Bill A.
Yelp
Best way to describe "Underbelly" Burger is a simple "Underwhelming".
First visit, and probably last, was earlier today while we were visiting the "new" Houston Farmers Market for the first time since the "remodeling". Being a native Houstonian and having grown up with the "Airline Farmers Market" it was sad walking up and down the isles without the crude vegetable stands with the families selling their goods. Seems a few of the old vendors are still there, but the big sheds in the back selling bulk vegetable are gone. Now there are new "eating" places along the paths.
In comes my visit to Underwhelming Underbelly. Feels like going into a Burger King or Whataburger with much fewer seating options; they can only seat about 14 or 15 people inside with the rest moving outside to find a table or chairs in the common area where the kids are playing. Very stark, institutional feel in the restaurant; the warmth of a school cafeteria.
So much for the structure and atmosphere and on to the food. With Chris Shepherd being a James Beard Award winning chef, and visits to his other restaurants, my expectations were high; but unmet. Wanting to sample as much as possible from the menu, I ordered the Chicken Sandwich ($12) and my wife order the 44 Farms Angus Burger ($12, a combo with fries and a soft drink comes for another 5 bucks), along with the Twisty Fries. Sad to say the Chicken Sandwich was a BIG disappointment with it's thin chicken patty that appear to be a thigh as a large portion of it was dark, covered with thin batter which lacked a crispiness typically associated with fried chicken sandwiches. The bun was a flat squashed plain bun that appeared to have been stored under sack of potatoes (noticeable in the photo attached) prior to seeing my sandwich. Most redeeming quality of the Chicken Sandwich was the "sauce' and pickles. Quite a disappointment when compared to the new wave of chicken sandwiches coming from everyone from Popeye's to Nashville style hot chicken. BTW - you can get THREE Popeye's chicken sandwiches for the same price as ONE Underbelly chicken sandwich, and just one of of Popeye's has a larger piece of chicken, about twice the size of UBB's.
I missed getting a photo of the Angus Burger, but I'll try to give you a good verbal description instead. The burger was spitting image of a McDonald's Double Cheese Burger with patties a bit larger, but the same diameter. The patties had a good flavor but overly salty, and overcooked (dry)
for my liking. Served with usual lettuce, tomatoes, pickle and house sauce. While the menu stated "All Beef PATTY" not PATTIES, it had two thin patties rather that a single juicy thick patty. The assembly of the burger was mess, thrown together and with a mashed bun similar to the chicken sandwich; but it was covered with sesame seeds which was a big plus.
In summary your better off going to Popeye's for your chicken sandwiches and MUCH better off going to Beck's Prime for you burgers. Beck's is light years ahead of UBB's burger and still 25 cents less!!