Aaron T.
Yelp
A slept on gem, a diamond in the rough, I can't gush enough. I used to live in West Village (pre gentrification, I could never afford it now) and Belle Isle was always expeditious, efficient, and delicious, I could always count on a great meal!
Once, I drunkenly ordered a small pie about an hour before they closed. When I arrived to pick up, the counter was deserted. After a few moments, an employee appeared from the back, clearly in the midst of those dreaded closing tasks. Once he had gathered my order info, he informed me that my pizza had been burnt, as the employees were closing shop for the evening and had forgotten about my wayward order (my words, not his) in the process. The employee took my name, phone number, and address, and promised me that they had a replacement pie in the oven for me and would deliver it free of charge.
I only lived a block away and had walked to pick up, but still a sweet gesture, as he hadn't known that prior to asking.
As promised, my perfected Supreme was delivered to my door in record time and free of charge along with the pizza they botched just in case I wanted to salvage it (I did).
Wonderful, friendly service, consistent product, and a surprisingly extensive ingredient option list, I mean, what more could I ask for?