KG
Google
Second visit, and The Cellar continues to deliver a consistently excellent experience.
We had a 6:00pm reservation but arrived right at 5:00pm when they opened. Instead of waiting, we decided to start at the bar and learned they offer happy hour daily and yes, even on weekends! The bar itself is intimate and fills up fast, so we snagged one of the nearby cocktail tables instead.
Lilly was our server during HH and she was wonderful. I ordered the Night Train- a spirit-forward cocktail that was bold, sophisticated, and perfectly on brand for this elegant, speakeasy-like space. The chocolate garnish on top was a nice touch. I also enjoyed a glass of Cab from the HH menu. My boyfriend went with a classic Manhattan, which felt like the perfect fit for the moody, old-world vibe of the bar.
We hadn’t eaten all day, which led to some questionable (but delicious) decisions. Watching what the couple next to us ordered off the HH menu didn’t help either. We ordered the bread and the HH mac and let me tell you what a big mistake that was! This is how you ruin your appetite, people!!!
Once we moved into the dining room, Caden took over as our server. He was friendly, fast, and efficient. We ordered everything at once, and he expertly coursed it out for us.
What we ordered:
Grilled Spanish Octopus Skewers – Delicious overall, though the octopus was just a tad dry. Still enjoyable and not a deal breaker.
Nordic Blue Salmon – My boyfriend told me to order something else since I eat salmon all the time… I ignored him! Zero regrets!! The salmon was perfectly cooked (medium, just how I like it), and the roasted squash and oyster mushrooms complemented the dish beautifully. Unfortunately, I only managed two bites before surrendering. Happily boxed it up though and it held up incredibly well the next day.
10oz Cape Grimm Filet Mignon – My boyfriend’s order and a recommendation from Caden. He usually doesn’t gravitate toward filet mignon, but he absolutely loved it.
For dessert, we ordered the Sticky Toffee Pudding, and it was heaven in every bite.
The Cellar has been part of downtown Fullerton since its grand opening in 1970, originally built into the underground space of a historic brick building. With its stone walls, vaulted ceilings, and European wine-cellar ambiance, it’s easy to see why it has endured for over five decades.There’s a reason this restaurant has stood the test of time and remains a staple of Orange County fine dining 55 years later.