Rika M.
Yelp
I finally experienced Stella last night for a very special occasion: my daughter's 23rd birthday. I made a reservation a few weeks in advance to ensure that our celebratory dinner would be special. They had our reservation accurate; upon going through the inconspicuous entrance (which surprised my daughter), two ladies at the dark hallway welcomed us with a welcoming/cheerful smile.
I have to say that my expectations were pretty high for this much-talked-about restaurant. As one of my dear friends (who lives in Boulder) told me about it a few times (and he likes Italian), my (or our) coming here was very much hyped up with so much daydreaming.
After that dark hallway, this cave like dining room opens up to you (this restaurant does not have any windows just so you know.) The round bar in the center of it is nicely lit but not too bright. We were sat at two-person table that was a bit small for a nice birthday dinner (I thought). Due to the fact that this restaurant is kind of small (my daughter counted about 11 tables total), this was completely understandable. It's got quite the ambience, however. Its dress code is business casual. I did see some people in their very relaxed attires, but my suggestion is that you dress up until the required code to match the high-end atmosphere.
Our waitstaff, Cassidy was extremely attentive. She took our food allergies very seriously and made a notation of it as she took our order. She also had a partner waitstaff (older gentleman); he made a great suggestion as to which red wine I should have. But this restaurant works as a team. Throughout the whole dining experience, several different people came and went to refill our water glasses, dropped off our food etc. We absolutely lacked nothing during the entire time we were dining.
Now let's go into the drinks/food, shall we???
-My daughter's zero proof cocktail: Spiced Tonic was amazing. And it's friendly priced at $8.
-My wine: Paolo Scavino Nebbiolo. Like I said, Cassidy's partner waitstaff suggested this. Like he said, this can be paired with any type of meal. It's medium-bodied but has got good flavors to your nose. Some spices which I couldn't make of truly entertained my palate. Extremely easy to drink.
-Welcome (Benvenuta??) starter: This surprised us as we, of course, didn't order it. It was a little complimentary welcome dish. I believe it's squash based and it's creamy. This was really good.
-Insalata Stella: Greens with some grapefruit pieces. This was good but nothing extraordinary to be frank. The greens tasted like they were soaked in some dressing so they were a bit soggy. But like I said, it didn't bad.
-Vellutata di Ceci e Scampi: Soup with a large piece of shrimp in the center. This was more for my daughter so she ate the shrimp. She said the shrimp was one of the best ones she has ever eaten. The soup part was nice and hot and it remained hot in the bowl for quite some time. There were some garbanzo beans inside the soup. To me, this was OK.
-Spigola la Forno: This is the seabass and this was excellent. And it's a good portion, too. My daughter and I shared this dish and it was just the right amount of food between the two of us. The veggies that accompanied the fish were excellently seasoned and cooked as well.
-Desserts: We ended up getting two. And one was complimentary or I should say it was on the house (it was for the birthday girl, of course.) We truly appreciated this kind of considerate/kind gesture by the restaurant. Crema Cotta Alla Lavanda is a panna cotta (the complimentary one) had a little candle on it. I personally enjoyed this one; it's funny that my daughter described it as "delicious lotion" (what??) The one we ordered was pistachio creme brulee (Crema Cotta al Pistacchio). At the price of $16, the portion is extremely small. Whereas its taste wasn't impressive, it was good.
Well, overall, we walked away with happy faces. Although we didn't order much, our tab was $132 after tax. This is not something I can do every week but for a special occasion where having the ambience is some good factor to consider, then Stella Cucina might be your place to dine in at.