Kyle H.
Yelp
Tonight marked our 7th visit to Elvie's since moving to Jackson in July '24. It quickly became one of our top dining spots, and until now, every experience had been a clear 5-star.
We arrived at 6:30 pm on a Wednesday, were warmly greeted, and promptly seated. We ordered our usual apps--duck fat fries and beef tartare--both excellent as always. After finishing, we ordered entrees: pork chop for my husband and the amberjack & risotto special for me. As the restaurant filled, we noticed that tables seated after us had already received their entrees while we were still waiting.
When our food arrived (about 25 minutes later), my husband's pork chop looked phenomenal, but my risotto was clearly off--soupy and undercooked, with grains of rice that crunched in my teeth. I politely pointed this out to our server, who agreed it looked off and took it back to be corrected. She separated my amberjack so I could enjoy it while waiting.
When the risotto returned, it was fully cooked but even runnier than before--almost like soup. Though I tried to eat a few bites, it was unappetizing. Our server checked in, and not wanting to seem difficult, I hesitantly said it was okay. When the manager later asked if it was better, we admitted, "not exactly... just an off night." She replied, "our chef likes to prepare risotto a bit on the al dente side," which felt dismissive--this wasn't al dente, it was initially crunchy and then overly runny.
Our total was $140 (without dessert or cocktails). We love Elvie's and plan to return, hoping this was just an outlier. However, we'd appreciate issues being handled with a bit more care in the future.