Erika B.
Yelp
Loved this place! The first thing I look for in a tiki bar is atmosphere. This place has it covered! From the mysterious directions on how to try to find it once inside the building...to the actual inside of the bar once we entered, it was just fun. It's dim and exotic, the way a tiki bar should be. There really isn't all that much seating. We got lucky because there was no line (we were there early though, around 6:30 or 7 on a Friday) and we were able to snag a perfect table for a party of 3.
I had read up about the dress code, and while I don't know if it would be strictly enforced, I made sure to wear a dress and some snazzy new heels I just bought (sparkly and black, more like booties, just got them at Wasteland that day, such a fabulous place...but anyway). As long as you don't look like a slob, you could probably get away with most anything other than tanks, flip flops, and that sort of thing. The feeling was friendly, not snobbish. I prefer to go all-out with a hawaiian dress, hair flower, shells, etc. when I go to anyplace tiki, but it was really chilly and rainy out and I couldn't even stand the idea of wearing open-toed shoes.
So now on to the drinks, the next super important part of any tiki bar. First of all, I wish I'd gotten the name of our bartender, because he was excellent. He was patient and took his time answering our questions, describing the drinks, and making suggestions. I'm pretty picky about what I drink, especially when it's going to be roughly $15. For the first round I had the Tradewinds, which I enjoyed a lot. I was in a coconutty mood (I am usually in a coconutty mood). I do not like anything too tart/sour. I told our bartender all this, and he suggested several drinks. I didn't regret this one. I took a sip of my sister's navy grog and it was good, but quite a bit more tart than the Tradewinds.
But let's talk now about round two. My, oh my, round two! All three of us had the Painkiller. To give you an idea how much we liked it, my sister's quote pretty much sums it up, "I want to drink one of these every day for the rest of my life". It was so yummy. According to a website, it is a specialty of the British Virgin Islands, and is similar to a pina colada. I know I love pina coladas, so that would partly explain it. But something really special about it was that it was topped with nutmeg. So if you don't like nutmeg, you probably would hate the drink, but it added something extra.
A warning to those of you who are not used to tiki drinks: do not be fooled by the cute mugs they come in, or the cherry garnishes or the parasols or any of that. They are so innocent-looking, but they are POTENT. They are also really tasty so they go down well. A little too well sometimes. We were told by our knowledgeable and friendly bartender that each drink has around 3 oz. of booze. So you figure, if you have 4 drinks, you just had 12 shots! I wisely limited myself to two, but my sister and husband...well, let's just say they weren't at their very best later in the night or the next morning.
If you like tiki places, try this place. Just try it! If you don't like crowds, maybe consider going at a less busy time like I did. Take time to savor the atmosphere and just relax. Aloooooooooha!