1

West Islip Bagel

Bagel shop · West Islip ·

West Islip Bagel

Bagel shop · West Islip ·
@grubstreet
13,564 Postcards · 1,477 Cities

What Makes Long Island’s Bagels So Great?

"This West Islip spot is unpretentious in appearance—its exterior proclaims "Hot Bagels" in mismatched fonts and features a repurposed Pillsbury Doughboy with a Yankees logo—while inside the stereo plays WBAB or Howard Stern and older customers kibitz, drink coffee, and pick at bagels. The atmosphere is described as old New York energy transplanted to the suburbs; a garlic bagel with scallion cream cheese is among the featured items." - Jason Diamond, Christian Rodriguez

https://www.grubstreet.com/2022/05/long-island-bagels.html

Information

Old school bagel shop with hot bagels, great BECs

bagels
breakfast sandwiches
egg sandwiches
friendly staff
fresh bagels
good service
owner
family owned
Google Rating
4.6 (184)
Yelp Rating
3.8
Featured in Grub Street
Featured in

544 Hunter Ave, West Islip, NY 11795 Get directions

$1–10

See Menu
Coffee
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
See full details

1

Information

Old school bagel shop with hot bagels, great BECs

bagels
breakfast sandwiches
egg sandwiches
friendly staff
fresh bagels
good service
owner
family owned
Google Rating
4.6 (184)
Yelp Rating
3.8
Featured in Grub Street
Featured in

544 Hunter Ave, West Islip, NY 11795 Get directions

$1–10

See Menu
Coffee
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
West Islip Bagel by null
See full details

More Places For You

The Chefs Table Long Island

Takeout Restaurant · West Islip

Takeout, delivery, catering, private events, amazing food

1 Postcard

Tom's Towers Flowers

Florist · West Islip

Custom wedding designs, seasonal bouquets, and timely delivery

1 Postcard

Hometown Heroes

Sandwich shop · West Islip

Generous heroes, mac and cheese, fresh ingredients, huge portions

1 Postcard

The Bennett

Condominium complex · Astoria

Luxury condominium development offering 16 units with commute

1 Postcard

Ammazza Deli

Deli · Williamsburg

Serving coffee, rotisserie chicken, fried rice, pasta, and subs

1 Postcard

Trestle

Software company · Long Island City

Data centralization and performance management for construction

1 Postcard

Bar Enzo

Cocktail bar · Long Island City

Italian-American cocktail bar with Negronis, spritzes, and postcards

4 Postcards

Cool World

American restaurant · Greenpoint

Uncomplicated seasonal bistro food plus cocktails, wine, and beer

8 Postcards

Hometown Heroes Hockey Club

Hockey club · Saint James

Unites vets, first responders, teachers through hockey

1 Postcard

Cowbell Cyber Inc

Insurance company · Midtown East

Cowbell: your go-to for all cheese needs

1 Postcard