The Mermaid Inn

Seafood restaurant · Upper West Side

The Mermaid Inn

Seafood restaurant · Upper West Side

570 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024

Highlights

A lively upscale-casual seafood haven with a Cape Cod charm, famed for $1 oysters and delicious lobster rolls, perfect for a fun outing.

570 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024 Get directions

themermaidnyc.com

$50–100 · Menu

@infatuation

"At this point, The Mermaid Inn is pretty much synonymous with solid, not trying-too-hard first date spot. There are lots of small plate options, plenty of drinks to choose from, and a happy hour deal that means you can afford to get a few of both. But take our word for it: you probably don’t look as good eating an oyster as you think you do." - Marisa Dunn

The Mermaid Inn Review - Upper West Side - New York - The Infatuation

View Postcard for The Mermaid Inn

@eater

"The Mermaid Inn is shutting down its 15-year-old Upper West Side location on October 16, according to the New York Post. The owners 'mutually agreed' to part ways with the building's new landlord, but they say that the seafood hangout may relocate to another spot in the same neighborhood." - Erika Adams

Trader Joe’s in Brooklyn May Be First New York Store to Unionize - Eater NY

View Postcard for The Mermaid Inn

@infatuation

"A lot of Maine lobster rolls just have meat, mayo, and not much else. We appreciate simplicity, but those versions can come off as bland. That's not an issue at The Mermaid Inn. Here, fresh and tender lobster meat is mixed with minimal mayo, relatively big slices of celery, and a blend of salt, pepper, paprika, and onion powder. All of that is stuffed in a heavily buttered and toasted brioche bun (which is like a big, semi-soft crouton.) The fries on the side are the best ones on this list—like slightly well-done McDonald's fries, but with Old Bay seasoning." - Bryan Kim, Kenny Yang

The Best Lobster Rolls In NYC - New York - The Infatuation

View Postcard for The Mermaid Inn

@infatuation

"The fact that The Mermaid Inn’s UWS location is just a seven-minute walk from the northwest tip of Central Park feels like divine intervention. If restaurants were deities, Mermaid Inn would be some kind of all-knowing, all-loving, being that could make all your wildest seafood and alcohol dreams come true. In addition to oysters, lobster rolls, and crab cakes, this seafood spot offers to-go drinks like margaritas to martinis every day." - Nikko Duren

Where To Get To-Go Cocktails Near Central Park - New York - The Infatuation

View Postcard for The Mermaid Inn

@infatuation

"Certain things are non-negotiable. It might be the side of the bed you sleep on, or the side of the family you spend holidays with. Or most importantly, it could be the incontrovertible fact that you and your dog are a package deal. Mermaid Inn understands that. They let your dog (or your date) be a third-wheel anytime, including during their daily oyster Happy Hour from 4:30-6:30pm." - Matt Tervooren

The Best Outdoor Date Night Spots In NYC - New York - The Infatuation

View Postcard for The Mermaid Inn

Milorad Vukovich

Google

We came on Sunday with a large group for happy hour which was a great experience. Make sure to get there early as there will be a line before they open at 5. Got there around 4:45 and we were fine to get a table for 7 + a stroller. They are very kid friendly. The food happy hour is great. $1 oysters were tasty and a steal. The shrimp and avocado sliders are delicious. The tacos were fun. My friends enjoyed the drinks. Definitely a fun Sunday spot. Dinner comes with a little cup of chocolate pudding for a taste of something sweet after.

G Frye

Google

We went for a quick dinner down the road by our apartment this evening, and The Mermaid Inn delivered an amazing experience for us! The atmosphere was great with nice music. They were busy but not noisy. The candles on the table created a warm and calm feeling. The oyster and clams were great! My husband loved the salmon and hush puppies. He said the salmon entree was unbelievably delicious with the salmon resting on top of a bed of vegetables: sweet potatoes, mushroom, greens, and so on. The service was great! We will be back to try more dishes!

HJC

Google

Loved the Mermaid Inn. They have such a great menu- so much to choose from and their prices are pretty reasonable. We couldn’t even decide what to get so we got a lot of small things.The service and staff were incredible as well! The best was the free mini chocolate pudding dessert at the end. I could’ve eaten 100 of them. Will definitely be back.

Aria Ni

Google

Canceled dinner reservation at my favorite oyster bar when my coworker suggested this gem. BEST DECISION EVER. One of the best oyster happy hours I have been to. First the atmosphere is very romantic, dimly lit and cute decor. Perfect for date night! Great service by all patrons. $1 oysters and clams for happy hour (5-7pm) . There’s only one type of oyster on happy hour but they were great so no complaints! The happy hour menu also included choices of fried oysters, calamari, seafood sliders, and a wide selection of drinks (cocktails, beers, wines) among other things. The quality of all the food was superb from the seafood to the steak. Presentation was great and EVERYTHING was delectable. I went yesterday and am already planning to go back this coming week. Keep it up!

Mahima Srivastava

Google

Had dinner during weekday at The Mermaid Inn. We tried lobster mac and cheese, fish tacos, crab cake and old bay fries. Everything was delicious and we got complimentary chocolate pudding from the Chef which was the cherry on the cake. We had a table outdoors in June and the service was very good. Will be back again!

Mike Eye

Google

A nice day for brunch at the Mermaid Inn. When in New York City I prefer to eat inside rather than on the street. Place was clean and not to crowded. We had our cocktails and started with a fresh oysters, clams and tuna. Moved to a lobster roll, shrimp po' boy and burger for all to share. Waitress was attentive and friendly.

Christina

Google

Do you know how you feel when you eat something so delicious you are afraid to eat the next thing for fear it won't be as delicious? Welcome to Mermaid Inn! We came during happy hour for a dinner meeting. Every item was just as delicious as the next item. We tried the mini fish tacos, the shrimp sliders, the salmon, and the shishito peppers. Everything was extremely flavorful and the Happy Hour menu gives you the opportunity to try a lot of little items. After dinner our waiter brought us complimentary dark chocolate pudding which was also delicious. The reservation system is also super convenient, the restaurant texts you to let you know that your table is ready so you know if you can be seated even earlier than your reservation. I will definitely return!

Chris X. C.

Google

This is the go-to place for me whenever I’m craving for oysters. I have come here for happy hour for 3 years. The happy hour menu here is just perfect, with the combination of good price, nice wine selections, and delicious food. Their happy hour is 5-7 everyday, but if you don’t want to wait for too long during weekends, try get here as early as 4:55. Oh and they have lobster combo every Sunday night which I don’t think is on the menu. Ask the server if you wanna try.