Valley Pearl Oysters

Based on previous review, we stopped into this quaint spot while traveling through the area. It did not disappoint although it was quiet based on our early afternoon visit, but staff Avery and Jenna were awesome and provided good hospitality and conversation at the bar. My husband was not disappointed with the large oysters and I enjoyed the mussels and fried oysters. A definite recommendation to visit if you are close by!

The best oysters we had during our three week tour of the maritimes. But also maybe the best oyster po-boy of all time. This place seems super unique - it isn’t going to win any design awards, with the dining room being in a dark barn area - they host dinner theater shows that people apparently come from all over PEI to see. The owner is passionate and creative and I wish everyone associated with the business the best — it made our trip!

Loved everything about this place! Great ambiance inside & outside, and all the food we had was excellent. You can even order oyster boxes to-go from the fishery located just downstairs - it can’t be more fresh than that. 200% worth the visit!

My girls and I stopped in and had dinner on Sunday evening after a random Google search showed us this restaurant. It’s our first time to PEI and I’ve got to tell you that every one of us has talked about this restaurant since. The food was amazing. I’m still thinking about my fish cakes! Just wanted to shout out our lovely server whose name I can’t remember, but she was on shift by herself and was doing an incredible job of balancing her very busy workload well still being so lovely and we appreciated her! Can’t wait to come back our next time in PEI.

NICE surroundings, GREAT service and EXCELLENT food! We always jump at the chance when we see fried oysters available and they did not disappoint. Started with a cup of seafood chowder which is loaded with a ton of seafood and has a nice consistency. Really should of just had the chowder for a meal, it was very filling. Entree was the fried oyster dinner with huge amount of french fries. Oysters were nice size and so fresh tasting. Breading not too heavy. Husband had the onion rings, also good. I forgot to take picture of our dessert which was a maple cheesecake I glass jar. It was sooo good. I think a local baker makes all their desserts. Everything on the menu sounded good. I wish we were here another day to try something else!

Honestly the best food we had on the island during our week long stay in North Rustico. Don't miss the fried quahogs!

Thomas is always so friendly & gives great recommendations & service! Everything we have had to eat there is exceptional! Keep up the great work Guys! Thanks! Sue & Dana very happy customers!

Amazing food and service! Trivia nights are great and the dinner theater is a must!