palestinian perspective on the history of the region, and many of these titles blame Israel, "Zionism" (and by implication, Jewish people). Some of these subtitles are very aggressive (for example: "How Israel Exports the Technology of Occupation Around the World" and "How Zionism Forged An Apartheid State from River to Sea"). In my many visits to the store since October 7, I only saw a featured book from the Israeli perspective once. The impact of this wall of titles in the aggregate means that any customer seeking to truly understand the attacks of October 7, the war, and the history of the region are instead bombarded with this singular viewpoint on behalf of the bookstore and have no other options or viewpoints to consider (unless they know what they want already and special order it). I expected a lot more from Skylight. The Middle East has a complex history, and there are many interesting books about it written by scholars and historians. Featuring only these titles upon entry to the store has had the impact of alienating local Jewish clientele. I have heard from my neighbors and many customers who feel similarly. Many have brought this to the store's attention in person, over the phone, and in emails and letters. The store's response has been disappointing. They do not see a reason to include other titles about the region alongside these selections for a variety of reasons, and claims this is what sells. Since October 7, I have sought out and have read many books about Israel and Gaza, and will continue to do so. There is always more to learn and understand. I would have bought these books from Skylight, but now I no longer feel good about supporting this store.