Kevin C.
Yelp
I think this place would be a 5 if not for a few missteps.
First the service was excellent. Very attentive, helpful, friendly and pleasant. Nothing was wrong about the service at all.
Next the design of the restaurant (the ambiance) was perfect. One of the nicest interior designs I've seen in a restaurant. A lot of attention to detail to the lighting was obviously made here and it was worth the time invested.
The appetizers were mostly a hit. The Insalata a la Mano (a deconstructed ceasar salad) was delicious. It was very beautifully plated, the flavor combinations were well balanced, definitely recommend this. The Bruschette Miste was also extremely tasty.
The mains were overall pretty good, but for some reason most of us were slightly underwhelmed and none of us could put our finger on why. I got the Gnocchi Senesi. It had a real home cooked feel to it, but I didn't feel like it was something that stood out enough fro it to be worth the whopping $35. The crunchy texture added was a potato skin deep fried, which is *interesting* but not enough. For the most part it was mushy. The dish did not really taste "elevated" to the level of the decor, appetizers, and the other dishes at the table.
My wife got the Mare e Bosco Risotto, which was the star dish in my opinion at our table. If you are a nice restaurant and you put Risotto on the menu, it better be perfect. However, the truffle might be a bit excessive and be unnecessarily driving the price up. Just putting truffle or any other expensive ingredient on doesn't necessarily elevate a dish.
My brother in law got the Spigola al Forno, the sea bass, and it was also excellent. It was so tender, perfectly seasoned, perfectly cooked, etc... Nothing bad to say about it.
My mother in law got the Arista al Finocchio, it was pretty good. It's a pork chop, so I'm a bit biased against them since I don't ever enjoy that cut, but she said it was great, so I'll take her word for it. The vegetables were prepared excellently.
My father in law got the venison special (forgot the specific name of this dish). It was flavorful but the portions were incredibly chincy even for venison. Personally it seemed a bit tough, but the flavors were on point, so I'd still consider it great.
The worst part were the cocktails. For such a beautiful fancy bar with such creative recipes the execution of the drinks was very disappointing. Every single drink we got was overly sweet, the balance was off in the sweetness completely.
My mother in law ordered their Manhattan with low sweetness as the request, and it was sweeter than any Manhattan I would ever prefer. Then my brother in law ordered it even less sweet than hers, it was still sweeter than I think anyone would expect. I think the combination of the two amaros is overpowering the drink and should be reconsidered.
I ordered the punch al latte. and while it was very creative with the golden cereal milk, i feel like the allspice dram should have been subbed out in the recipe for something less sweet as it was overpowering.
I also ordered their old fashioned. Again, far too sweet which was very confusing since it's an old fashioned, it really shouldn't be this sweet (just like the Manhattan).
A few of them got the L'allodola, yet again, too sweet. It's such a bummer because this is a take on the jungle bird which is one of my favorite all time drinks, and they actually used Campari (a lot of places sub in Aperol and it's not the right flavor). The only twists on this over a jungle bird was they used Meyers dark rum (which has quite a bit of sweetness) and added a falernum liqueur (which should be sweet too). It's unfortunate because this one said "balanced" in the menu, yet it was another too sweet drink.
The desserts were all very creative and tasty. Reminds me of the deserts at the former restaurant Arcana in Boulder. Definitely try them out if you go there. I had the Terra Misu and it was filled with flavor and perfect texture. My wife had the chocolate thingy (forgot the name) and it was really well executed. What's funny is the sweetness balance was better in the desserts than it was in the cocktails! None of the desserts were overly sweet!
If they fixed up the drinks this would be an easy 5 stars, but at this price I can't give it 5 stars when the drinks aren't up to par with so many other good places in Boulder.