7

Proper Fish

Seafood restaurant · Bainbridge Island ·

Proper Fish

Seafood restaurant · Bainbridge Island ·
@infatuation
132,814 Postcards · 3,234 Cities

Proper Fish - Review - Bainbridge Island - Seattle - The Infatuation

"One of the best orders of fish and chips in Seattle is actually a 35-minute ferry ride away on Bainbridge Island at Proper Fish. The greatest thing about this British spot, though, is how enormous their filets of fried cod are—they’re around a foot long, with a puffy beer batter that's cracklier than anything produced by a state fair. That, plus tasty minted peas, thick-cut fries, and tangy tartar, and there are plenty of reasons why we’d hop on a huge watercraft to grab lunch here." - Aimee Rizzo

https://www.theinfatuation.com/seattle/reviews/proper-fish
Nate Watters

Information

Gigantic fried fish and chips with crispy beer batter

fish and chips
huge portions
crispy fish
battered fish
flaky fish
mushy peas
clam chowder
lobster roll
Google Rating
4.4 (1.4K)
Yelp Rating
4.1
Rated 8.2 by The Infatuation
8.2
Featured in Eater
Featured in

112 Madison Ave N, Bainbridge Island, WA 98110 Get directions

$20–30

Order delivery
See Menu
Restroom
Accepts reservations
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Cozy
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by Nate Watters
Proper Fish by Nate Watters
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
See full details

7

Information

Gigantic fried fish and chips with crispy beer batter

fish and chips
huge portions
crispy fish
battered fish
flaky fish
mushy peas
clam chowder
lobster roll
Google Rating
4.4 (1.4K)
Yelp Rating
4.1
Rated 8.2 by The Infatuation
8.2
Featured in Eater
Featured in

112 Madison Ave N, Bainbridge Island, WA 98110 Get directions

$20–30

Order delivery
See Menu
Restroom
Accepts reservations
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Cozy
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by Nate Watters
Proper Fish by Nate Watters
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
Proper Fish by null
See full details

More Places For You

Café Hitchcock

Restaurant · Bainbridge Island

House-cured meats, sausages, hearty sandwiches, and coffee

20 Postcards

Via Rosa 11

Italian grocery store · Bainbridge Island

Wood-fired pizza, homemade pasta, and specialty Italian market items

5 Postcards

Bainbridge Brewing Alehouse

Brewery · Bainbridge Island

Craft beer, wine, cider, games, and snacks with indoor/outdoor seating

3 Postcards

Ba Sa Restaurant

Vietnamese restaurant · Bainbridge Island

Modern Vietnamese featuring pho, braised catfish & brunch

23 Postcards

The Eagle Harbor Inn a Boutique Hotel

Hotel · Bainbridge Island

Luxurious townhouses with harbor views & private elevators

1 Postcard

Mora Iced Creamery

Ice cream shop · Bainbridge Island

Homemade ice cream & sorbet with unique flavors, pints, shakes

2 Postcards

Coquette Bake Shop

Bakery · Bainbridge Island

Zest for Life pastry, French treats, sandwiches, coffee & bread

3 Postcards

Bruciato

Neapolitan restaurant · Bainbridge Island

Neapolitan-style pizza, grilled Italian fare & gelato

9 Postcards

Agate Restaurant

Bistro · Bainbridge Island

Seasonal bistro fare, cocktails, and wines in a quaint setting

1 Postcard

Jake's Pickup

American restaurant · Bainbridge Island

Organic sandwiches, espresso, and baked goods, made fresh.

2 Postcards