Time Square Pizza & Subs

Time Square Pizza Review We ordered super late and still got our food right away — now that’s service! This is a true mom-and-pop spot, and it absolutely doesn’t disappoint. The food came out hot, fresh, and packed with flavor. Honestly, it was so damn good I completely forgot to take any pictures. That should tell you everything! If you’re craving real-deal pizza and that local, welcoming vibe, this is the place. We’ll definitely be back.

The best pizza in south Florida and it’s always excellent every time you order. Friendly service. Cupped pepperoni with Mikes Hot Honey is a new favorite.

Ordered a small pizza with 5 toppings, one of their specials. The pizza has thinner style crust but it's firm and not flimsy. They don't use very much sauce and it's light on cheese. Toppings were generous and overall the pizza was good.

Visiting the area, ordered online. Quick delivery. Large portions, could only eat one slice of pizza, cannolis delicious. Also ordered the caprese salad, excellent with the balsamic vinaigrette. Highly recommended.

First time at time square, I’m a pizza enthusiast I was highly rated for trying this place being told it’s one of the best places. It wasn’t busy at all, pizza itself was flabby and falling apart. I rate it 4.3 I’ve had better pizza. I was really looking forward to it but ended up disappointed ☹️

Love Times Square pizza and subs. Moved to Arizona and miss eating there. When here on vacation it's one of our must eat there place.

The pizza was terrible, to say the least. Not sure if it was a bad night for the kitchen staff.....but this may be the worst pizza I've ever had in my life.

TRUST ME, order now! Seriously amazing pizza … I am going to miss this place. Will always come back when I visit FLL. My wife and I got the cheese and a make your own with our choice of topping. It hit the spot!!!

First time today! So so good! Pizza is not heavy and sauce is not too sweet or acidic. Huge slices!!!! Price worthy! I love a real gem like this. People kept coming in and out and the salad was super fresh too. Do yourself a favor and go!

The most authentic pizza found to date in down town Fort Lauderdale! This is a large and huge, definitely didn't expect such a large pie at such a low price. The pizza was ready in 10-15 min and delicious

Just got here from New York today and wanted good pizza. 10/10 so good and the pizza was huge! The owner was very nice!!!

Opted for the calzone tonight. Left the ham out and instead got sausage and black olives. Very good but they don't give enough sauce with it. Also, plastic fork in hot food has the tines bent like an S. No metal utensils. Quick and friendly service.

Usually, everything is great! I have been ordering from here for years! Food is usually fantastic, no complaints. Today, the calzone is burnt and three out of five subs were wrong or just sub-par. Got onions on the ham sub, did not ask for onions, and there were only two pieces of ham on the whole sandwich. Asked for extra cheese on the veggie cheese sub, got almost zero cheese at all. The tuna sub had, on the whole sub what would usually be on one half on the sandwich. Not sure if it was new staff today, but this very regular customer is very disappointed.

Service was friendly and so fast, even considering I ordered for pick up on my phone right after I loaded my car up as I was leaving Target across the street. The pizza was yummy, fresh, and crispy!! Very busy spot with lots of foot traffic. Seemed like a pretty popular community pizza joint. Wasn't my favoriteeee pizza in the world, but I'd get it again!

They do pizza by the slice! and it's not overpriced. I love the fact that it's right across the street from Target. After shopping for a bit it's so convenient to just call in a slice or pick it up. I order the pepperoni slice with a sprite and a side of ranch. Its the best combo.

Been coming to Times Square for years and it is a favorite throughout the community. A hole in the wall but has quality pizza, great prices, personable staff, quick service, and big portions.

I'm a New Yorker so I definitely had to check this spot out! The moment I walked in I felt like I was at home! It smells so delicious in there! And all the tables were filled! They are definitely doing something right! You can watch them make the pizzas as well when you walk in. It was so amazing I ordered a cheese slice to go and grabbed a soda. I spent less than $6 and I enjoyed it. The pizza had a great flavor to it! It folded perfectly. I was overall impressed and sad I didn't get a second slice lol. I will definitely be back again to get more delicious pizza!

I used this visit NYC all the time for several years for work. This place is like the best NYC pie you could find. This is a compliment. Great sauce. Not floppy (I ask them to leave it in a little longer) and great sauce to cheese ratio. Anyways. The pie is bomb. Haven't had anything else.

Great pizza. A little overpriced. But consistent pizza. Tried Italian hoagie. Was good also.

Tried the slice of cheese a few weeks ago and got a cheese 16 inch for carryout this week, both were great! Yummy New York style pizza! They also have lots of drinks. Very good pizza parlor!

Calling yourself Times Square Pizza is a bit ballsy when you're nowhere near New York. But, this pizzeria got its name from the little shopping center it's located in, not Manhattan. Walking into TSP, it had the right smell and feel as a NY pizzeria. It was a busy night with 2 guys making pizza's exclusively, TSP makes 18" pizzas, which is the size of any reputable real NY pizzeria. They stretched the dough out by hand, but there was no tossing of the dough. I ordered an 18" pie, half meatball and a slice of Sicilian with anchovy. The pie was overly cheesy. The sauce was excellent & robust. The crust had an ok bite and chew, but was very airy and lacked flavor. The meatballs on top were plentiful and tasty. The Sicilian slice was huge, but not the right type of dough; it wasn't dense enough. Again, it was too airy and lacked flavor. Overall, the pizza was better than most in South Florida, but it just didn't quite reach that level of pizza excellence I look for.

I have been here many times, but haven't written a review in the past. They always have a pizza / salad & drink special. I have been to NYC and have tried many slices of pizza from Rey's, Joes etc. This little hole in the wall pizza shop, is the closest to authentic to NYC pizza shops I have found down here. The price is still nice and you get quick service. I recommend them for lunch quick bite.

I used to love the pizza from here. But the last couple of times I've ordered their pizza, it's been a disappointment. I don't know if they've changed their supplier, or cut done on the quality of the ingredients to save money, but whatever the reason, it's sadly gone down hill. I will keep trying them, every 6 months or so, and if it bounces back, I will definitely update my review. I hope so.

We ordered a pizza while visiting the area. They have the best thin crust pizza I have had. We visit the area a few times a year and will go back

It says open until 10:00 p.m., and we arrived at 9:25 p.m., and the door was locked and the lights are out. He would not let us in the restaurant, except for takeout. Another guy he's almost turning away and it's 9:26 p.m. so don't believe them when they say they're open till 10:00. Also, the owner argued with me when I said why don't you put on Yelp that you're only open until 9:30? He could not understand the logic between behind that and he said no we're open till 10:00. But I said yeah we're here at 9:26 but you won't let us in so why don't you put your clothes at 9:30? He still didn't get it.

Received the wrong item. I was told they would make it up to me. well they didn't. item went in the trash. Don't go they are not nice when they make an error.

This place is very good. Some of the best pizza and sub I've had that I can remember. I had a pepperoni and jalapeño pizza and a meatball sub. Both were phenomenal. I will 100% be back

Super yummy New York style pizza! I had a to go order, pepperoni, it was delicious. Easy parking too.

So, the food we ordered this time was SOOO much better. We had a pepperoni and bacon thin crust pizza. And oh my goodness. This is such an underrated combo!!! Tried the creamy Italian dressing on the salad, and it was very good. This place is a bargain!!!! You can get the deep dish slices for like $3, and they are HUGE!

Delicious and authentic NY pizza! I can't believe I've lived here almost my whole life and I had never tried this place. The pizza is very fresh, nice chew, crispy crust. The ingredients seem fresh and house made sauce. Very good, this is definitely going to become my go-to spot. The ambiance is kinda cute honestly. It's dated and very casual, but it reminds me of an old school diner. They definitely get a lot of take out orders, the guys were busy behind the counter. Only about a handful of of booths, but seemed enough. Quick and friendly service!

Always a sure thing. Times Square pizza is a great little spot to grab a slice or a pie!

only leaving a review because the restaurant has no way to write to them. walked in between 9:15pm and 9:30pm (sign on the door says closes at 10pm). Nobody looked at me when I walked in then as I was looking at the menu someone asked me "you picking up?" I said no and collectively all 4 employees audibly sighed. He then asked "what can I get for you?" I asked "so you don't sell pizza by the slice?" and the employee pointed to the counter and said "we don't HAVE pizza." I said okay and looked at subs on the menu and said "what about..." and then another employee told me "it's closed." it was not even 9:30pm and the website, door, and google all said closes 10pm. the staff was rude and they expect you to pay a parking meter to go inside.

Great pizza! We've been going there for years and it's the best around in Fort lauderdale!

I'm usually very happy with the pizzas I order from them but this pizza was so bad I will not order again. I did not give them a horrible rating because it's a bad economy but my supreme pizza had so few toppings and cheese on some pieces it was pathetic. And I could count the number of meat pieces on the pie. I would rather them raise their price and give the same quality pie than to charge me full price for a bad pie.

I have been going here for over10 years, they make a great pizza. When friends come into town and want pizza I always take them here.

spicy Italian sandwich was absolutely excellent. The service was excellent as I was there a little bit early before rush-hour but they became more and more busy and I was in and out in about 10 minutes. And everyone was polite and had manners. Will be going back soon when I get back from Atlanta. Dang that was a good sandwich.

Been coming here for years, a classic Ft. Lauderdale establishment. Can always count of Times Square for a real NY slice and quick service. The pizza is 100/10, consistently delicious. Truly my favorite pizza ever!

We love time square. We order once a week. Nice staff and wonderful pizza totally recommend

Love the food here! Has there pizza at a party. Went tonight Had an Anti- Pasta it was large and fresh Also had a 16" house pizza Could only eat one slice So good and full of toppings Pepperoni sausage mushrooms onions green pepper and I had a banana peppers it was really good. This is a true pizza shop with four booths and you order at the counter but they do bring it to your table and they serve with paper plates and plastic cutlery but the food was amazing and the prices are very low for the quality of the product I will be back and I recommend anybody to try it thank you Rick

We ordered a medium pizza half cheese and half bacon and pepperoni. It was delicious the kids really enjoyed it and it was ready as soon as I walked in. Looking forward to getting pizza here again.

I'm very picky with my pizza choices and here it was excellent! Love it! Crust was thin and crispy, and they make it very fast!

I absolutely love this place! Old school pizza joint with amazing prices and deals. Salad is crisp and full of fresh ingredients; pizza slice is huge, thin and crisp; and you get a can of soda with the combo. You can eat inside or take it out. Either way, highly rated!

I've had the pizza here before and it was pretty good. Today we order subs (chicken and meatball) and they were both pretty tasty. Another bonus was that they stayed piping hot the whole ride home. The only thing I would've preferred is for the bread to be a little more toasty--but I know many prefer the softer "easier to chew bread". I also would've liked if it came with a side like fries, chips, side salad or a drink. The staff was very accommodating by providing us with extra little condiments for our subs and like I said once we got home they were still piping hot. All in all we would come back and continue to check out the rest of their food items.

We ordered a 16 inch pizza and garlic bread. Both were very good. Everyone one was friendly there. We enjoyed our time there.

Bad manners. We order from this place at least twice a month. We order the same thing every time. An extra large half cheese half pepperoni. When I came to pick it up, I saw it was a small box and questioned if it was an extra large. The man that took the order over the phone told me they don't call their pizzas extra large. They have their own name for them, the big deal or something. Then why not tell me that over the phone before I drive over there with a car full of kids. Why not say, "I'm sorry we don't carry extra large we only carry a pizza called the big deal." The young guy even tried to talk some sense into him. But no, he said I can just buy two pizzas. Real nice. So, they rush another pizza. I get home and it's not even cook and doesn't even have enough cheese on it. And your pizza is always good. Was at work doing this?

For the last 10 years I had my go to pizza shop - but with new management the pizza was just not the same - so I decided to try something new - OMG this is almost as good if not BETTER and less expensive - Here's to a new 10 years run Times Square - thank you!

I've said it to my friends and now I'll say it on here, hands down the BEST Pizza in Fort Lauderdale and maybe South Florida. Whenever I want a good slice I don't even bother going anywhere else. The owners are always working and they get you in and out as fast as you want without pushing you out the door. Pizza is always fresh, Hot and perfectly made! Lunch special is $6.00 for 2 months Slices and a can of soda and guaranteed to fill you up! 11/19/18 Back again!! Even better than before!!

I've ordered sandwiches delivered from here many times. They are consistently delicious. My favorites are the turkey, ham and cheese and the tuna. The fillings are generous and the bread is oh so good. Delivery is prompt and friendly. I highly recommend this place.

Been coming here since 2004.. Ray and the rest of the guys are 1st class.. most of the guys have been there 10+ years. The pizza is by far the best Ny style slice I have had, great sandwich's especially the Tuna and the cannoli is also outstanding!

Definitely not NYC pizza. Crust was hard and tasted old. Like pre-cooked. Sauce was sweet. There are so many other options out there. Try them.

I tried this place about two months ago and have been back about 5 times since! It reminds me of a true pizza parlor in New York. The staff is awesome and the pizza is delicious! Will not order from anywhere else

The pizza here is such a treat. Can't believe how yum the sauce was. Meatball is their specialty. The ownership takes great pride in the recipe and it shows in their work. We went there 3 times in a week and look forward to going again.

I lived in this area my whole life, right in Coral Ridge and this is the spot to go. My parents have been buying here for who knows how long. Perfect pizza in a timely manner and you can't go wrong :)

A great place to pick up a quick slice or a pie. Just like slice pizza I used to get in the NYC metro area pizza parlors. Reasonably priced and fast service. Thin slightly crunchy crust, tasty sauce and cheese + toppings of choice. Always a steady stream of customers. There are entries and heros/subs/hoagies on the menu, too.

Really mediocre. Barely had any cheese on it. Sauce was bland. Onions were undercooked

Time Square Pizza has got to be one of THE best pizza places in Broward county. I love a thin crust pizza and this is the place. Not stingy with the cheese or pepperoni. The slices are huge!!! The flavor of their sauce will please your taste buds for sure. It also offers many other menu items but this is why I come here. To have a slice and work to keep that sauce from rolling down my hands just like in NY!. Private owned with staff that are friendly and courteous. Outdoor and indoor seating available. Not a huge restaurant. Four booths and three small tables inside. Take out and delivery available. Clean floors and tables. Meter parking so be sure to have some coins available. 50 cents an hr so that's not bad! Try them out!

Times Square is by far the best tasting pizza I have found since moving here six years ago. Always fresh, not only the pizzas but the hot grinder sandwiches are excellent. And, the quality is consistent. I've never been disappointed. I highly recommend Times Square to even the most picky pizza lover.

Times Square Pizza is pretty much of an old time hole in the wall, dated in appearance both from the outside and within, pizza shop. But like the old time pizza shops has an operator speaking with an Italian accent, gracious and friendly, and turning out slices of pizza that sort of break the norm of what has become the chain standards of today. I went for two of their menu slices, one with toppings of spinach, anchovies and broccoli, the other with ground beef, eggplant and bacon. Indeed these topping combinations, once rather common, are now infrequently found. Matter of fact few, with the exception of the real Italian pizza shops, few even offer anchovies. That being one of the reasons that, if you look in the glove compartment of my car, you'll find cans of anchovies. LOL! Though I can't say that the slices I had consisted of the best flavors I've experience, partially because of the fact that they start with an already prepared base, then add the toppings and heat it, I can say that the slices were two of the largest, most generous in size, I have ever been served. Though rather drab in appearance, the kindly warmth of the staff along with nearby free parking more than offset any of those shortcomings. Overall, Times Square Pizza makes for a pleasant enough stop for a pizza snack or meal as they also offer varying cold subs, hot subs, salads, a special homemade lasagna, a special Times Square platter of chicken parmigiana with stuffed shells, manicotti as well as a number of other offerings.