The Seafood Shop

The 29 Best Restaurants In The Hamptons - New York - The Infatuation

"At first glance, this old-school fish market may not look like one of the Hamptons’ most beloved restaurants, but step inside the tiny grocer and head to the back for a pretty unique dining experience. You'll find a great made-to-order combo seafood platter with fried scallops, shrimp, and white fish—and get some cocktail sauce on the side. Prices are reasonable for the generous portions. The heaping takeout container of hot fish goes for about $20, and the small outdoor patio is perfect for eating on-site. Otherwise, take your picnic to a nearby beach (Wainscott Beach is a five-minute drive). Rumor has it, Ina G herself buys her fish here, but she has yet to text us back to confirm." - melissa kravitz hoeffner