Gordon Y.
Yelp
Cuisine: 6
Service: 7
Decor: 6
Value: 9
Overall: 6
Another new sushi omakase in Manhattan trying to make a name for itself, and I really came very close to giving it 4 stars due to its incredible value - 16 courses for $56. However, I landed on 3.5 stars and the quality of food ultimately was the tie breaker that decided the final rating.
What about the SHARI (rice)?
I always start with the sushi rice. If that sucks, then it's going to be a long night. Upon the first bite, I was a bit weary because it felt a bit mushy. However, as the meal progressed, the rice got consistently better. It's not top notch by any means, but it certainly was good enough compared to many sushiya in this price range. I would say that SHARI was a 6.5/10 overall.
What about the NETA (Topping)?
THE GOOD - The trio of Maguro (Bluefin Tuna) were actually quite good, especially the extra fatty Chutoro (Medium Fatty Tuna) with wasabi stem. Other good pieces included the smoked Sawara (Spanish Mackerel), buttery sweet Hotate (Scallop) and the super tender Unagi (Fresh Water Eel).
THE BAD - Well, I would say that a few cuts of fish, including Hamachi (Yellowtail), Madai (Sea Bream), and Shima Aji (Striped Jack) were too mushy compared to what I'm use to texturally. Also, the Uni (Sea Urchin) on top of the Botan Ebi (Spotted Prawn) was fishy and not great. Oh yeah, a bland bowl of Miso Soup should not count as a course. Lol
THE UGLY - Why does every new sushi omakase restaurant (Uka Omakase included) believe they need to enhance every piece of sushi with unique toppings or sauces? Please don't cover up the natural beauty of the seafood. What ever happened to letting the fish shine with simply a nice swipe of aged soy sauce. It is still the best accompaniment imho.
Bottom line, I would rate the NETA about 6/10.
As for the decor, it is a very long room with two sushi bars on the first floor. The sushi bar upfront is very long with 15 seats and 3 chefs serving the patrons, while the back sushi bar is for 6 guests and 1 chef. The space is sleek with black marble counters, dark and moody with mini chandeliers. I didn't get to see the upstairs private room, but it serves a $99 VIP 18 course omakase.
Our chef, Tommy, was a quiet guy and kept to his job. Can't blame him. He's only got 1 hour and 15 minutes to serve all the food. Btw, our server was pretty attentive as well. Lastly, I met the owner Xin and he is quite friendly. Regardless of the harsh words I may have said here, I do wish him and the restaurant the best of luck. I might come back for the VIP meal and update this review if necessary.