Casey C.
Yelp
Honestly over priced and overly sweet. We use to be big fans for years but they've been in a steady decline. We use to even joke SLJ was my husband's mistress bc of how often he'd go to and refer their cakes, finding any excuse to order from them.
Cakes... They use to have a lot of interesting cake flavors but they have scaled back their operations so much it's now boring. All you're really getting is some minor variation of chocolate or yellow cake. And what you're getting for the price isn't great. Triple berry is the best and is really carrying them. Even that, I feel like the cake crumbles so much so when you cut it, it falls apart (this wasn't an issue back in the day). The choco/triple berry is meh. The berry cheese cake is meh. Their carrot was ok. Imo you can find better cakes elsewhere for that price, if not cheaper.
We use to always order their "almond roca" cake bc my hubs loved it, but that's discontinued. Their hummingbird cake was good but they discontinued that too. Their German chocolate was good but also discontinued. The coconut was good (though it had the same crumble issue), but they've discontinued it.
Red velvet was ok, they still have that, but it's not a fave flavor in my circle so we have tried that in a loooong time.
Pies not that great, crust too thick.
Tarts are pretty good. They discontinued the blueberry one, but the pear almond one they have is pretty good.
They use to have and Oreo trifle that was a fave in my group but they discontinued that. The tiramisu is ok (honestly not sure if they have that anymore either).
We only go for the triple berry now, and only if its specifically requested. The last time we ordered it they lost our resv but luckily they had one we were able to take, and that too crumbled apart when cut (and no, we are not horrible cake cutters and it wasn't hot/melted).