Delilah M.
Yelp
I'm struggling to understand the 5-star reviews of Republic. I'm not sure if I caught the Chef on an off night - but the food was far from great.
We had a small group & ordered several items from the menu: Tallow Onion Rings, the Pig Heart Carpaccio, Rabbit, Carrots, Ploughman's Plate, Fried Green Tomatoes, & the Potatoes. We also ordered a few of their craft cocktails - here is my lengthy summary.
First off when we arrived our 2 partners were already at our table. The first thing we were told by our friend was that he had so far ordered (3) beers off of the menu and they were out of all three. *sigh*. The more frustrating part of this experience is that when the waitress returned for another try - she ONLY took his drink order. This means the three other people at the table had not even ordered drinks, while she tried to find our friend's beer. (Note: I do not hold the waitress accountable for the out of stock beer.)
Finally - about 20 minutes after arriving - we have received drinks. This is probably due to the fact that only one bartender was working on a Friday night. Service was SLOW. I ordered their Devil Wears Prado, which is a spicy, margarita type drink. My partner ordered a dirty martini with a vermouth rinse. My drink was okay. The kick of the spice was nice, but the other flavors weren't noticeable. It also came in a tiny NYE style champagne glass - which I HATED. I don't understand why either -since tequila is not served like this. My partner's martini came in the same glass - which was laughable. The martini was not made to order, and was terrible.
Moving along - we started with the Ploughman which is the meat & cheese board. I was a little underwhelmed. There were only two (2) types of cheese to the 5 types of meat. Boring. The bacon loaf was snackalicious though. The dill spread was divine, the spicy mustard was average and the rest was unmemorable.
The Pig Heart Carpaccio was not exciting at all. It was relatively flavorless and sliced into tiny little pieces (no wonder there was not flavor). The Tallow Onion Rings were served at the same time and they were great! Deeply fried and flavorful....but they're onion rings....
The Rabbit and the Carrots got the highest of praise, although the rabbit definitely was not the start of his dish (the pistachios were). The carrots were cooked well and had a nice braise to them and I would recommend this dish.
The Fried Green tomatoes and the Tallow fries were bad. The tomatoes were over cooked & the breading was far too crunchy. The poached egg was slightly overdone with this dish as well. This made me sad. I love fried green tomatoes, and really wanted this dish to be excellent. The Tallow Fries were terrible! Overdone fries that were (get this) somehow too salty AND bland at that same time. We spent about 10 minutes trying to wrap our heads around it. The dipping sauce they were served with was runny and also seemed bland.
We skipped dessert.
Overall - it is not worthy of the price or the wait. Again - maybe we got them on an off night - but when you are claiming to be the place that Republic wants to be, you cannot have "off nights". On the other hand our server was great. I believe her name was Ashley.