22

Defonte's Sandwich Shop

Sandwich shop · Red Hook ·

Defonte's Sandwich Shop

Sandwich shop · Red Hook ·
@infatuation
132,791 Postcards · 3,235 Cities

The 15 Best Sandwiches In America 2024

"NEW YORK CITY Defonte’s is the old-school NYC Italian sandwich shop blueprint. They serve big fat sandwiches with names like Italian Stallion and The Zio Vito, there's someone who drove in from Jersey standing in line next to you, and the person behind the counter might be a little peeved that you’re trying to order at 3:15pm, even though they close at 4pm. A visit to this cash-only spot is the best Saturday adventure, and if it’s nice out you can head down to Louis Valentino Jr. pier and eat there. " - team infatuation, carlo mantuano

https://www.theinfatuation.com/all/guides/best-sandwiches-america
Emily Schindler

Information

Huge heroes stuffed with fried eggplant or chicken parmesan

fried eggplant
cash only
italian sandwich
old school
big sandwiches
nicky's special
golden boy special
roast pork sandwich
Google Rating
4.7 (1.8K)
Yelp Rating
4.4
Rated 9.0 by The Infatuation
9.0
Featured in Eater
Featured in
Featured in Conde Nast Traveler
Featured in
Featured in Grub Street
Featured in

379 Columbia St, Brooklyn, NY 11231 Get directions

$10–20

See Menu
Cash only
No restroom
Accepts reservations
Popular for lunch
Trendy
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by Noah Devereaux
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by Robert Sietsema/Eater NY
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by Emily Schindler
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by Kate Previte
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by Photo: Daniel Krieger
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by Robert Sietsema/Eater NY
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
See full details

22

Information

Huge heroes stuffed with fried eggplant or chicken parmesan

fried eggplant
cash only
italian sandwich
old school
big sandwiches
nicky's special
golden boy special
roast pork sandwich
Google Rating
4.7 (1.8K)
Yelp Rating
4.4
Rated 9.0 by The Infatuation
9.0
Featured in Eater
Featured in
Featured in Conde Nast Traveler
Featured in
Featured in Grub Street
Featured in

379 Columbia St, Brooklyn, NY 11231 Get directions

$10–20

See Menu
Cash only
No restroom
Accepts reservations
Popular for lunch
Trendy
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by Noah Devereaux
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by Robert Sietsema/Eater NY
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by Emily Schindler
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by Kate Previte
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by Photo: Daniel Krieger
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by Robert Sietsema/Eater NY
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
Defonte's Sandwich Shop by null
See full details

More Places For You

La Compagnie, Centre Street

Wine bar · SoHo

French wine bar with Mediterranean small plates & extensive list

30 Postcards

Quick Eternity

Cocktail bar · Financial District

Nautical-themed tavern with innovative cocktails & New England bites

5 Postcards

Anemi Modern Greek Mediterranean Cuisine

Greek restaurant · Astoria

Mezze, grilled fish, seafood pasta, Greek wines, cocktails

2 Postcards

Gnocchi Bella Forest Hills

Restaurant · Forest Hills

Customizable gnocchi bowls with rich sauces and proteins

2 Postcards

Madras Dosa Co.

South Indian restaurant · Flatiron District

Crispy dosas, flavorful fillings, rice plates, chaats, sandwiches

3 Postcards

YAO Modern Cantonese Cuisine 富瑤

Restaurant · Financial District

Modern Cantonese cuisine with tasting menus, private rooms, and duck

6 Postcards

Randall’s Barbecue

Barbecue restaurant · Lower East Side

Barbecue classics, unique dishes, draft beers, full bar

7 Postcards

Taqueria al Pastor

Taco restaurant · Ridgewood

Specializing in al pastor tacos with handmade tortillas

3 Postcards

Shy Shy

Cocktail bar · Chelsea

Golden hour martinis & botanical forward cocktails

4 Postcards

Early Yves Cafe

Coffee shop · Bedford-Stuyvesant

Pastries baked daily, brunch bites, and amazing lattes

1 Postcard