Nobody Told Me

Cocktail bar · Upper West Side

Nobody Told Me

Cocktail bar · Upper West Side

5

951 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10025

Photos

Nobody Told Me by null
Nobody Told Me by De Graux Imaging
Nobody Told Me by De Graux Imaging
Nobody Told Me by null
Nobody Told Me by null
Nobody Told Me by null
Nobody Told Me by null
Nobody Told Me by null
Nobody Told Me by null
Nobody Told Me by null
Nobody Told Me by null
Nobody Told Me by null
Nobody Told Me by null
Nobody Told Me by null
Nobody Told Me by null
Nobody Told Me by null
Nobody Told Me by null
Nobody Told Me by null
Nobody Told Me by null
Nobody Told Me by null
Nobody Told Me by null
Nobody Told Me by null

Highlights

Nobody Told Me is a vibrant Upper West Side cocktail bar where playful drinks and globally-inspired bites thrive in a cozy tropical-chic atmosphere.  

Featured in The Infatuation
Featured on Michelin
Featured in Eater

951 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10025 Get directions

nobodytoldme.nyc
@nobodytoldme_nyc

Menu

Information

Static Map

951 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10025 Get directions

nobodytoldme.nyc
@nobodytoldme_nyc

Menu

Features

dine in
takeout
delivery
payment credit card
Tap to pay
reservations

Last updated

Jul 7, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@infatuation

"When: Daily, 3-6pm The Deal: $2 oysters; $5 chicken slider; $12-$14 cocktails; $12 wine; $10 beer and shot; $7 beers on draft Nobody Told Me is a neighborhood cocktail spot on the UWS, with tropical wallpaper and drinks with ingredients like corn and strawberry shrub. If you can slip out of work a bit early, get a seat near the big windows up front and enjoy $2 oysters, discounted drinks, and sliders from 3-6pm." - willa moore, neha talreja, will hartman

The Best Oyster Happy Hours In NYC
View Postcard for Nobody Told Me
@michelinguide

"My go-to casual spot is Nobody Told Me uptown. They have the best fried chicken sandwich and burger in the city, hands down." - Edward Barsamian

Designer Bach Mai on His MICHELIN Guide Must Try's
View Postcard for Nobody Told Me
@infatuation

"Nobody Told Me is a neighborhood cocktail spot on the Upper West Side where you can grab a drink with ingredients like pineapple-infused rum and coconut cashew milk. It’s a little room with tropical wallpaper and some big windows up front, and it’s ideal spot to grab a drink after work or read a book while drinking something alcoholic. And if you get hungry, there’s a full dinner menu with things like a chicory caesar salad and a fried chicken sandwich." - Bryan Kim

Nobody Told Me Review - Upper West Side - New York - The Infatuation
View Postcard for Nobody Told Me
@eater

"Nobody Told Me is a new cocktail bar on the Upper West Side, created by Nick Pfannerstill and Alberto Miranda. The bar features quality cocktails and lively bar fare, with a focus on a younger crowd. The menu includes shareable snacks, robust dishes, and playful cocktails. The food showcases Pfannerstill’s fine dining background, with dishes like blistered shishito peppers and barbecue cabbage. Cocktails by Miranda include innovative drinks like the 'Pepper Jelly Julep' and a tequila drink in a Day of the Dead-esque prayer candle." - Carla Vianna

Nobody Told Me, a Cocktail Bar from a Dovetail Vet, Opens on the Upper West Side - Eater NY
View Postcard for Nobody Told Me
@eater

"In July, Nick Pfannerstill — who was previously at Michelin-starred Dovetail — will open Nobody Told Me. Pfannerstill described the restaurant as “fast cuisine.”" - Kayla Kumari Upadhyaya

UWS Is About to Get a Slew of Promising New Restaurants - Eater NY
View Postcard for Nobody Told Me

Blake Rasmussen

Google
A solid little cocktail bar. The food was quite good, particularly the salad which was fresh and lemony. The empanada was coated in an almost Tajin-like powder, which was a little too strong for our tastes. The burger was ok value at $22, and was basically a Big Mac. I would come back for it, but I do wish it was on the happy hour menu. The happy hour doesn’t include a lot off the food menu, just some snacks. Cocktails were good, though the dirty martini wasn’t nearly as filthy as I like.

David Jang

Google
Having a midday coffee here right now. Coffee served to stay in a nice cocktail glass, guessing it’s typically for mulled wine(?). Feel very welcome even though I’m here solo. Bartender cool AF. Space beautiful. Multiple interesting design elements. Only showing photo of coffee to urge you to see the space yourself. Have had cocktails and food here in the past. Always good.

Jesse Field

Google
No table service, just sit and order from the bartender. We got fancy cocktails and brunch items. It’s funny to pay more for drinks than entree, but it makes sense at brunch, and we appreciated. Smokey mezcal and grapefruit drink was delicious, and my bacon egg cheese croissant was a hot mess of really good scrambled eggs and thick cut bacon. The croissant was drowned out, but that’s fine. I’m into bacon and eggs!

Jozef Watson

Google
Excellent little cocktail bar with great ambiance, drinks and food. Stopped in just before happy hour and it wasn't busy at all. Staff were friendly and quick to help with ordering. I got the spicy chicken sandwich with fries and Guilty of Everything drink. The sandwich had great flavor but I didn't think it was spicy at all. Fries were very crispy and delicious. Ketchup was smoky and unique. The drink was decent but I would try a different one when I come back. Great place overall to grab food and drinks.

Annabella Muller

Google
The place is really great! I went during happy hour with two friends, and we had a fantastic time. We enjoyed fries, a beet salad, and chicken sliders—all delicious. The only thing that bothered us a little was the noise, which made it hard to hear each other at times.

Melissa Fergusson

Google
Great drinks and food - came here on a drizzly cold Friday evening and the drinks and food hit the spot. I loved my drink the Search and Destroy, the truffle queso and the fried chicken sandwich. My husband had the Among Thieve drink and enjoyed it. The Mac and cheese was good - it was smoky which had a unique flavor but it was just a tad too salty for me. With just a bit less salt it would have been great. You do have to be a bit patient as you can only order at the bar but the bartenders are friendly and the vibe of the place is great!

Alon Grinshpoon

Google
This place is a great cocktails bar 🍸 and eatery! 🍴 Nobody Told Me serves an large selection of cocktails 🍹 and delicious 🤤 food items - definitely get the Slushee (ask for the flavor) and Truffle 🍄 Queso 🧀 which comes with root chips, baguette 🥖, and apple 🍎 slices! Thier burgers 🍔 also look great! Service is quick ⏲️ and the ambience 🎶 is fantastic! I wish I came here earlier!

Shachar Ashkenazi

Google
Great food and cocktails, really bad service. The bartender was also the only one who took orders, there was a 20 minutes line just to order because he had to make cocktails while other people were waiting to order. We ordered two dishes to share, one of them arrived after 20 minutes, the other arrived 15 minutes later which was pretty frustrating. Edit: we went again for the second time to give this place a chance, food was great as usual, service was great as well!