Victoria B.
Yelp
tl;dr: good drinks, good service, close to T -- a trifecta!
We were looking for a convenient but out-of-the-way meeting spot after work. The Merchant is very close to the T (2 min walk from Downtown Crossing; 5 min walk from Park Street) but tucked away from the crowds. When I entered alone around 5 pm, I was surprised at how crowded it was. Two hostesses greeted me warmly. So far, so good!
Bar seating is open, including, I'm pretty sure, the hightops just behind and beside the very long, dark, wood bar. The seats themselves are sturdy with backs. I was meeting a date and so needed two seats but was early and so aimed to take the only empty seat at the very busy bar, a singleton. The only problem was that the woman in the adjacent seat had shoved her seat up against the open seat where her coat and bag prevented anyone from using the seat. So I kindly asked her if she would move. She refused and turned back to talking to her date, who looked embarrassed. As I stood there in front of the only open seat in a very crowded bar, trying to decide what to do, the bartender placed a glass of water and menu at the place. So far, good marks for attentiveness and vibe. Except for the selfish bag lady, the vibe was pretty good.
So while I was standing there, I said to the bartender, thanks, but I don't think I can fit into the seat. It took him about a millisecond to recognize that the woman was taking up two seats and he asked her to move, which, with great fanfare and huffs and whatnot, she finally did. (Life advice, folks. A bar is like a subway. If it's crowded, take up only your space.)
And more marks to Merchant for managing the bar from the barside and corralling the unruly. Once seated, I asked for a whiskey list, which he promptly produced. I love it when a bar actually has a list of whiskeys with prices. With a range from $10 to $25 for a 2oz measured pour (also good marks -- not just a bartender's eyeball), I like to know what I'm spending. More great marks for having a good selection. I went with the Blanton's at $13 with ice on the side.
Soon enough, the crazy lady left and my date arrived. The beer selection is extensive so he created a black and tan which was poured to perfection by another bartender. We later ordered the Thai curry mussel appetizer which was very very good. The toast it came with was perfectly crunchy. We both could have eaten more toast (dipped in the broth!) and when we jokingly said as much while the bartender cleared our plates, he offered to leave the broth and get us more toast. We declined (-- it would be like licking the bowl, non?-- ) but it's good to know that they're generous that way.
While we were there, several bartenders attended to us so that we never wanted for anything. And a barback kept clearing dishes. Everybody was chatty and pleasant and fun and modest. No arrogance at all.
I'll be back!!
(This review is for the bar. I barely glanced at the dining room, which looks dark and, well, dark.)