"It takes a certain amount of humility for a team of Philadelphia writers to name something from New York the top in its class (especially when we’re talking about pizza). But that’s just how f*cking delicious the Hellboy Squared is. The square, upside-down pie comes loaded with sweet tomato sauce, mozzarella, pecorino romano, piles of Ezzo pepperoni, and hot honey, all on a sesame seed crust that gives it a nutty boost. It’s dense yet airy, making each bite a cheesy, crunchy, sweet and spicy revelation. We like the 80's basement vibe of this Washington Square spot–complete with a tube TV and duck hunt–but it’s the Hellboy that we just can’t quit." - alison kessler, candis mclean