pauline h
Google
I really wanted to like Blue Magpie, and perhaps because my hopes were so high, my disappointment was greater. I don't usually leave a review (especially a negative one) for a new place, but I am hoping the restaurant will see this feedback and improve.
First - all the stuff that was great: beautiful restaurant, very chic and inviting. The staff was great, from the host/hostess to servers. Easily 5 stars for service and atmosphere.
What needs major work: the food. First of all, the price (at least the dinner menu) is very high - that's not a problem if the dishes are worthwhile, but Blue Magpie's are not. We ordered Napa Casserole ($35), Fermented Rice Short Ribs ($60), Popcorn Chicken ($27), and Sesame Oil Chicken Rice ($45). The Napa Casserole: the cabbage was bland and flavorless, and my poor parents couldn't even chew through the cabbage and ended up having to spit it out. The Chinese description says it's baked cabbage, which is a traditional dish I knew of and this tasted nothing like it. The only char is the server bringing a torch to scorch a bit of cheese on top. I asked our server about this, and he said the cabbage is blanched and then the sauce is poured on top. This was not a good dish and they should remove it from the menu until they refine the recipe. Our server returned and said the kitchen offered to redo it, but at that point we were already done with our meal and it didn't sound like they were going to prepare it any differently so there was no point. The short rib had some good flavor and overall tasty, but I would say more than 1/3 of this was just fat. While I am in the camp of some slight fat on meat makes it taste better, at $60, there needs to be more lean meat. The popcorn chicken and sesame oil chicken rice were actually fine, but I wouldn't go back just for those dishes especially at those prices. In Arcadia - or SGV in general - there are so many authentic Taiwanese restaurants that serve these two dishes at a fraction of the cost, so they need to be much better than just fine. The food overall is 2-3 stars, but because of that Napa Casserole dish (that deserves 0 stars) I'm scoring them at a 2.
I'm a fan of upscale dining, and I was excited to see Blue Magpie attempt this with Taiwanese food, but a lot more work is needed here. Hopefully they can find the right balance on price and quality soon, otherwise they will get only curious one-time customers, and that's not sustainable as a business.