Proper Fish

Seafood restaurant · Bainbridge Island

Proper Fish

Seafood restaurant · Bainbridge Island

7

112 Madison Ave N, Bainbridge Island, WA 98110

Photos

Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by Nate Watters
Proper Fish by Nate Watters
Proper Fish by Nate Watters
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null

Highlights

Chill joint specializing in British-style fish ‘n chips & standard seafood fare with beer/wine.  

Featured in The Infatuation
Featured in Eater
Placeholder

112 Madison Ave N, Bainbridge Island, WA 98110 Get directions

properfish.com

Menu

Information

Static Map

112 Madison Ave N, Bainbridge Island, WA 98110 Get directions

+1 206 855 5051
properfish.com
ProperFishy

Menu

Features

dine in
wifi
payment credit card
Tap to pay
reservations

Last updated

Mar 29, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@infatuation

"One of the best orders of fish and chips in Seattle is actually a 35-minute ferry ride away on Bainbridge Island. The greatest thing about Proper Fish, though, is how enormous these entire filets of fried fish are—they’re around a foot long, with a puffy beer-battered crackle better than any state fair could achieve. That, plus tasty minted peas, thick-cut fries, and delicious tartar sauce, and there are plenty of reasons why we’d hop on a huge watercraft to grab these fish and chips." - aimee rizzo, kayla sager riley, gabe guarente

The 15 Best Fish & Chips In Seattle
View Postcard for Proper Fish
@eater

"The fish and chips at Bainbridge Island’s Proper Fish look exactly like what’s served at an English seaside pub: a twelve-inch cod served with thick-cut chips and a dollop of mushy peas. The only thing missing is the waterfront view. Luckily, the crispy batter will survive the five-minute walk down to the Waterfront Park, where diners can indulge in one of Seattle’s most traditional takes on the dish." - Nate Hall

Where to Get Fantastic Fish and Chips in the Seattle Area
View Postcard for Proper Fish
@infatuation

"The greatest thing about this British-style fish and chips spot is how enormous their filets of fried cod are—they’re around a foot long, with a puffy beer batter that's cracklier than anything produced by a state fair. That, plus tasty minted peas, thick-cut fries, and tangy tartar, and there are plenty of reasons why we’d hop on a huge watercraft to grab lunch here." - aimee rizzo, kayla sager riley

The 14 Best Restaurants & Bars On Bainbridge Island
View Postcard for Proper Fish
@eater

"Lunch alternative: At Proper Fish, one longer-than-imaginable piece of cod, perfectly fried with a light batter, makes for a massive meal with a side of French fries (a.k.a. “chips”) and a spot of mushy peas, all laid out “properly” on a sheet of newspaper in a basket." - Jay Friedman

Where to Eat in Bainbridge Island - Eater Seattle
View Postcard for Proper Fish
@infatuation

"One of the best orders of fish and chips in Seattle is actually a 35-minute ferry ride away on Bainbridge Island at Proper Fish. The greatest thing about this British spot, though, is how enormous their filets of fried cod are—they’re around a foot long, with a puffy beer batter that's cracklier than anything produced by a state fair. That, plus tasty minted peas, thick-cut fries, and tangy tartar, and there are plenty of reasons why we’d hop on a huge watercraft to grab lunch here." - Aimee Rizzo

Proper Fish - Review - Bainbridge Island - Seattle - The Infatuation
View Postcard for Proper Fish