Enrique O.
Google
Please let me preface this rather extreme review by sharing that I typically do not leave negative reviews, as I understand the impact it has on a business. I grew up with a father who was a restauranteur, so I make every effort to be kind and engaging with staff to ensure they enjoy their experience with me as a guest they are serving, and to build a relationship for future visits.
As someone who fine dines multiple times a week, and a former fan of Margeaux that previously lived at this location, I had high hopes for Chez Nous. Beautiful design aesthetic aside, the experience was quite honestly the worst I have had at any restaurant in NYC, with 0 exaggeration.
Upon arrival the hostess at the front told me my guests had arrived, and advised me to walk to the back to find them… there was no queue at her station, so I would have expected her to escort me to the unknown
location at which my guests were seated.
2 of the 3 first round of cocktails were not made as described on their menu, but were easily returned and redeemed by a wonderful red wine suggestion from the server.
Our appetizers arrived and the cheese platter really was a joke. Even the serving staff laughed when we provided feedback on the dish, indicating they agreed at how ridiculous it was, that they have received the feedback countless times, and even went as far as to share that “the presentation is actually a recent upgrade”. Our request for additional jam to compliment the cheese was confirmed but then never arrived. $38 for literally 5 slices of cheese (not 5 TYPES), even for a guest who has the financial means to purchase the entire hotel if they desired, was truly insulting.
The entrees arrived and my guest bit into a large piece of plastic in her food. The response by the manager was anything but empathetic, with no introduction and not so much as a reassuring smile. She offered us free dessert as a remedy for the consecutively poor courses, which I declined in fear of consuming plastic.
This was the first time in 16 years of living in NYC that I did not eat my entree and actually called a nearby restaurant from the dinner table to make a reservation within the hour, then prematurely left Chez Nous.
The icing on the cake was a male server thinking it was appropriate to offer his phone number to my female guest to “take care of her” when she privately advised him that we still intended to offer considerable gratuity to the servers for trying to make the situation as best as they could within their respective roles.
My overall sense is this new restaurant opened earlier than it should have before working through the menu, did not hire a consistently high caliber of staff to meet the expectations of fine dining, and did not find their rhythm to ensure they are delivering an experience to be proud of. This visit left much to be desired and I’m hoping if I revisit in the future, they will have worked through these opportunities.