"New York Bagel and Bialy in suburban Lincolnwood stands tall among Chicago area bagel purveyors, offering a slightly chewier take on its namesake’s offerings. The space isn’t ornate, but looks can be deceiving — the unfussy strip mall space puts out some of the most sought-after bagels in the Midwest. There’s also a suburban location in Skokie. Call to place orders." - Naomi Waxman