Toscano Ristorante Italiano

The food here was absolutely amazing. You can definitely tell that everything is made from scratch. I went with several colleagues who ordered fried calamari, garlic bread, and chicken Alfredo. They both let me try their orders; and it was to die for. I ordered fried cheese tortellini and tiramisu. Both were better than anything else I’ve ever had at any Italian eatery. The service was nothing short of excellent. Our waitress checked on us often and returned quickly when we asked for something. She was friendly and had a smile on her face the entire time. The restaurant was quaint and quiet overall. Great place to come for a nice dinner with friends or for a date night. Highly recommend giving them a try!

The truffle fries are the best thing on the menu. I got the veggie pizza and the broccoli was a little wet for me- I personally would have browned/charred it before putting on the pizza- but it was still yummy! The tiramisu was awesome! And the water is good haha. We were going to get drinks but our server said they were like 8oz, very small for $15- not worth it. I would eat here again.

Me and my boyfriend decided to come here for my birthday dinner. I love Italian food, especially pasta, so I had high hopes. We walk inside and the atmosphere is more sports bar than anything. We get sat and we waited 10 minutes before our server got our order. Another 30 minutes go by and I see our food sitting under the heat lamps in the window. I also see, at the same time our server, sitting down eating food talking to another server. We wait another 10+ minutes before our server finally brings our food. I had originally ordered the spiced shrimp penne. I recieved the chicken, and it tasted undercooked. My boyfriend ordered the frutti de mare and the spaghetti was sitting in a bowl of "white wine", it looked like water. It also smelled horrible and the pasta was over cooked. We managed to get my food taken off because I couldn't eat any of mine and we left. Never coming here again.

Little Italy in Atlanta. The food, the ambiance, and the staff are all great! Gabriel is a very nice server and served me excellently. I don't need to say much about the pizza, just check it out :) yummy!!!!! One small remark: please play Italian music. Otherwise, everything's fine, thank you very much. 🙌

We had a little glitch in our order but Xavier handled it beautifully. We loved the food, the service was great, the house red was delicious, and the decor is relaxing and the background music was sublime!

Maria G. Was an amazing server and she gave great recommendations. Because of her I stepped out of the box and had the sacchetti pasta and I HIGHLYYYY recommend it. The flavors were amazing with the savory and slight sweetness of the pear. The truffle fries were great. Definitely will be back and hopefully I get Maria again. Great meal and great service.

We enjoyed everything, especially the wings. I could bottle that sauce and seriously debated on asking for the recipe. Our server was so great we were very happy with our drinks and how quickly the food came out. The calamari was hot and fresh, it just could’ve used some seasoning in the batter. The pizza was really well balanced, great sauce to topping ratio. The restaurant and bathrooms were clean. We saw some salads a at a table over from us that looked delicious. Would definitely come back and recommend!

Toscano I Ristorante Italiano at Atlantic Station absolutely deserves every one of these five stars. From the moment we walked in, the service was top-notch – attentive without ever feeling overbearing, and genuinely welcoming in a way that made us feel like valued guests rather than just another table. The portions here are huge, so come hungry or plan on bringing leftovers home (which is honestly a bonus). Every dish we ordered was fresh and flavorful, but what really stood out was the seafood. The quality was excellent – perfectly cooked, tender, and seasoned just right without being drowned in heavy sauces. You can tell they truly care about sourcing and preparation. Overall, Toscano I Ristorante Italiano exceeded our expectations. Great service, generous portions, and seafood that’s some of the best I’ve had in Atlanta. Highly recommend.