Colby D.
Yelp
After learning from another Yelp review that owners of the Taco Stand and Himitsu came together to open Comedor Nishi, I was excited to try this place. I really enjoy both of those restaurants and think they're both done very well.
The whole vibe is really cute. It reminds me of a place you'd see in Portland or Seattle--an intimate dining experience tucked away, just off the main road, with mood lighting, a neutral color scheme with bright accents, and an open kitchen layout. I wanted to love this place; I wanted it to become my next regular spot.
I want to preface the rest of this review by making it clear that I understand that they are a new restaurant and still have some kinks to work out, but my partner assured me that early feedback is the most helpful kind of feedback, so I decided to review.
We started off ordering the sangria and suero cocktails, which consisted of red and white wine, respectively, as well as topo chico, lime juice, and sea salt. Our server, while friendly, didn't mention that they needed to refill the lime juice to make our second drink until we received it, which was at the time they brought out our main food items (about 20-30 minutes after we had ordered the two drinks).
We had started drinking the sangria first when they brought out the double chocolate-miso cookie and pineapple scone that we ordered, and right away we felt that the sangria had too much salt in it. We like interesting drinks, especially espresso tonics, and we thought that these drinks would be reminiscent of them. Instead, they tasted like something closer to a margarita, which I suppose is how you get around not having a full liquor license in the early days.
I tried the pineapple scone first, and we felt that this was the best thing we ordered overall. The sweetness of the pineapple was subtle enough to not overpower the saltiness of the scone, and we would have enjoyed it even more if the sangria hadn't been so salty.
Next we tried the cookie, and while it was rich in flavor, and the concept of a chocolate, miso, and sesame cookie sounds amazing, we both thought there were too many sesame seeds on top. It was a little too loud, if you know what I mean. It was like "I have these ingredients and I want to use them, but I just don't know how to blend it all together." Like Guy Fieri was gonna pop out at any second.
As I mentioned, we tried the suero when it came out with the main items we ordered, which were the Torta de Cochinita Pibil and the Pan Frances. The suero tasted even more like a margarita, and the lime was even a bit too overpowering.
The cochinita pibil torta also came with black beans, avocado, and pickled onions. The bread was soft enough that you could cut it in half without too much trouble, but still had the crispy outer shell that offers a crunchy texture. The meat was decently cooked, but my partner and I felt that the torta lacked something overall. Maybe it was that our drinks were so salty that we couldn't taste much salt in anything else, or maybe it was that the torta's flavors were so subtle that they simply couldn't be discerned, but at this point in the meal, we were starting to feel a bit disappointed.
We dug into the Pan Frances last, hoping to end on a sweet note, but alas, it wasn't in the cards. Again we were enticed by the promise of a well-crafted Mexican-Japanese menu item that lived up to the legacies of the Taco Stand and Himitsu, but again we felt it fell flat. The bread was dense and cakey, similar to concha bread, and probably similarly as unsweetened. Whereas on conchas you have the sugary coating on top, this bread had sour cream and berry compote. The toppings were too tart for the rest of the bread, which felt flavorless in comparison. We didn't finish this or the cookie, but my partner decided to take the bread home so he could attempt to fix it up later.
Overall, this place has great potential. We were very intrigued by the menu items and are looking forward to returning in the future to try lunch and/or dinner, but we feel that the menu items need a bit of a reworking in the meantime. Like, keep all the same items but just work on the ingredient ratios. We're hoping this feedback is useful to someone with input on the menu.