Rob W.
Yelp
I love Greek/Mediterranean food, and this simple, unassuming West Village gem serves it up with the best of them. In fact, the only complaint I can muster is the fact that this place has been here for years and I've never known about it!
First off, drink options are strong; I started with a Powers Sour (sour with Powers Irish whiskey) which was spot on, and had a glass of an excellent dry Greek white recommended by the server with dinner.
Started with a dip sampler--hard to skip that at a good Greek restaurant--and the selection was excellent--hummus had a surprisingly spicy kick to it, as did the delicious melitzanosalata. My friend enjoyed his Greek salad, which was appropriately very traditional, in that it does not have lettuce--just tomatoes, onion, cucumbers and feta. While I acknowledge this is the true Greek salad, this is not my personal preference, but nevertheless... made me know this was an authentic spot.
The entire menu looks fantastic, but for me the smaller seafood plates where it really where it was at, allowing us to try more of this spot's incredible dishes in one sitting--the shrimp Santorini with ouzo scented tomatoes felt like a small, seafood-based shakshuka--delicious on its own, and perfect for dipping your excess pita in! The Spanish octopus was incredible, as was the sautéed calamari with delicious gigantes beans in a garlic lemon broth.
The location is incredible, just one block off of busy seventh avenue, but you feel as if you are in another world on a quiet sidestreet. The addition of the current outdoor seating areas feels particularly sublime here, unlike on your busier streets. The service was fantastic (server there close to 20 years and had many good recs), and got to speak with the owner (my friend frequents the place) who was incredibly friendly. What a gem--again, I left almost annoyed it had been here for so long, but now I just have to make up for lost time and get back soon!