9

Big Gay Ice Cream

Permanently Closed

Big Gay Ice Cream

Permanently Closed
@eater
391,688 Postcards · 10,993 Cities

NYC Restaurant Closings in February 2025 - Eater NY

"An Upper West Side ice cream store that closed due to slow sales and high rent." - Nadia Chaudhury

https://ny.eater.com/2025/2/7/24356123/nyc-restaurant-closings-february-2025

Information

Soft serve ice cream, cookies, and unique donuts with toppings

salty pimp
soft serve
donuts
american globs
vegan ice cream
friendly staff
lgbtq+ friendly
rainbow flavors
Google Rating
3.9 (183)
Yelp Rating
3.4
Featured in The Infatuation
Featured in
Featured in Eater
Featured in
Featured in Grub Street
Featured in

516 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024 Get directions

$$

Order delivery
See Menu
Contactless accepted
LGBTQ friendly
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by Infatuation - Reviews
Big Gay Ice Cream by Infatuation - Reviews
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
See full details

9

Information

Soft serve ice cream, cookies, and unique donuts with toppings

salty pimp
soft serve
donuts
american globs
vegan ice cream
friendly staff
lgbtq+ friendly
rainbow flavors
Google Rating
3.9 (183)
Yelp Rating
3.4
Featured in The Infatuation
Featured in
Featured in Eater
Featured in
Featured in Grub Street
Featured in

516 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024 Get directions

$$

Order delivery
See Menu
Contactless accepted
LGBTQ friendly
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by Infatuation - Reviews
Big Gay Ice Cream by Infatuation - Reviews
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
See full details

More Places For You

Gus and Marty's

Greek restaurant · Greenpoint

Modern Greek dishes like moussaka, lamb gyro, baklava sundae

10 Postcards

Knori Hand Roll Bar

Japanese restaurant · Greenpoint

20 handroll options from spicy salmon to caviar, chef's tasting menu

2 Postcards

Phalia

Pakistani restaurant · Midtown East

Pakistani, Bangladeshi, Indian cuisine open until 4am

2 Postcards

Pebble Bar

Cocktail bar · Midtown West

Seafood towers, steak tartare, inventive cocktails

28 Postcards

Margot

Restaurant · Fort Greene

Seasonal menu with seafood, vegetables, pasta & cocktails

21 Postcards

Bar Kabawa

Bar · East Village

Caribbean patties, rum cocktails, and daiquiris, lively vibe

32 Postcards

Sailor's Choice

Restaurant · Chelsea

New England seafood shack with lobster BLT, fish & chips, oysters

3 Postcards

Sushi Aozora

Fine dining restaurant · Chelsea

Seasonal Edomae sushi, sake lees marinades, elegant atmosphere

5 Postcards

Parlor Coffee

Coffee roasters · Clinton Hill

Roastery and tasting room open Sundays, pour overs, and direct subscriptions

6 Postcards

Iona

Bar · Williamsburg

Scottish bar with hot toddies, televised soccer & garden

5 Postcards