"You’re in Times Square. This isn’t the night to be classy. Have a New York tourist experience at Tony’s Di Napoli where the chandeliers are tacky, and the tablecloths are red-checkered. Just like at the original uptown location, the Italian food hits the spot. Caesars and parm are served tableside, and the pasta is heaping and al dente. Tony’s is great for a not-so-serious group." - bryan kim, sonal shah, will hartman, molly fitzpatrick, ciera velarde, arden shore
"Family-style Italian restaurant offering large, shareable home-cooked portions—an ideal choice for family gatherings and groups looking for hearty, traditional Italian fare." - Rachel Chang Rachel Chang Rachel Chang is a travel and pop culture journalist who contributes to Travel + Leisure, Condé Nast Traveler, Lonely Planet, and more. Travel + Leisure Editorial Guidelines
"The popular Italian restaurant made a name serving family style, so it’s a natural for large parties, and a bargain at $49.95 for the Thanksgiving menu. It kicks off with pasta e fagioli soup or salad, and includes roast turkey with sausage stuffing, sweet potatoes, and cranberry sauce, followed by apple crisp dessert. For those who can’t resist the fried calamari or chicken Parm, the a la carte menu will also be available." - Beth Landman
"The last time you thought about spending your birthday in Times Square, you were probably a child, brainwashed by gigantic M&Ms, or on your way to see Wicked (or all three). But hear us out. The dangling chandeliers, celebrity caricatures, and checkered tablecloths at this family-style Italian spot set the scene for a good time that’s just the right amount of tacky. It all feels like the childhood birthday parties we had at Bucca di Beppo, except the food is actually really good. Come here with six of your friends, order the huge, shareable platters of caesar salad and rigatoni alla vodka, and drink a boat load of wine next to a painting of Mario Lopez. " - bryan kim, neha talreja, kenny yang, sonal shah
"Family-style restaurants work well for group dinners, and this Times Square favorite, enlivened with caricatures of actors on the walls, has one of the best deals in town, with prix-fixe packages starting at $34 per person including appetizer, salad, pasta, entree and dessert. Classic Italian favorites, including chicken Parmesan, fettuccini Alfredo, and baked salmon oreganata, followed by homemade tiramisu, cannoli or cheesecake, are presented in private rooms that hold between 10 and 80. Tony’s also has a second location in the East 60s." - Eater Staff