Forsyth Seafood Market & Cafe

It is a fish market with a dining space next to it. When you entered you order your food and pay for it. They provide you with a pager that will ring when your order is ready. You get your sauce from a dispensary that is stationed in the middle of the dining area. Their were many people placing takeout orders. The place looked clean and cozy. I had the shrimp dinner. The candied yams were too sweet and it taste so much like caramel candy. The collard green and shrimp were good and even gave me some hush puppies on the side.

Food was not that good. Ordered a scallop boat $12 (5 fried scallops) and a $5 baked potato. Potato was fine but scallops were salty and tasted like they were fried in old oil. The place smelled fishy when we walked in because of the fish market. If the fish is fresh it shouldn’t smell. Also the floor was very sticky. Guess being from New England has spoiled me on good seafood. The staff was very friendly and efficient.

The food here is incredibly good. Seasoned so perfectly. Everything from the flounder to the oysters to the shrimp, is so delicious. As well as the sides, some of the best collard greens I have ever had. Really good desserts too that they make in house, we tried the strawberry shortcake and the banana pudding. Great hardworking people here that will cook you an awesome seafood meal. Will definitely be back!

Just wanted to take a moment to say—your seafood is absolutely incredible. The freshness, the flavors, the way every dish is prepared with care—it all speaks volumes. Whether it’s a simple grilled fish or a more complex seafood platter, your food doesn’t just satisfy hunger—it creates an experience. Keep doing what you’re doing. You’ve mastered the art of making seafood taste the way it should—fresh, flavorful, and unforgettable. ~Teresa Taylor

Good spot for fried seafood. I came here with coworkers earlier in the week for the first time, I had been wanting to try it for awhile being new to the area. I ordered the pick two combo- popcorn shrimp and fried clams with a cup of seafood gumbo and mac and cheese. The shrimp and clams were great, mac and cheese was okay, nothing spectacular. But I appreciated the variety of sauces available- tartar, cocktail, hot sauce, ketchup. A little surprised they didn't offer tap water, said we would have to buy a bottle, so I just got my water bottle from the car. Service was friendly but a bit slow, it took over 20 mins for us to get our food after ordering and it didn't seem too crowded/busy at the time. A bit pricey for lunch, but it is seafood. Overall, I'd recommend going if you're craving some fried goodness.

My partner and I came here for lunch it was both of our first time. we had asked if our food could be made before the time the computer had generated it would start getting prepared. Because we work in EMS. it would have been fine if they said no, But instead the cook was very rude and nasty. “I don’t know why they came here before there food is ready”. Her tone was very hostile and rude. I really had high hopes for this place obviously I want to support black owned businesses. Happy Juneteenth to us.

I see why Forsyth Seafood was voted best Seafood in 2020. Hands down the best seafood in the area. Everything made fresh to order. Staff were friendly and made great suggestions on popular items. Fried Snapper hush puppies and Jumbo Shrimp were amazing! Forsyth has two sides a dinning side and Fresh Seafood market. Mobile ordering and EBT are available.

I wish I could give more than 5 stars for this restaurant. Friendly staff and delicious food. Some of the best seafood I have eaten, especially the shrimp and oysters. This is a must try restaurant if you are in Winston Salem.

Just WOW. I love good seafood. This was way better than anything I just had at the coast last week. And the cost was great. It was so fresh. And almost too hot to eat when we got it to the table. Whiting filets were absolutely perfect. Shrimp is not easy to cook just right- but they were dead nut perfect. The sauces are really good. And as much as you want. The sides, okra and white slaw were as good as any of mine homemade. Possibly better. The hush puppies will kill you. I just wish they gave me more to die for. NEXT- the fresh fish on ice next door is where I will be going from now on instead of the so-called fresh fish at the stores. ***My last word- If y'all don't go eat here and buy your fish, y'all are making a bigass mistake.***

I LOVE Forsyth Seafood and I always forget how amazing it is. I've only been here a handful of times but each time I tell myself I need to make this a regular seafood destination. The staff is always super friendly and this time was no exception. It was a Friday evening and I fully expected them to be busy. The dining room was not crowded but they had a steady stream of customers in the market side and restaurant side the whole time I was there. I browsed the digital menu and decided what I wanted but as soon as I got to the counter to order I saw a whole snapper special and immediately changed my mind. Everything is of course cooked to order so it was a little wait but not too bad at all. When my order was done I was so happy I got the snapper. It was so perfectly fried and seasoned! Moist and tender with a mild flavor that was addictive. Both my husband and I agreed this was the best seafood we've had in a while. It was also such a big portion I couldn't finish it. Thank goodness my husband was there to help me finish it. I highly recommend trying this if you see it offered. The ambiance is very casual and kind of cafeteria like. You have your basic table and chairs but decor isn't important when the seafood is this good. Just sit anywhere and wait for your delicious seafood to be ready.

Everything I ordered was delicious, had the catfish, shrimp and crab cake. My new to go spot in WS!

The best whole fried flounder in NC!! Yeahhhh, give it up for Forsyth Seafood Market & Cafe. I have been drooling on my phone for years about eating here and I finally got the opportunity. The flounder was the best thing on the plate. I had hiccups with my baked potato being bad. I sent it back 3 times and each time, it was the same. When I opened it up, it looked like potato flakes for instant mashed potatoes. I have no idea what would make a baked potato appear that way, but I know it was not normal, and was not going to eat it. I eventually ended up with mac and cheese in a one ounce condiment cup to replace my baked potato. I can say, I came for the fish and not the sides. The reason I gave it 4 stars! That fish was amazing! I can do without the chili pepper flakes added on top though! I'll be back soon!! Wish we had this in Greensboro! Also, I joked with my friend that I was disappointed that I did not get the "whole fish" because its head was missing. I love the head being on my fish! Some of the best tastings!

Good spot for fried seafood. I came here with coworkers earlier in the week for the first time, I had been wanting to try it for awhile being new to the area. I ordered the pick two combo- popcorn shrimp and fried clams with a cup of seafood gumbo and mac and cheese. The shrimp and clams were great, mac and cheese was okay, nothing spectacular. But I appreciated the variety of sauces available- tartar, cocktail, hot sauce, ketchup. A little surprised they didn't offer tap water, said we would have to buy a bottle, so I just got my water bottle from the car. Service was friendly but a bit slow, it took over 20 mins for us to get our food after ordering and it didn't seem too crowded/busy at the time. A bit pricey for lunch, but it is seafood. Overall, I'd recommend going if you're craving some fried goodness.

This place is a diamond in the rough! The ambient characteristics are pretty on par with a "fish joint," but the food is so, so, so, SO good. I had the flounder dinner (broiled) with slaw and gumbo as my sides. My only regret is that I didn't place a separate order for a larger portion of gumbo! Can't wait to go back!

Love love love Forsyth Seafood all the time any time whether I'm dining in or ordering through Uber eats online. I love mostly all of their fish and shrimp and even the steamed crabs. A win in seafood in Winston for me.

best seafood in the south, friendly service that will make you feel like you at a family fish fry.

Being originally from New York, visiting a fresh fish market is nothing new to me. For some time I've been craving Alaskan King crab legs so I went on a mission to locate a store, ANY store within Winston-Salem that sold them. No success at Lowe's, Harris Teeter, etc. etc. (Sam's Club was the only one carrying them). A local suggested I checkout Forsyth Seafood Market so I did. Unfortunately, they only carry snow crab legs (at $27.99 a pound!!) Disappointed (and a bit shocked, I must confess) that a seafood market refused to carry Alaskan King crab legs, I had to remind myself and come to a realization that the actual location of the market could be exactly why they don't carry Alaskan King crab legs (which are the most expensive crab legs one can purchase). Still... with snow crab legs listed at $27.99 a pound, which are not at all cheap, affordable prices, I cram to understand the logic behind how they do business. In any case, the staffed butcher was more than helpful answering my questions. He was even cool enough to weigh in some snow crab legs for me to provide a price range of what a bag of them would generally cost. With this establishment being both a dine-in restaurant (which I did not visit... yet) AND a fresh seafood market attached to it, one has to still admire the overall presentation and ambiance. I look forward to returning to experience the actual restaurant... You should, as well.

Lovely place in Winston Salem. We were out of town and headed back home and wanted good food for lunch. This hit the spot! Clean establishment. Very clean seafood market with the restaurant attached. Staff were friendly and smiling. They seem to have regulars, as they knew what people wanted when they came in the door. My husband had the Pick 3 Combo: (w/2 sides) Catfish (nice and meaty!) Jumbo shrimp Fried oysters (for an additional charge) Mac & Cheese Fried Okra I had the whole fried flounder dinner: (w/2 sides) Huge bone in flounder Collard greens Cole slaw (some of the best I've had) All seafood was very fresh. Crispy & flakey. We will be paying them another visit when we're back in the area.

The fresh seafood market has a wide variety of items for you to take home and make your own. Eating in the restaurant was good we had the platter with shrimp and clams they were fried golden brown to perfection along with the hushpuppies. The Mac and cheese was excellent as well.

I walked up to the Cafe and before I could get in was taken straight to the beach with the smell of fresh seafood. This is the only place I will get seafood in this area! I had the catfish with Mac n cheese and gumbo and my wife had the founder with slaw and hush puppies. Every single item was above our expectations including the slaw which had an awesome celery flavor. The Mac n cheese was the kind you go back for thirds for and the gumbo was like going to New Orleans! We were both really happy with our fish. The cut was clean and the fry was perfect. There weren't a ton of people in there for Thursday lunch so get on in there people!!

They need an active working website. Called many times with no response. Hit Contact Us with no response. Are you closed??may past experiences were good with fresh seafood. Now Im not so sure. Please send out emails flyers so your customers would know you exist Jumbo ShrimpOysters Scallops Snow Crab Legs

What a fantastic place to support local, enjoy delicious fresh seafood and meet great people. This is a very popular spot for fresh seafood that is brought in several days a week. There is a counter service where you can order prepared food and grab a table to enjoy. We had a party of 4 and ordered, scallops, clam strips, oysters and fish. All of it was extremely fresh like it was caught that day. A special note about the clam strips is that they were not chewy like so many restaurants, these were absolutely delicious. During our meal the owner came out and stopped by the various tables thanking customers for visiting their place. So very kind. Through another door you can order fresh fish to take home and prepare yourself. Both areas had lines but they went quick so no long waits. I will definitely return to buy some fresh fish to put in my grill and avoid the grocery store.

Good food with great people . It was my first time there they helped me pick things out and everything I chose was good

I've been buying fish and eating at Forsyth Seafood since I was a girl. This review is mostly for the café and not the fish market (which is the ONLY place in town to buy FRESH NC + VA caught fish, mollusks and crustaceans) which is a wonderful community resource and accepts cash, card and EBT as forms of payment. Like, I said: I've been a customer for years, since it was on Broad Street where the Dash ballpark is now. AND it's gotten better over the years with a ton of offerings like gumbo, crabcakes, honey drizzled hushpuppies, seasonal soft-shell crab, blue crabs, and crab legs. My latest visit: I went with my mom and qw both had the whole fried flounder (with sides to make it a meal). We ate inside and while we waited for our food, the dining room was nearly empty. A few tables sat down to eat while we were there, but most were picking up orders they called in. PRO TIP: CALL IN YOUR ORDER because the kitchen is extremely short-staffed and it will take time to get your order together. It's 100% worth the wait.

I ordered their crab cakes, hush puppies, and macaroni-n-cheese and the breading tasted the same across the board. I believe there needs to be different batter for every item. Not bad service and the food tasted good, it just all tasted the same because they use the same better for everything.

Worst experience at a seafood market. Dead crawfish, waited 30 min just to get to a man that told me my order is on the cooked restaurant side. I told him no I did it online order for the market side he questioned me again. Then he left for about 10 minutes and came back and walked over to a machine that had my order still hanging out from where it was printed at 2:30 in the afternoon for a 4:30 PM pick up this guy could've cared less about my order or me and I gave him no grief or lip. I decided I would like another pound of shrimp and that took another 20 minutes to find 1 pound of shrimp. Horrible '!!! ruin a day , lack of service or caring and a great dont give a shit attitude.. Don't advertise online ordering if no one knows how to use it! First time there and last time there

If your looking for great friendly service and good fish then this is your spot! I had the whole red snapper plate with coleslaw. The fish was seasoned and fried perfectly! If you get it be prepared to pay market price but I promise you it's worth it!

Maybe I'm picky, maybe it's the time of day that I visit. Service is lacking. Food is so-so. Took forever to receive my order. I probably could have driven to the coast, stopped at Walmart to get a rod and reel, found a pier, caught my own fish, driven back to Winston, cleaned, and cooked the fish quicker than this. Service like this makes me pause when it comes to supporting BOBs

The seafood and shrimp were absolutely excellent! Sides very good except the baked potato would be better with a bit of crusty on it. Cocktail sauce a little too sweet.

Forsyth Seafood has been on my list of places to try. I was in the area and decided to check it out. They had a huge selection of fresh fish. I decided to get some NC shrimp. They were excellent. The man who helped us was nice and showed my son a fish up close. You can tell they love their customers. I can't wait to come back and buy more fish and eat at the cafe.

It's always a solid meal at Forsyth Seafood, but I never think to write a review. When it comes to fried fish, it's always fresh, lightly battered and piping hot. Tonight we got the Captain Charlie's Platter with flounder, shrimp, oysters and clams. The flounder was perfect, and a good sized piece, the oysters were big, plump and juicy, the clams were tender and the popcorn shrimp was on point. But tonight's special was the star of the show: fried whole Red Snapper! It was so tender, flaky and the batter was adorned with an abundance of red pepper flakes! It wasn't too spicy at all, but man was this excellent! The slow was cold and flavorful, hush puppies were lightly sweetened and the mac and cheese was bland. My wife got a baked potato which was a nice side option. Overall a very good meal.

From the time that you walk in the door to exiting the building you get the best customer service ever . So I am visiting in town with my boyfriend and he decides to bring me here . I'm super mad that he didn't bring me here when we first started dating because the food is just that DAMN GOOD! I ended up ordering a pick 2 which came with 1 piece of fish ( they gave me an extra because it took a little longer ). It also came with popcorn shrimp , Cole slaw hush puppies and my choice of a side , I ended up going with the sweet potato. THE FOOD WAS AMAZING HOT AND FRESH. I'm not eating sweets right now but if I was I would have for sure gotten some of the strawberry short cake. I can't wait to come back and try the desserts they were homemade , huge and fresh . If you are in the Winston Salem area do yourself a favor and visit this place , I promise you that you WILL JOT BE DISAPPOINTED!

Very nice place family dining & the best fish in the area! My place to eat fish!!! Dare you to try it!

I recommend for fried seafood only, the fish market area needs a lot of help. Thanks for posting.

So, so good!!!! I can't believe how good it was. I had high expectations, which sometimes can end up disappointing. This was not the case! Everyone was so nice. I'll be back ASAP!

Wonderful first time experience hit fresh flavorful seafood. I enjoyed a fried founder w fried oysters coleslaw and seafood gumbo w no seafood but I'll give them a pass this go round, the hush puppies were perfectly sweetened and crispy, the staff was pleasant the restaurant was very clean and the market side did not wreak of a foul seafood smell I will definitely be back. If you are on WSU campus or nearby it's on the same street as the campus off the highway very convenient location!

I really loved this place the first time I visited! But each subsequent time has left me a little lackluster. I wish the fry batter was more unique for each item. As is I can't really distinguish what I'm eating unless it one of their delicious hush puppies!

Service and staff were excellent, food is extremely fresh and comes out quickly. I will be coming back for sure and if they have the soft shell crab BLT you must order it, incredibly good

Where is the 10 star option? I'm big on customer service & I've never seen customer service at this level in all my many years. There was a slight hiccup from this place which involved me traveling over 30 mins to Winston & returning home without the steamed crabs I ordered. But listen, this is the icing on the cake! The owner herself traveled all the way to my home the next day to give me what I ordered with a smile. Her & Sonya was extra apologetic & made up for all the trouble. I am in awe!! Will be returning again & again. This is excellence!

Went and purchased 10 pieces of croaker. Not exactly sure why they are more expensive than any other fish for 10 pieces. The fish not only lacked taste but it wasn't cleaned properly. I live in another state. I came to get my fish only to be disappointed.

My go to place for seafood in Winston-Salem. Freshly cooked seafood with affordable prices. Service is awesome and depending on the time or day you can be in and out in 15 minutes. Servings are overflowing so much the food is hanging out the carton.

I had no idea this place has been opened for so long. Apparently it was originally on Broad St. plenty of seating and it's light colors and sea decor give it a seaside feeling. You place your order 1st and then they call your #. The meals and baskets are all fried. The tilapia is plentiful with two decent pieces, same on the sandwich. Plenty of sides, from creamy Cole slaw, baked sweet potatoe to soft hush puppies. Make sure you get the silky homemade fresh clam chowder soup. The large shrimp basket is my favorite as well as the scallops. But for a meal I would go with the fish combo or sandwich. They have self serve drinks and condiments. Great place for lunch or dinner solo or with family.

From my experience they always have fresh fish and seafood. I'm super stoked that they have live crabs and you gotta get there right when they open which is at 11am. Half a dozen will cost you about $33.44 including tax. They can also filet your fish while you wait. They also take EBT or PEBT - if you want fried seafood to go they can also take fresh order and made to cook. Friendly staff and knowledgeable. I recommend this place!

Delicious but a little slow. Clean but a 94. Fantastic Mac and cheese.I am super picky but would absolutely come here again! Advice would be to call in your order.

We do love fried seafood, and we finally made it to this combination seafood market and cafe. I was especially looking forward to trying the bone in Whiting, one of the most under rated fish there is, along with bone in Black Sea Bass. I don't mind working my way thru the bones as long as there is enough meat to make it worthwhile. The restaurant, which has been around since 1984, is bright and clean, and is rather large. You know that you are in the presence of fish, but there is not a heavy, unpleasant air to the place. It is strictly no frills - plastic plates and table ware, condiment table in the middle with hot sauce, tarter sauce, napkins, small packets of salt & pepper, and functional wooden tables & straight back chairs. We ordered 2 item combos - bone in Whiting (2 pieces), with Potato Salad and Slaw, and Flounder (2 pieces) with FFs and Slaw - both came with HPs - and with 2 soft drinks, the tab was $29.85, more than a bit pricey for lunch, especially considering the portion sizes. The time out of the kitchen wasn't at all bad, but what we were served wasn't worth the price. This is especially true for the Whiting - there were 2 small, butterflied fish, heavily battered, and very much over cooked. Picking thru to fish any meat, yield perhaps a 1/4 cup of flesh - bit of a ripoff! The HPs were good, as was the Potato Salad (bit different with a little dill pickle & a touch of mustard). The slaw is sweeter than I care for, and very wet. The Flounder fillets were not as over cooked, but did come out a touch on the dry side. The FFs are battered and were excellent - best item in the entire meal. The service was efficient, but not friendly, or in anyway engaging. I don't know that we'd return here considering the value and quality aspects we encountered. Coulda been a bad day in the kitchen for the quality problems, but the value consideration is gonna be there.

Everything was absolutely delicious and so flavorful! Don't skip dessert, I'll dream about the strawberry shortcake

Love this place and staff are super funny.l always place a big order .l could eat seafood every day

Knocked it out of the park! I had flounder, oysters, and shrimp, more than enough. Wife hade Whiting and oysters and gave me part of the whiting. The sides were plentiful and delicious, great cole slaw! Service was top notch, counter waitresses were courteous and very friendly. Gave good tips on ordering and where everything was. I like the cocktail sauce and tartar was serve your self. Drinks were self serving and let you get refills! Server was joking with another customer about their service was as good as Chik Fi La, and I would agree, they are also closed on a Sunday! We will be back!

Haven't stopped in awhile, but figured this was the day I would. I got 2pcs Whittening, sweet potato, hush puppies, and slaw for $8.53. I expected more of a crowd being around lunch and the day after Valentine Day. It was actually good to see I was wrong. I was ready to eat. I took about 10min to get my plate, for me I would have preferred a little more kick in seasoning. I guess they use(promoted everywhere) House of Raeford mix since they had a stand near the cash register load up. Decor wasn't dated and the music playing wasn't overwhelming. Staff was real friendly. Portions of fish were actually good sizes.

This seafood was delicious. We had the battered cod and shrimp with sweet potato and Mac and cheese. Don't forget to add the Banana pudding for dessert. Great staff. Easy ordering online and ready on time. Our new spot!

Fish was fresh from both the restaurant and fresh fish section. I was visiting Winston Salem and saw this place on Yelp. Glad I tried it. The owners and staff were very pleasant. Would have given a 5 rating but my baked potato wasn't hot. Other than that I'd recommend wholeheartedly.

Hands down - the best seafood in town. Always fresh fish and seafood, properly prepped and perfectly cooked. Easy order and a pleasant pick-up experience. Good people and awesome food - you can't ask for anything better.

I have been going to this place for years and it has never occurred to me to leave a review. Today, our food was so amazing that I had to call them back and let them know! I had the Bone-In Croaker (my favorite) with collards. The collards were so delicious, I'm thinking of going back by there after work to pick up some more! Even the hushpuppies were tasty, and I don't really even care for them. I shared with my coworker, just so she could understand! Thank you guys for continuing to provide great service and delicious food to our community!

The food was very tasty especially the fried whiting - well seasoned and fried just right! Fried okra was also delicious. To make it even better, the customer service was superb. Kimberly helped me with a phone order and though they were super busy, she was very friendly and patient. I would certainly choose them again!

I Lovvvvvvvvvve Lovvvvvvvvvve this place!!! Best fish and cole slaw!! Great staff as well.

Definitely the best I've been too since being in the triad! Everything was fresh and delicious! Felt just like home cooking for me! Authentic and full of love! Yasss

Glad we made the stop on our trip through. It's conveniently right off the exit. The staff is nice and the seafood is fresh with the market right there. It is a seafood market so the fish smell takes a minute to adjust to. The dining area is nicely decorated and bathrooms are clean. The portions are generous and you could easily feed 2 off one combo. Would highly recommend!

This place came highly recommended. Not knowing what hat to expect i went with just a two piece fish sandwich. It was more like 1 and a half. They gave me some small pieces that were suppose to equate to one filet.....but it was not. The fish was Hot and fresh but lacked flavor. Personally I would have rather eaten fish from red lobster.... it has wayyyyy more flavor! I