Nate’s Detroit Pizza

Pizza restaurant · Carroll Gardens

1

@infatuation

"We don't need to tell you that New York City has great New York-style pizza. But Detroit-style pizza is much harder to find. For that, try Nate's. The casual Carroll Gardens slice shop—with two other locations in Cobble Hill and Industry City—makes thick, heavy pies shimmering with red sauce and drizzles of olive oil, all encased in a blistered crust that tastes like the burnt edges of the very best grilled cheese. There’s a steady stream of takeout orders, and a tiny seating area crowded with neighborhood folk, especially on Tuesday when they sell $1 cheese slices from 5:30-6:30pm (or earlier, if they sell out). The Court Street shop is on the same block as F&F Pizzeria, but why choose? Having them both within a few feet of each other is a perfect excuse for a mini pizza crawl. Food Rundown Cheese For a crash course in Detroit-style, get the cheese slice. We wish every potato chip tasted like the burnt tips of its cheesy crust. Vodka The resounding favorite on our most recent visit. The ultra-creamy vodka sauce and that excellent crackly crust are a match made in pizza heaven. Supreme This one is about as over-the-top as you can get. It has not one, not two, but three types of meat—pepperoni, sausage, and thick-cut bacon. They’d be better off calling it the meat lover’s." - Willa Moore

Nate’s Detroit Pizza Carroll Gardens - Review - Carroll Gardens - New York - The Infatuation
Nathan Skid

451 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231 Get directions

natesdetroitpizzany.com
@nates_detroit_pizza

1 Postcard

See full details

More Places For You

Gerritsen Bagels Inc

Bagel shop · Gerritsen Beach

Tucked away in Gerritsen Beach, this local bagel haven serves up mouthwatering rainbow bagels and hearty breakfast sandwiches, perfect for your morning fix.

2 Postcards

Wild Ink

Restaurant · Chelsea

Asian-inspired eatery on the 5th floor of Hudson Yards with an oval-shaped bar & large wine wall.

9 Postcards

Rowdy Rooster - East Village

Fast food restaurant · East Village

Rowdy Rooster is the go-to spot in the East Village for mouthwatering fried chicken sandwiches with a fiery Indian twist—perfect for spice lovers!

18 Postcards

Olmsted

American restaurant · Prospect Heights

Olmsted is a charming Prospect Heights eatery where seasonally inspired dishes shine, all sourced from its lush backyard garden, making it a must-try for inventive brunches and dinners.

73 Postcards

Ichiran

Ramen restaurant · Chelsea

At Ichiran in Midtown, dive into authentic tonkotsu ramen in cozy solo booths designed for distraction-free slurping; just order on a kiosk and let the indulgence begin.

11 Postcards

FARIDA - MIDTOWN

Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen

An array of central Asian halal dishes in a rustic space with traditional decor & banquette seating.

12 Postcards

Speedy Romeo

Pizza restaurant · Lower East Side

Buzzy Italian joint for wood-fired pizza & grilled plates in cool digs with an open kitchen.

2 Postcards

WINNER

Cafe · South Slope

This laid-back café and bakery offers mouthwatering breads, pastries, and a fantastic coffee selection, all enjoyed on a charming outdoor patio.

24 Postcards

Orion Bar

Bar · Bushwick

Nestled in Bushwick, Orion Bar serves up inventive Korean-American bar snacks and playful soju cocktails, offering a cozy vibe for your next night out.

7 Postcards

Astor Place Hairstylists

Barber shop · NoHo

Astor Place Hairstylists is a beloved NYC gem that offers a whirlwind of skilled haircuts and colorful transformations, all with a vintage vibe that keeps locals coming back.

0 Postcards