Fairway Market of 74th Street

Miyokos cream cheese yes please! Also nuts for cheese smoke Gouda, country crock plant based whip cream.. this place has more vegan options than most in the upper west side

Don’t take me wrong, this Fairway branch has great variety of products and great quality. This 3* go for the hot bar, where the quality is a rocky mountain. I bought beef stew and yellow rice yesterday. At my office, I realized the sauce had disappeared, the beef was not edible -I cut not cut it with my knife because it will break apart into pieces- it was old over- boiled beef. The after taste was disgusting. I took it back and after talking to three staff members only the first one acknowledge that they had to remove it from the hot bar. The Manager, Christian, was very disrespectful and told me to go the MD if I felt sick! I have already written a feedback note to the company and I’m not planning to come back. No apology was provided.

Shopping at Fairway is a new experience for me. Recently my OTC benefits changed. So here I am shopping at Fairway. This location is spacious with so much variety of products. Their meat department is amazing. The fresh coffee selection is also impressive. The staff at the meat and coffee departments were so friendly today. This is now a go to market. My organic eggs were quite the buy, this morning. Highly recommended!

Visited just once for a little shopping as a tourist. Encountered a terrible experience lastly - completely ignored by a casher although she had looked cheerful with all other customers in front of me in line. But, to me, no greeting, no smile, no eye contact, no reading out the total price and, of course, no thank you. Learned interesting Social Studies from a racist?

Fairway market has had a cafe upstairs for years! Every time I stop in it’s always a different but wonderful experience! This time the beef burger was fantastic! Grass fed beef perfectly cooked and garnished! Simple yet compelling! Kinda wish they would install banquets around the perimeter to warm the space up and make it more comfortable! So happy fairway has overcome the effects of Wall Street miss handling!

One of my favorite places to visit when I am in that area. During the spring and summer, the flower selections are amazing but quite pricey. Given their location most of the items are pricey but my favorite is the bakery department - their selection never disappoints me. The line moved quickly, but I expected it to be at 11am. Overall a nice little market.

Despite its high price point, adore this store. Watch for sales! Some great deals. It annoyed me that their French bread prices went up, but I still buy it. Unfailingly helpful and friendly staff. I am proud to support this business.

I used to love Fairway, but now it's more or less a normal grocery store in terms of product selection. (Although still better than many New York markets.) The service is very inconsistent. The cafe staff are friendly and the customer service agents sometimes floating around are wonderful, but the checkout staff are clocking it. Do you enjoy bagging your own groceries? Then you'll have a synergistic relationship with the cashiers who seem to enjoy watching you bag them. Will I keep going? Yes. Sadly. I prefer TJs down the street, but it's closer than Morton Williams and I apparently prioritize convenience.