Sharon H.
Yelp
Finding a nice restaurant in the Highland/Phoenix Hill area at 3:30 in the afternoon is not easy to do. It seems most everyone closes after their lunch rush and doesn't open again until five. However, we rarely get into that area, and were hungry at 3:30! Who would've thought?! And we wanted to eat something we couldn't get out in "the country," where we live. Fortunately, we thought of The Cafe, where we hadn't been for a few years. a
Really glad that we did! I had not seen their new location under the same roof as Louisville Stoneware & across the street from where they were previously.
Even though I was tempted to stop and gawk at the attention-grabbing bakery products on display as we entered, a sweet lady met us and escorted us back into the restaurant proper. I absolutely loved the colorful posters on the walls, and since we were the only two patrons, there was plenty of time to walk around and look at things to our hearts' content. While there is also a bourbon bar, that's not something either of us cares for, so we ignored it. Writers option!
We had barely gotten seated when a server took our drink order and left us with menus after a debate with one of the other servers as to whether we qualified for the breakfast/lunch menu or the dinner menu. The breakfast and lunch won, but we also got a look at the dinner menu to decide if we would like to eat dinner there sometime. We would.
I ordered the Stephen Foster sandwich, which is basically their version of a Hot Brown with country ham and eggs. I was a little concerned that the ham might be a bit chunky and overwhelming, but it was more shaved than chunky, and it was delicious. The eggs added an extra exciting element that I'm not used to in a Hot Brown. I wouldn't have minded a little extra tomato, but I couldn't finish the whole plate, so I really didn't need anything more!
Hubby ordered the chicken sandwich, well done, along with some tater tots. He was quite pleased with his meal and cleaned his plate in short order.
We had seen the available cakes for the day as we entered the restaurant. Although we didn't have room for dessert there, they were more than happy to prepare a couple of slices for us to take home. We haven't tried the cake yet, but will probably have it for dessert for at least two, and possibly three, days! It was difficult for me to pass on the Italian Cream Cake, because I have had it in the past and know that it is delicious. However, I couldn't resist the Strawberry Cake. I will try to remember to come back and add that to this when I have eaten it all!
My review for the restaurant would easily be a 5 star, but the facility is still under construction and the restrooms weren't available. The facility in the communal area wasn't very clean with garbage cans all overflowing onto the floors. Hopefully, the restaurant's restrooms will be completed & cleaner when we return.