Bill L.
Yelp
Where do I even start with this place...when I first heard about this place I just assumed it was a shop where you go buy cheese to take home to eat and cook. I thought, ehh I'm not that big into fancy cheeses so I may pass on checking this place out. It was after checking out Yelp reviews that I found out they serve actual meals and food here along with their full service cheese counter (like a local butcher but for cheese).
We walked in and at first it appeared to be just a busy cheese shop with a good number of people waiting to order their cheeses and meats. A kind staff member recognized our confusion immediately and asked if we were here to get an order or to eat lunch, we happily said we were here for lunch and we were seated at a table.
The decor is very...cheese shop-like haha, and I've never been in a cheese shop, it was nice and "real". There aren't too many tables so I wouldn't be surprised if they lacked seating some days for lunch or dinner. The staff members are all extremely friendly and knowledgeable about the products they serve. We had a few questions regarding the menu and everything was answered to our satisfaction.
For those who are wondering, they have a separate menu for those eating in that is not on the menu board at the counter. Also, for those eating in, anything on the counter board is free game to order for your meal. Same goes for all their drinks and wines.
I ordered the standard Toastie, which is a grilled cheese sandwich and I believe the item they are best known for. You can added different meats to it, but I just kept it plain. Obviously I had to get a cup of tomato soup with it because you have to eat grilled cheese sandwiches with tomato soup or else the fabric of the space time continuum will rip.
IT WAS AMAZING! THE TOASTIE AND THE SOUP OHH , NOT GONNA EXAGGERATE, BEST GRILLED CHEESE IVE EVER HAD IN MY LIFE! The texture, flavor, everything was perfect!
My wife ordered the special Mac and cheese which was a special that day. It was a bit pricey and the dish itself was complex with complex ingredients. It tasted pretty good and exotic, but for the price I would stick to their simple dishes which I know they will knock out of the park. We also got two drinks, ginger ale and root beer, they were both good and would recommend them.
We are counting the days until we make a repeat visit back here! So many things I want to try! You will love the atmosphere and staff as well, I'm glad our town has a place like this!