"Connolly’s, an Irish pub in the Rockaways, is most famous for their frozen piña coladas. A standard will run you $10, but you’ll want to upgrade it with a $2 floater of spiced rum, or maybe a "sinker" (rum poured on the bottom of your drink) or a "swimmer" (a layer of rum in the middle). Choose your own adventure. (Maybe get all three.)" - will hartman, sonal shah, molly fitzpatrick, willa moore