Tartini Pizzeria & Spaghetteria

Italian restaurant · Lancaster ·

Tartini Pizzeria & Spaghetteria

Italian restaurant · Lancaster ·

Pasta, wood-fired pizzas, tableside cheese wheel theatrics

Information

6327 S Orange Ave, Orlando, FL 32809 Get directions

@eater

391,688 Postcards · 10,991 Cities

Orlando’s 16 Best Pizza Restaurants | Eater Miami

"This Belle Isle stalwart draws folks from all over for its pizzas baked in a unique wood-fired oven that simultaneously lifts and rotates the dough. The cornicione of Tartini’s Slovenian-style pies are blistered, doughy and have a lot more girth to them than the average Neapolitan pie. Dig into the namesake Tartini pizza with Genoa salami, soppressata, sausage, and pepperoni and find out. It’s a thin-crust wonder. Calzones, scored for effect and tear-ability, are like works of art." - Faiyaz Kara

https://miami.eater.com/maps/best-pizza-map-guide-orlando

Tartini Pizzeria & Spaghetteria

@postcardnews

22,027 Postcards · 1,950 Cities

Beloved South Orlando spot with an oak‑wood oven and Slovenian‑influenced technique. Eater highlights Tartini’s blistered crusts; locals come for pizzas as much as the tableside cheese‑wheel theatrics.

https://miami.eater.com/maps/best-pizza-map-guide-orlando/

Best Pizza in Orlando (2025)

Tartini Pizzeria & Spaghetteria

Allison K.

Google

Absolutely wonderful experience dining here for the holidays! They promptly took us back at our reservation time, ALL of the staff was so friendly and kind.The atmosphere and decor were perfect. The food was delicious and came out quickly. Portions are HUGE so you definitely get your moneys worth! I have zero complaints and would definitely come back!

Gregory G.

Google

I have visited this place a few times and it never disappoints, they are a little expensive and parking can be a pain. Everytime I visit Orlando I always make it a point to visit. Their salads are off the chain delicious. Tried their gluten free pasta and salmon and it did not let me down from the tenderness to the seasoning of every bite. Definitely a restaurant worth visiting if you are in the area. Visited me for more restaurant reviews on MealswithGreg on facebook.

B.E. Garmon, S.

Google

This place is incredible! I can't say enough positives about our visit. So just take my word that it is ALL GOOD!!! It really blew my mind when the Robot brought the appetizers to our table!!! NEAT!!! The human service was great also! And the food!!! The Food! The Food! The Food!!! Not only was it incredible; the portions are humongous!!! But it was all so good! Took it home and ate for the next 3 days! This is a MUST DO if you're ever in the Orlando area.

Darren O

Google

Great Italian restaurant with options for everyone. The staff was friendly and welcoming, the restaurant was clean and organized and the food was great with a large selection of wine as well as other drinks. I'm always happy to support local small businesses especially when I have a positive experience and I can tell that they really care about their customers and their food. Definitely give them a try, you won't be disappointed.

Kristi O.

Google

This was the best food we have had in a long time. After traveling all day, we were looking for something good and happened to come across this place. And they did not disappoint. Everything from the ratatouille to the doughnut things for dessert was absolutely delicious. We hated leaving the doughnuts but couldn't finish one more bite. Thank you so much for the fabulous food.

Kaan K.

Google

We got Tartufo and proscuitto pizza. Both of them was PERFECT !! We got their handmade mozzarella sticks too and as a pizza gourmand, loved all their product. We had couple slices left to next day. After quick heat up in the oven. They were still like fresh out from their wood oven. They have good crew as well Highly recommended !!

Lyznette S.

Google

The food was very good and the portion sizes were reasonable. However, I found the prices to be a bit high for the area where the restaurant is located. My main reason for giving 4 stars is the service. For the amount of money you spend, I expected better. The waiter who served us seemed unhappy and had a rather unpleasant attitude.

kevin D.

Google

This place was amazing! I could just eat the marinara with a spoon in a bowl by itself. You are warned the portions are massive. Angeli was a perfect hostess she knew the products and was always there with perfect timing. It was the largest single portion of chicken parm I've ever seen. We had the pasta with the cheese wheel a d I couldn't stop eating it. This place was truly a gem.