The Crow's Nest

We decided to come to Crow's Nest after seeing it posted so much on social media and let me tell you, it is worth the hype. Our food and drinks were absolutely amazing - it was the best dinner we had on our trip. In addition, the service was phenomenal. We sat at the bar and the bartenders were very attentive and kind. We had a great experience with Chelsea, who went above and beyond what any other bartender/server had done during our stay in Montauk. We will definitely be back here!

Overall, we had a lovely stay. The Crows Nest has a beautiful little property tucked away off one of the main roads. Since we stayed at the hotel, we were allowed to make a reservation. Delicious food and drink - I asked the waitress for her recommendation and she promoted the lobster pasta and the scallops - very satisfying! Yes, everything is a little overpriced, but it’s all worth it and it was incredible :) the pictures of the rooms on their website do them no justice, the king bedroom was really cute and so was the bathroom! Plus, we were just a few minutes away from the main street, shopping, and a bunch of beaches :)

Wow just wow. I had high expectations for this place. From the hype around town. Recommendations from the buddies at the beach. But then I arrived and what did I see? A CULT! Everyone doused in white. Me? I was in black with some swim trunks on. But don’t you worry they sold their cult cloaks at the front for a small fee (your next 5 pay checks). But it’s okay they sat me anyway even though I didn’t meet the crows nest dress code (white). I hold the menu with my hands shaking in fear. What am I doing here I thought… then my head shoots to the left! The owner or maybe the cult manager on site laughing at me! Unbelievable… then some cult rookie comes over and asks if I want their “special” sparkling water. Stunned I couldn’t answer. “Just water please” I reply. Next thing I know he brings me water from the tap! I go back to looking at the menu. In horror I realized I couldn’t dine there as the guy at the front stripped me of my goods. “Dammit”I thought. Now I can’t join the locals and gain my acceptance into the cult. I call a waiter over and told her of my troubles. “I think I’m going to swap out” I said. She replies “oh you want to move outside?”. I say, “no, I mean home!”. As I say that I fly out of my seat throwing it on the floor. I run towards the counter grabbing my wears that was stripped from me. I get into my Chevy Camaro and speed out of the parking lot knocking over some cones disappearing never to return again.

This is one and done for me. The entire staff is just miserable as if they don't want to be there. The restaurant and property is just filled with young woman taking photos for instagram. The cocktails are $27 which is convenient considering the wait for a table is 2 plus hours. This is a tourist attraction. On a positive note the lamb kebab is VERY good.

Ok so I was supposed to meet someone on a date and he bailed (boo! Why are men so fickle?)! Instead of giving up, I decided to take myself on a date. I was lucky enough to meet some girls to chat with, and the bartender was empathetic- I don’t drink but I ordered the lamb. As a New Yorker, the best part of this was the outdoor scene. I needed stars. And fires. Both needs were met. And I would definitely eat the food again. I didn’t stay in the hotel.

Save your time. They are rude and nasty. We first get there it’s not busy at all there’s multiple tables outside available. The hostes goes to sit us inside and we asked if we go can go outside she made up a bunch of lies saying they aren’t seating outside yet until it’s busy (there were like 6 tables filled outside) I said but there’s people outside she then said it’s only big parties. We were table of 5. Then she lied saying there’s no wait list either for outside until later. I just turned around and didn’t speak to her and went back to the front and the lady said it’s no problem to sit outside. Not sure what the other girls problem was. Then the waitress comes we place our order for a bunch of apps and drinks and she makes a comment like oh well we really prefer for people to order meals. But it should be fine. Like what? Is she kidding? Then she never came and checked on us once. There rude and nasty. Don’t even go

I was nervous when I heard you can’t make reservations but once I arrived, I realized I could hang out on that property all night and not even care. Their scenery is gorgeous, they have bars outdoors that you can grab drinks while waiting, and tables to hang at. The drinks were SO refreshing. Expensive (!!) but so fresh! Their food was amazing. The Lobster Tagliatelle is a must try! Honestly, we had a large group and ordered so many items and not one thing disappointed.

We take no reservations. No worries. Waiting is part of the experience: sooking up the atmosphere. Cocktails by the beach, sunset views, and people-watching. The perfect comfort food proved to be worth the hype. Lobster tagliatelle was perfection, and the swordfish kebab? A Montauk unicorn—rare, flawless, unforgettable. A true Montauk foodie pilgrimage. Would give it 6 out of 5 well-dressed crows if I could.

Had dinner at the most beautiful spot this past weekend with friends! Crows neck in Montauk was a spot recommended by a friend who frequents the area and she told us we had to check it out. This resturant had one of the most beautiful sunsets I've seen and the food is quite lovely as well. I especially enjoyed the lobster tagliatelle, tuna tartare, and the local beats salad! Be sure to come early because they don't take reservations and grab a drink by their beach bar and watch the sunset!

We had a girls dinner (4 of us) here this past weekend and the food and drinks were delicious. I ordered a watermelon mock-tail which was so refreshing! We ordered various appetizers, entrees, and desserts and loved every single dish. I will highlight a few of my favorites below: *The ricotta is a must! It was phenomenal! *The lobster salad was one of the best we've had while in Montauk. *The lobster pasta was also delicious, definitely a must! *The blueberry cookie gelato was amazing! In addition, the location and setting is beautiful, you can walk down and sit by the water if you want. Also the service was pretty good for a busy Sunday; our server was so sweet and she gave us great recommendations! I would definitely return if ever in Montauk again!

Waiters were nice, service was EXTREMELY fast (I was honestly surprised how fast the food came out), and very nice ambiance right next to Lake Montauk (there is also a lakeside bar if you are waiting for a table)... but waiting more than 1 hour (heard it is up to 3 hours) for mediocre food is kind of absurd. For apps: -Whipped Ricotta (4/5): favorite dish of the night. Sourdough was toasted and ricotta was delicious, but definitely had better in the city. Honey could have been more evenly spread across the ricotta and sourdough could have been warmer -Fattoush salad (3/5): decent... refreshing and liked the za atar crisps, but very average to be honest -Heirloom tomatoes (3.5/5): tomatoes were a bit underwhelming... they did not taste as good as the tomatoes we had at other restaurants in Montauk, but refreshing nonetheless and loved the stracciatella -Mini mezze (1.5/5): would pass on this. did not really like the dips at all, the only saving grace was the naan was served warm For mains: -Lobster tagliatelle (3.5/5): pasta not cooked too well, but I did enjoy the chunks of fresh lobster and the breadcrumbs -Steak (3.5/5): some parts were cooked better than others (fattier parts were better), but overall, pretty mid steak. a bit chewier and tougher in some parts -Halibut (3/5): kind of more touch, less soft than I would have liked Overall, great ambiance by the lake. I would come here to check out the vibe but the food is definitely not worth the same

I stepped off the sprinter van after a 3 hour ride from NYC into the gravel parking lot at the Crows Nest, excited to see what Montauk was all about. It was my first time in the Hamptons, and my buddy brought me as a +1 to his little model party thingy that Banana Republic was hosting. He shook some hands, kissed some babies, and took some pictures while I checked the weather app on my phone. We walked down a grassy hill towards the water to catch the last remnants of the sun. A wood-burning fire on a sandy beach, glassy water with sail boats in the distance, wooden cabanas on the beach, and well dressed beautiful people everywhere had me feeling like I was in the Great Gatsby or a Lana Del Rey song. I was sitting there nodding my head as if to say "yeah, I get the hype." We had wristbands for free drinks, but were STARVING as there was no food provided. When I went to re-up on my Watermelon Tequila drink (hehe), I ordered a Mezze appetizer plate that I saw some people grubbing. I laughed when bro rang up the Mezze plate at $50. "Actually, I'm okay. Thank you though" I said, completely exposing myself as a brokie. That's the one thing about the Hamptons, it will make you feel your brokieness quick. I lit up one of my little cigars to make myself feel better. Who's gonna know I'm a brokie if I'm in Banana Republic linen smoking a little Cohiba? Once the sun went down, we went back inside and I watched my homie politic with the best of them. It was inspirational. One of my favorite things about these kinds of nights is meeting people at the beginning, then seeing them go mask off once they get all liquored up lol. The creative industry is so interesting. I would love to do an exposé on it one of these days. Well, more of a BTS than an exposé, but you feel me. So many moving parts to it. A lot of cool people and a lot of phonies. I have a lot to say, but this Yelp Review at the Crows Nest is not the place. We got back in the sprinter van and went to Hideaway for the after party. Crows Nest was cool though. Everyone should come here once. Ig @jnov_ Tiktok @jnov_reviews

This is probably the only place that I'd happily pay $26 for a cocktail at. The Crow's Nest is a magical spot with the best sunset you've ever seen. It's romantic and dreamy, situated on a hill that overlooks the water, with a beach that you can sit and lounge at situated at the foot of the hill. There are no reservations at this place and parking is minimal. Both times that I've come here I've arrived shortly after seating opens at 4:30 to snag a parking spot, grabbed an overpriced cocktail and hung out at the beach for an hour, then put our names down in order to eat around 6:30/7. If you get here any later than 6 pm, I would say you're probably not eating until 9/10 if at all. Though again, $26 for a cocktail is a crime, I have to say the watermelon mint cocktail they offer really hits the spot on a summer day. On my last visit we arrived at 4:45, checked in to see that they were still offering immediate seating, headed down to the beach bar to have a cocktail and snagged a lounge chair by the beach, then put our names down at the list at 5:30 and were seated around 6:30. If you're coming here, dress to impress. The best fashion show I've ever experienced is waiting on the bathroom line at The Crow's Nest. Women decked out in designer everything, designer bags and shoes that are worth thousands and dresses that look like they came off a runway. It's really a sight to see. This year we started off with the whipped ricotta appetizer which is so stupidly good. I don't understand how you can get bread and cheese to taste this incredible, I really don't. The ceviche and beet salad were also standouts, the fish was fresh and the beets were refreshing. We split their famous lobster pasta which was worth the $42, and topped everything off with the smores dessert. If you're looking for a leisurely dinner, this place is not it. They are here to turn tables, and if you're not eating fast enough they'll come by and try to take away almost full plates, so keep up. Definitely a spot to try at least once.

Wonderful atmosphere and beautifully decorated. Boho vibes with a little beach area. Defs pricey but yummy - we got a lot of plates to share- pretty big portions didn't finish near all of it. Fav was the corn and scallops dish- flavor was amazing. Enjoyed lamb kebab, chicken kebab, tomatoes, salad, and more. Waiters were super friendly and relatively quick. We came early and out in our names- no resys. Overall recommend

We had a great experience in this best friend. The staff is super good, friendly and very attentive. We ordered a bunch of stuff and refilled that everything reached our satisfaction. This place is a pretty cool ambience. You should go check it out because it's good for family and friends together And especially for date nights. This is amazing place to take somebody there.

If you haven't been to Crows Nest yet, you're truly missing out. This restaurant is, without a doubt, the standout culinary gem of the area. From its consistently delicious dishes to its diverse menu, Crows Nest never fails to impress. One of the highlights of dining here is the breathtaking outdoor area. It's especially enchanting during sunset, where you can enjoy a glass of wine while the kids have fun running around on the beach. The ambiance is simply unbeatable. When it comes to the food, you can't go wrong. The Mezze is an absolute must-try, and the lobster tagliatelle and scallops are nothing short of fantastic. If you're a fan of fresh seafood, the raw bar is a real treat. Every dish I've tried has been a delight. I wholeheartedly recommend Crows Nest. If you're looking for a memorable dining experience, this is the place to go. Trust me, you'll thank me later!

Long wait times but I was able to grab a couple seats at the bar. Service at the bar is amazing, extremely attentive staff. The drinks were fun but a little weak, but the food was great! Pasta was delicious the ribeye was cooked perfectly! The highlight was the whipped ricotta which was so light and flavorful-drizzled with honey and a hint of spice. Beware of pricing- we were offered more bread for the ricotta and charged $10- which was fine but I wished they would have disclosed it. Overall I had a great experience and I definitely find myself coming back again.

If you want to be treated as less than human by a group of teenagers this is your place. After hearing about Crow's Nest from friends and family, my group of friends and I decided to give it a try on our annual trip out here. At a first glance it was absolutely beautiful, the employees at the front desk were great, and the drinks we had while waiting for our table were pretty good. From the second we sat down, our young waitress had us out to be criminals. I don't know if she overheard us talking about how horrible the oysters were but after that she had the worst attitude towards us. The Entrees were good and I made peace with the experience until the waitress decided to chase my friends and I down to make sure we signed the receipt? When has that ever happened to anyone? Anyway, if you want to be belittled by teenagers go to your local high school. If you want better oysters go... anywhere else in Montauk. This place is only worth it for ambiance and *maybe* drinks. But beware of dog shit in grass.

Good views, decent food, not quite warranted by the outrageous pricing and an unprofessional waitstaff. My friends and I were met with suspicion early on. Our waitress said "you're good to stick around until your food comes out, right?" immediately after we ordered. After paying for our meal, as we were leaving the restaurant, our waitress chased us out and accused us of not leaving a signed check-- only to find out, upon investigation, that a different server had picked up our signed check. Tip to the local Montauk parents: just give these kids an allowance.

I adore this restaurant the food was outstanding and the fire pit was delightful. Great family, great conversations and wonderful layout- Wonderful service another winner!

This is a gorgeous restaurant. It may just be the most gorgeous restaurant. Indoor, outdoor and beach seating are all amazing. Here you'll find a plethora of would be Instagram models happily assuming various poses for both themselves and others. It's a scene that I found to be fun but I can see where someone else mind find it mildly annoying. The table wait was 1 1/2 hours so we made our way down the grassy knoll to the beach sitting area. Here you'll find teak seating, fire pits and a casual bar. Ordered a couple of drinks and a Mediterranean platter to nibble on while we waited for our table. Price wise this isn't for the faint of heart. Drinks are $30-$35 with a shot of top shelf tequila approaching $100. Basically, it's a damn fortune. But it's Montauk, it's the summer and I don't think a hell of a lot of their patrons were overly concerned. Parking lot is a straight up shit show with cars parked randomly and extremely close to one another. Backing up was a chore and I can't see how there aren't frequent accidents with anxious diners trying desperately to ditch their cars. I will definitely return next visit as the ambience, food and service were exceptional but again, that experience comes at a hefty price.

We went there for dinner and the service was great but the menu was ok, the price was $$$$$. The food was not worth the price in any way! The grounds were beautiful and so were the people but not down to earth at all. It was like a fashion show.

Crow's Nest is as good as it gets. And this isn't a "5 stars for Montauk" rating - it's an all time rating. Maybe we hit it on a good night, maybe we did everything right? Here's how we experienced the Crow's Nest: - Arrived at 4:15PM for a party of 19, broken into tables of 8 (women), 7 (men) and 4 (older kids) - the younger kids roamed the property (supervised down by the cute swing set) and never did sit - which is good since there really aren't any good children menu items. - Some in our party knew the menu and knew how to order. We started with a few table appetizers, whipped ricotta (I love you), tuna and fluke tiradito (Peruvian for sashimi). We then moved onto a pasta course of lobster tagliatelle and Moroccan lamb pappardelle - out of this world. Then for mains, we ordered scallops and ribeye. The women's table had the halibut and said it was among the best they've had. For desert, they offer a platter which has a small taste of everything, which was perfect. And their coffee / espresso was perfect. The tastes of the dishes were all amazing. I remember zoning out in the conversations, not able to pay attention, because the food was so delicious and I couldn't focus on anything else. - We had the MOST AMAZING server- she was the most professional, down to every single detail. How she served, how she cleared, silverware service, deep knowledge of the menu, and awareness of what was going on at our other two tables. She wasn't a seasonal person trying her had at serving, she knew what she was doing, and it made a tremendous difference. She wasn't "chummy", she never disappeared, and she was around whenever needed. I can understand the mixed reviews - as most people might think it is crazy to deal with all of these policies that Crow's Nest puts in place to be as fair as possible - to those people I would say - you are a guest of their experience - and I suggest you appreciate it. Just because you're paying alot of money, you don't get to dictate the terms of this (perfect) restaurant. And our check was on the higher-end. You can see the menu online, and don't need me to tell you that. As for the decor - everything, every tiny detail, is exquisite. Montauk-esque, with a high-end touch, all with a North African-ish vibe (think Moroccan / Tunisian, however, I'm no expert) - this is down to the font they use on the menus.

Beautiful food, beautiful people. Lovely area. Expensive & ridiculously long waits. We arrived at 5:30pm and told we had a 1hour & 45 min wait. We went down to the bar near the water and order drinks. We ordered their special Watermelon drink and added vodka ($30 each with a small tip). We tried to wait. We walked by the water but it was too crowded, no seating available not staff to help with the chaos of people roaming around. We finally gave up 2hours later. We later got a text over 2 1/2 hours later that our table was ready. We never made it for dinner. We left at 2 hours & 15 minutes later for Gossmans which was fabulous, not crowded and 1/3 of the price. I was told you needed to get there by 4 - 4:30pm to get in line for a 5:30pm- 6pm seating.

My friend and I go to Montauk every summer and I can't believe we had never tried Crows Nest. To start- it is absolutely beautiful both inside and outside. The crows nest is on a huge property. That is literally breathtaking and beautiful. If the weather is nice, definitely sit outside. They give you carrots and hummus, and honestly my friend and I were laughing at the portion size, but then we remembered we were in the Hamptons. After asking several staff, what they recommend, the whipped ricotta appetizer was a must and I will be dreaming about it for the next several months. It literally was so delicious and I wish I had some right now, HA! Our scallop entrée was delicious as well. We ended up splitting all the plates we got. The scallops were tender and cooked perfectly. Seeing queen Alix Earle herself was the highlight of the night, LOL! Make sure to make your way down to the bar at the bottom of the hill for a nice drink and people watching afterwards. Its right on the water and so pretty down there!

Good food, great ambiance. Beautiful sunset on the lake Whipped ricotta & Lobster pasta were delicious

Amazing ambience! Wait for a table was 2 hours but after catching the sunset at the shore we found a spot at the bar. They ended up calling us for our table after only an hr and 15. Food is pretty solid and delicious drinks! Only downside is this is a very expensive venue, not atypical in these parts but being an nyc resident I'm used to a high price point cocktail but 2 drinks ran us $70. If it wasn't our anniversary that would be very hard to justify and keep me!

Overpriced and overhyped. The prices are high even for Montauk and the service is not at all anything above average. This is a place to see and be seen but I guess we are over it because its is all too scripted and the management themselves make fun of people sho come to Montauk for the scene so why bother. Some of the dishes were very good including the famous whipped ricotta, carrots and lobster pasta but those dishes are everywhere now and done better in some spots. The addition of some lakefront seating while waiting was smart but it also gives them another chance to sell overpriced drinks.

Ambiance is great! Service is terrrible and the food is subpar especially for prices. The lobster salad was delicious but the swordfish had as much flavor as an ice cube. The waitress said we had to order all of our food at once but then allowed the table behind us to order their appetizers separately. We couldn't get another drink we had to ask another waitress to help us. The staff has zero personality almost as if it's uncool to be friendly.

This restaurant is a must if you're in Montauk. Service was next level- Everyone who works here actually acts like they wanna be there. The male host came and got us seated very quick. Our waitress Hagan was awesome, knowledgeable about the menu and even called us an Uber because both of our phones were dead. Food- Amazing and all good portions. The lobster tagliatelle was delicious, burrata was off the charts. Place is a must.

We arrived early, as it is a 1st come 1st serve situation. Upon arriving I was definitely taken by the vibe and decor. After being seated we were approached by a personable young server, who asked about drinks/cocktails. We were a bit surprised when one of our party asked for a Bloody Mary, to find out they don't serve them (no tomato juice). I asked for a drink that required a muddler, to be told they don't muddle. After perusing what we found to be an interesting menu, we decided on the charcuterie board, which was supposed to have smoked duck, soppresata, ham and sausage (and other charcuterie board staples, but no cheese). Let me state here that I am a person who doesn't eat beef or pork, but my companions do. That being said, I was all about the smoked duck. When the board arrived there was no duck, and when we asked the server, he at first said the ham was the duck. After checking with someone he came back to advise that in fact the duck was missing, as the didn't get their duck that day. I feel that it was bad form to not tell the guest that that ingredient was missing before serving. We did end up refusing the dish. It is not an inexpensive dish. We then ordered an alternative appetizer (which was just ok). The entrees were fine, well prepared and presented. I do feel that we were there a little too long, but I'll attribute that to the confusion. I assume this is considered a high end venue. The server(a young man) was pleasant, and I got the impression he was fairly new. He seemed compassionate to the issues we were encountering, but perhaps further training would be effective with regard to responding to requests, such as "please let us know the situation before...". That being said, I was visually pleased with the ambiance, but this experience as a whole has left me with a bad taste.

As a visitor, we had a wonderful meal at Crow's Nest. If you get there and there's a waitlist, head down to the little bar by the water. You walk all the way down a hill to the water and it's super cute with all of the boats on the lake. (You can't see the beach bar from the restaurant but just walk down the hill and you'll find it.) We ate scallops and drank wine and it was all so delicious.

Awesome date night. Food was very good but the fatty part of the steak was too chewy, the wait for 2 people was 2 hours so we ate at the bar . The views are gorgeous , you have to see this place in person, it's on a hill that leads to a beach with a fire pit, just fantastic spot over all

Came here for dinner last night with my girlfriend and three other friends. When we got there they told us it would be a 1.5 hour wait (it ended up being 2), but honestly the wait here isn't that annoying because drinking in the lawn while you wait is a great experience by itself. The crowd is a mix of families (likely rich) and young people (either rich, with rich families, or with credit cards). Rumor had it that Scarlett Johansen was here last week. We sat by a guy from million dollar listing. The food was incredible. For appetizers we had oysters, tuna, beet salad, and burata. For my main I had the lobster tagliatelle- absolutely incredible.

We went on a Saturday night at 6:30 and got seated 7:30. Didn't have a problem with waiting as we were expecting it and there is a lovely beach bar that you can grab drinks and wait at. Highlight was our server Nile who was so lovely. Drinks were good and food was good. Like everyone said it's expensive but you're paying for the great vibes!!! Shout out to Nile again for making our dinner experience wonderful :)

5 stars for the setting. 4 stars for the food. 3 stars for the price tag. We were lucky enough to snag a cabana on the beach so the kids played in the sand/water the whole night. If you're not on the beach, you're at a table on the grass with no water view. I'm told it's full because of the atmosphere. If there weren't any tables available by the water, I don't think it's worth it. Cocktails were delicious as was the majority of the food. Once you sit, you order from the website and then pick it up and bring to your table with paper/cardboard plates, napkins, utensils. Mezze plate, ceviche, ricotta toast, kale salad were all delicious. Lobster pasta, scallops, halibut, and vegetable curry were also great. Kids pasta with butter was a late addition for the fancy 6-year old palate but it was flavorless (probably why she liked it), and rang in at a whopping $30 after tax and tip. A beautiful spot with delicious food for a great socially distanced evening out - just be prepared for an expensive night.

$$$$ but GREAT quality food and amazing vibes.. feels like your in a vineyard somewhere in Italy. Beautiful setting. Drinks were ok but the whipped ricotta, the chicken kebab and lobster pasta is a must! Also service was GREAT.

We have been here a handful of times. The quality and vibe has gone downhill, sadly. I remember a pasta dish with spicy lobster that was taken off the menu in subsequent years. This dish is now offered with a tiny bit of crab and intense heat. Sorry, it will not be this place that rips me off the beach to shower and be in queue at 4:30pm for dinner. We are glad to drop some coin for dinner when it is worth it. Beautiful location though!

Lovely food and lovely staff! Perfect setting with a view :) We got the steak and lobster pasta which was delish!!

Worst attitudes ever ... we didn't ever get to the food! The hostess was so mean upon arrival, we were a party of 10 ... I had a plastic cup with me from my boat with ice water in it ... she says to me: "Ummm jussssst for the opticsssssss ... can you get rid of the sippy cup?" I wanted to smash her ... plastic, fake, ugly vibe ... And we didn't even get to the food.

Although we didn't get here in time for sunset, we found a table to sit at right away at 830pm on a Saturday evening (first come first serve self seating due to COVID). You have to order what you want on line and then pick it up at the counter for take out, which you then bring back to your table and enjoy! I got a watermelon cooler, which I love drinking during summers and my friend got a margarita. For starters we got the Mezze platter and Montauk local sea bass ceviche, both good. For entrees we got the Moroccan vegetable curry, black truffle linguini, and the scallops. I didn't try the veggie curry, but I did enjoy my linguini and the scallops were cooked and seasoned perfectly. The vibe was great. It was so nice out! Next time I would try and come back to get in time for the sunset, which my friends tried going the next day (Sunday), and apparently they were at capacity. I guess you gotta get there early and hope to get a table..

The reason this gets 4 stars: ANASTASIA. She made our meal so special. The rest? The host staff, the bar staff at he beach? Act like they're doing you a favor. The food coming out of the kitchen is outstanding. Anastasia, outstanding. The rest? Meh. (And the smoke wafting over us from the fire pit? Yuck!)

Great spot for a sunset. The drinks are good. They have outdoor fire pits and a bar that's open till just after sunset

I would never go back there for dinner. I expect a place like this to charge an exorbitant amount for their food because it's located on the lakeside where you can watch the sunset and that's very nice. But as far as the food, it's totally not worth it. I ordered the chicken kebab and they were the driest pieces of chicken I've ever had. The little squirt of yogurt sauce that comes with it does nothing for it. You must have a lot of saliva in your mouth to bring down the dry chicken. I would just go there for the sunset and the watermelon cooler drink.

What a wonderful place! So picturesque I could stay there for hours. My group of 6 shared starters and mains. Everything was fresh and delicious, but the standouts were whipped ricotta and lobster tagliatelle. Our server was very charming and accommodating. We arrived at 6:00 on Sunday and seated on the patio right away. Pricy but worth it (IMO) for the memorable experience- take photos!

I'm going to start with how unacceptable the oysters were. Never in all my years of enjoying oysters have I encountered a paper-thin, quarter sized slime trying to pass itself off as an oyster. We didn't have the opportunity to express this disappointment because the waitstaff completely avoided us after sensing our frustration. It's obvious there's nobody managing this place, which is inappropriate for Crow's Nest's reputation and the pedestal it puts itself on. The setting is beautiful, but the execution is poor. After our meals (which were fine) we settled into the experience and let go of our bad first impressions. That was until we were chased down and accused of not paying by our server. instead of checking in with her coworker who took our bill from us, she spring-boarded into the assumption that we were stealing our meal. This final encounter was really what summed up our experience & how we were treated all night

One of the most beautiful hotels and dinner spots we have been at. Our room was super cute and the bed was super comfortable. The staff was friendly and accommodating. The views are just breathtaking and picture perfect. The restaurant was great kick ass drinks and tasty food. We had a great time can't wait to go back.

As you hear the gravel beneath you shift and grate, you step out of the car to approach the hostess stand and inquire about a table. You'll be told to wait for 30 minutes and while waiting, could order a $26 cocktail from the bar or make the more economical choice with a $14 beer. You'll tip toe around the dog poop that owners leave on the ground as you get to your table. When at the table, you are met by an under experienced server and presented with a menu that has some good options. You'll peruse the menu and settle on the ribeye, cooked medium rare. When the ribeye comes out, it will be cooked with three different temperatures throughout, and the entire thing tastes burnt as it has spent way too much time over an open flame. Last but not least, you may be chased out of the dining area by the server because the other waitstaff misplaced your signed check. After beating the theft allegations, you'll post a picture of dinner and the view on instagram, because you can't let your followers down. Bon appetit!

Never had nothing short of an excellent experience here in the 6 or 7 times I've dined for dinner. Service, food, ambiance, sunsets, all A+. Only wish they took reservations.

Wow. The ambiance is rustic and charming overlooking Lake Montauk. Mediterranean fare that was fresh and delicious. The buratta with warm peaches and mixed greens is amazing. The hummus platter exceeded expectations. The cocktail menu is varied and interesting, try the vodka watermelon, yum. Servers were attentive and friendly. Honestly, cannot wait to come back but come early or be prepared to wait as they do not take reservations.

My husband & I had a wonderful dining experience at Crows Nest. We went early and in September so there was no wait to be seated but even if there was, the views & grounds are spectacular to enjoy. The host was friendly and welcoming. We sat in the main dining room;the boho-look decor is perfect for MTK. Service was excellent even at full capacity.Each dish was beautifully presented, unique and flavorful. The beausoleil oysters were fresh. The halibut with pistachio & harissa was delicious. The lobster fettuccine was perfectly prepared. The Chef is outstanding. Nice wine list too. Our only complaint is that we can't return until next year as its closed for the Winter season. We're counting the days to return!

Went to see what all the hype is about and we were so pleasantly surprised. We arrived on a Friday night right before 5PM and there were already ~20 parties in line before us. They start seating folks promptly at 5 and we were seated shortly. (To note: we ran into friends post dinner who tried to put their name in around 7PM and were told that the list was closed for the night). Our server and the overall service was incredible. Ambiance cannot be beat - it has all the allure of a magical garden combined with the elegance of a fine dining experience. Cocktails were good, but were nothing too special. A tad disappointed that they do not stock Casamigos. All in all the food was incredible. Highlights were the ricotta and lobster tagliatelle. If you want a side you'll be impressed with the sweet potatoes. Dress for dinner like you might end up sitting next to someone famous - because you just might. Pro tip: arrive at 5:15/30 to put your name down and head to their beach for drinks while you wait!

OUTRAGEOUSLY OVERPRICED, even for the Hamptons. You will spend 40% more here than any other place put east or in NYC. I paid $75, plus tax and tip for ONE DRINK. YES, just ONE drink! Pros: The staff by the water (outdoor bar and seating) were very polite an courteous and it is a lovely and quiet place to watch the sunset. CONS: - It was about as easy to get a seat by the water as it is to get one on the NYC subway during a 2019 rush hour. The same goes for the parking lot... it was bedlam out there. It's best to take an UBER or just avoid altogether. - The staff inside the main restaurant were very rude and not accommodating in the least. That being said, they are severely understaffed so it's not all the fault of the employees. However, the girl at the front desk was the absolute worst... So pretentious and unfriendly. - Did I mention it was grossly overpriced? There are MANY better options out in MTK and the entire east end of Long Island. Save yourself time and aggravation (and enough money to put 1 of your kids through college) by going ANYWHERE else. I'd rather set fire to my own hair than go back here, and I have magnificent hair.

The good: -truly beautiful, 100% magical Hamptons experience. The restaurant has the most delightful faux bougie beach shack vibes. If you are lucky enough, you can score an outside seating where you get a view of the lawn and are surrounded by string of lanterns and near fire pits. The ugly: -tough to get in, we were lucky enough to be visiting after Labor Day and missing a lot of the crows -parking is insane, it took us 15 minutes to get out of the lot because of how cramped it was -food was pricey & medium in taste -we felt a bit rushed by the staff The tips: - if you must see this trending spot for yourself, come early (like 530 early) - don't miss the cute little inlet a walk down from the restaurant

New Yorkers complain about how overrated South Fork is every year yet we end up there every summer/ fall. When in Montauk, Crow's Nest is our favorite restaurant to be. While dogs aren't allowed inside, their staff always welcomes us at the outside tables. Great food, friendly staff & lovely view (especially the sunset). Recommend- Maple Brook Burrata, local fluke & tuna crudo, Scallops and Rib eye steak. For dessert- the olive oil cake was spot on.

When in Mountauk, this is a STOP YOU HAVE TO MAKE!! beautiful scenery , and really great drinks !! Look forward to coming out here again and trying it out for dinner since this time we only stopped by for drinks. Watermelon cooler and the spicy marg are pictured and those drinks were seriously made to perfection !!!

We shut up right when Crosnest opened and the place was about 25% capacity with empty tables everywhere they stuffed me and my family of five in a table of four in a corner when we asked to be moved to one of the empty tables that were everywhere we were told they reserved but yet they don't take reservations. It quite frankly the staff was a bunch of rude hippies in my opinion and I will go near this place ever again. You can keep it way better restaurants with way better service